Quote (thundercock @ Oct 8 2019 02:00pm)
That's a very odd way of looking at it lol. The AH was terrible because everyone got their gear from there as opposed to in-game. The loot system was fundamentally broken and that was addressed in Loot 2.0. The D3 launch was also fucking horrible. Sure, they made A LOT of cash, but the experience was just awful. I think most Blizz employees saw D3 as a massive failure in game design.
i guess it's a bit hard to pick apart because everything that i say "worked" had it's issues.
in the start of the game they had a stable currency, gold. it wasn't easy to get, it was how all items on the RMAH were priced, etc. everyone needed it.
yes people did instantly gear up chars sometimes, but who had the gold to truly gear out a decent char? you bought a shitty echoing fury, a random unique for every slot, then went back to playing the game and farming. you got just good enough gear to farm. that's fundamentally what D2 is. people log on 12 hours after ladder reset, buy a spirit, rhyme, stealth, and start farming.
the real problem here was the ease to hit high/max level. people bought too much gear because leveling was easy, make leveling harder and you'll stagnate the buyouts.
the other problem we're not really touching on here is the lack of coherent game. it became mini games, rifts, events, etc. obviously that's kind of what D2 is. cows, baals, diablo, etc. BUT if you want to play the game you can, it's coherant act to act, difficulty to difficulty. chop that out and you lose a part of the population. for every baal game there's a game of kids still questing the game, even in 2019. its nuts.
they have a successful model. take the number of "ok", "good", "really good", "godly", and "super godly" items a player can find in a 100 hour window of farming diablo 2. build your loot table around that ratio. it's worked for decades in keeping players engaged. then add a GOLD auction house with no ability to buy gold for $$. basically a D2 economy, with out the d2jsp middle man. in 2019 d2 and d2jsp are synonymous. perhaps 1/100 players dont use jsp. then work in pvp in a world setting, not some private dueling room.
all anyone wants is an updated D2. adding in AH is optional, as we can just use jsp if they don't.
but overall i REALLY liked the first 3-4 months of D3. like a lot. then it was just shit.