d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev11101111121131144498Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 35,291
Joined: Aug 17 2004
Gold: 12,730.67
Mar 7 2022 01:24pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Mar 7 2022 11:12am)
When you encourage normal people to make Molotov's and pick up AK's what do you think the natural consequences are going to be? You think Russian soldiers or tanks are not going to fire on someone simply because they aren't wearing a uniform if they are resisting?

That was the problem some of us were pointing to. The longer this goes on, the higher the probability of this looking like a real war instead of surgical strikes to weaken key military targets it was in the beginning.


That was always the plan after day 2....why would you think otherwise?

Civilians attacking fuel/supply trucks have been critical to the success that Ukraine has seen so far. It's not like anyone is forcing them to do it either....they WANT to do it for their country. Wouldn't you do the same if someone invaded America?
Member
Posts: 26,367
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 15,395.00
Mar 7 2022 01:29pm
Quote (thundercock @ Mar 7 2022 02:24pm)
That was always the plan after day 2....why would you think otherwise?

Civilians attacking fuel/supply trucks have been critical to the success that Ukraine has seen so far. It's not like anyone is forcing them to do it either....they WANT to do it for their country. Wouldn't you do the same if someone invaded America?


Every male 18-60 is not allowed to leave the country, many males across the country are being forced to go to hot zones as well. Also not sure what success you're referring to, what I see happening is something that would of happened fairly fast (Ukraine falling to Russia) is happening much slower with much more destruction and death.

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Mar 7 2022 01:29pm
Member
Posts: 1,775
Joined: Feb 2 2017
Gold: 945.00
Mar 7 2022 01:32pm
Quote (Goomshill @ Mar 7 2022 10:33am)
Another international angle is the Indian students who were in Ukraine studying abroad, which has obviously been a big deal for India. About 20,000 total. Many were evacuated through Poland already, about 16,000 and with many more flights en route. Some remain in Sumy. In the past few hours, Russia proposed opening yet another humanitarian corridor for civilians, this time exit routes leading east to Russia and Belarus from six major cities. Ukraine has rejected Russia's call for those humanitarian corridors and say they will not honor them, while demanding humanitarian corridors that lead to Lviv in the west.
Obviously Ukraine is not really in a position to dictate anything, Russia has them surrounded, and the move for these corridors is unilateral by Russia, but it also shows Ukraine's unwillingness to let any citizens escape to Russia or Belarus,
and they may be attacked by Ukraine while trying to flee.

Also worth noting that Wang Yi, foreign minister, just gave a speech declaring that China's support and friendship with Russia is "rock solid", signaling a willingness to broker any ceasefire.


Who in their right mind would want to flee to the side that is destroying your country and actively bombing, during the evacuation ?

Here is our very humane choice: either be blown up, or surrender to where the bombs come from.

This post was edited by Knoppie on Mar 7 2022 01:47pm
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Mar 7 2022 01:33pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ 7 Mar 2022 20:12)
When you encourage normal people to make Molotov's and pick up AK's what do you think the natural consequences are going to be? You think Russian soldiers or tanks are not going to fire on someone simply because they aren't wearing a uniform if they are resisting?

That was the problem some of us were pointing to. The longer this goes on, the higher the probability of this looking like a real war instead of surgical strikes to weaken key military targets it was in the beginning.


you mean like american cops are so trigger happy because every civilian is a potentially lethal threat since everyone could be armed? you're so close to a revelation there...
Member
Posts: 4,584
Joined: Jan 30 2021
Gold: 751.50
Mar 7 2022 01:39pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Mar 7 2022 07:32pm)
The European refugee crisis was driven by short-sighted idealism from the journalist and the activist classes, and by cynical opportunism among business leaders and industry-aligned politicians who thought they'd import a fresh batch of cheap labor. Take any of these groups out of the equation and the temporary pro-refugee-sentimentalism which prompted Merkel lose her fucking mind never materializes.

The current situaion is very different imho since the vast majority of corporations have nothing to gain from sanctions, soaring energy prices, the loss of a market and so on. Likewise, politicians have little to gain and a lot to lose if they lead their people into a winter (22/23) of freezing and hardship just to stick it to the Russians.

Regarding Zelensky: I might be wrong, but I think he's intentionally displaying unwavering resolve in his public appearances to keep morale of his troops and his people high. The way he constantly pleads for foreign help, however, shows that he's actually really desperate.


Side note: how the fuck could I butcher the word "wave" so badly I'm my previous post? Yikes.


dont forget the asylum industry that has established itself since 2015

it has literally become a business here to profit from having the country flooded with people

i have heard some politicians talking about integration courses already among other stuff for ukranians

the entire process from arrival to housing (whether actual houses or containers), food deliveries, security services, courses is set up to extract boatloads of taxpayer money

i know from a family member in the local police that they already dont know where to put all these people and deportations have been stopped, because the bureaucrats are needed elsewhere

well, we would have a lot of space, but unfortunately that is already occupied by all kinds of illegal fighting age migrants .....
Member
Posts: 35,291
Joined: Aug 17 2004
Gold: 12,730.67
Mar 7 2022 01:46pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Mar 7 2022 11:29am)
Every male 18-60 is not allowed to leave the country, many males across the country are being forced to go to hot zones as well. Also not sure what success you're referring to, what I see happening is something that would of happened fairly fast (Ukraine falling to Russia) is happening much slower with much more destruction and death.


There are a lot of resources I can point you to regarding Russian logistical failures, how the Russian military excels at some aspects of war and is crappy in others, etc. All of those can be corrected of course if there is will to do it. The question is, do they? It took them over a year to mobilize ~200k troops, supplies, vehicles, etc. to the border. Is Russia going to institute a draft? How is Putin going to sell it? Is Russia going to transition to a war time economy and dedicate resources to the war over everything else? If Russia decides to ignore civilian casualties, what are the odds that countries start sending non-military aircraft to give aid to the cities? Will Russians shoot those planes down too? There are A LOT of variable to consider here.

The fact that Ukraine is still standing, how Russians struggle to hold territory (duh, they don't have enough troops, they need to increase it 5 fold), etc. IS success from Ukraine's perspective. The attacker is almost always at a significant disadvantage and sieges of major cities can often take years.
Member
Posts: 51,672
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 31,169.00
Warn: 10%
Mar 7 2022 01:55pm
Quote (fender @ Mar 7 2022 07:33pm)
you mean like american cops are so trigger happy because every civilian is a potentially lethal threat since everyone could be armed? you're so close to a revelation there...


this comment was pretty good!
Member
Posts: 26,367
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 15,395.00
Mar 7 2022 01:58pm
Quote (thundercock @ Mar 7 2022 02:46pm)
There are a lot of resources I can point you to regarding Russian logistical failures, how the Russian military excels at some aspects of war and is crappy in others, etc. All of those can be corrected of course if there is will to do it. The question is, do they? It took them over a year to mobilize ~200k troops, supplies, vehicles, etc. to the border. Is Russia going to institute a draft? How is Putin going to sell it? Is Russia going to transition to a war time economy and dedicate resources to the war over everything else? If Russia decides to ignore civilian casualties, what are the odds that countries start sending non-military aircraft to give aid to the cities? Will Russians shoot those planes down too? There are A LOT of variable to consider here.

The fact that Ukraine is still standing, how Russians struggle to hold territory (duh, they don't have enough troops, they need to increase it 5 fold), etc. IS success from Ukraine's perspective. The attacker is almost always at a significant disadvantage and sieges of major cities can often take years.


I don't doubt this is a thing but I just don't think it's indicative what will happen over the long term. It's focusing on the trees rather than the forest. I think Russia expected (like some of us did) that Ukraine's military forces would fold and start running, and this hasn't happened to the extent to which they thought they would.

I also don't think them taking their time to put those troops into place is indicative of anything really important, rather than they wanted to see if simply by display of force and numbers was enough to get the Ukrainians to agree to recognize the eastern region autonomy and not join NATO. Once that didn't work they actually pulled the trigger on the invasion. Right now, 200k is like what 1/5? of Russia's active military personnel, and i think they have a few million in reservists, so don't think a draft is coming.

Who knows how long this will drag out, I think Russia underestimated the cost but at this point they're too dedicated to the cause to pull back.

I also don't really know what's a good gage to consider something a success vs a failure? Like this is a week old war, and they have the capital surrounded? I think success/failure here is relative and of course we in the west would want it to seem like a complete failure, but objectively speaking, to have your forces basically ready to assault the capital in less than a week is a success story in any war that i've read about.

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Mar 7 2022 02:04pm
Member
Posts: 8,545
Joined: Oct 4 2021
Gold: 281.64
Mar 7 2022 02:14pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ 7 Mar 2022 11:29)
what I see happening is something that would of happened fairly fast (Ukraine falling to Russia) is happening much slower with much more destruction and death.


I don't have a dog in this fight, but its hard to get good information about what is happening. Take vietnam/afganistan for example. The United States reported they were in full control, and the other side would speak to the opposite.

Its hard to quantify if they are, or not slowing them down - we won't know for years until AARs get leaked/declassified. Russia's objectives might just be search and destroy of military targets and the assassination of the UA government instead of an actual conquest of all of eastern Ukraine. Its hard to say what sides goals are, and how to measure them.

This post was edited by Cascadian on Mar 7 2022 02:20pm
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Mar 7 2022 02:18pm
Quote (Cascadian @ 7 Mar 2022 21:14)
I don't have a dog in this fight, but its hard to get good information about what is happening. Take vietnam/afganistan for example. The United States reported they were in full control, and the other side would speak to the opposite.

Its hard to quantify if they are, or not slowing them down - we won't know for years until AARs get leaked/declassified. Russia's objectives might just be search and destroy of military targets and the assassination of the UK government instead of an actual conquest of all of eastern Ukraine. Its hard to say what sides goals are, and how to measure them.




This post was edited by fender on Mar 7 2022 02:18pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev11101111121131144498Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll