d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > New Option "sold" On Trade Topics
Prev123410Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 16,604
Joined: Jul 29 2010
Gold: 10,687.34
Warn: 90%
Apr 7 2021 09:32am
Quote (Negan @ 7 Apr 2021 08:22)
It takes 3 seconds to sellers click sold

and save alot of time to buyers


It takes less time to let the topic die like half the other trades on the site. If you want to update the list to t4t, done, sold, etc so that you feel you are a better trader than the next than do so. If all trade deals are done following the rules you should not need to constantly update a trade list to done but rather follow all the trades.

In addition to "Done" as much as you are saying it may save time you are essentially bypassing the GM Opportunity for people to say t4t, update the trade list, and more.

I see Done being used for laziness and thus causing less quality control of each individual user and on a larger site basis. I think it takes away from people having an opportunity to engage themselves in their trades. Rinse and repeat. It could get boring.

Voted no.
Member
Posts: 44,182
Joined: Feb 12 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Apr 7 2021 09:35am
Quote (Sempervirens @ 7 Apr 2021 17:32)
It takes less time to let the topic die like half the other trades on the site. If you want to update the list to t4t, done, sold, etc so that you feel you are a better trader than the next than do so. If all trade deals are done following the rules you should not need to constantly update a trade list to done but rather follow all the trades.

In addition to "Done" as much as you are saying it may save time you are essentially bypassing the GM Opportunity for people to say t4t, update the trade list, and more.

I see Done being used for laziness and thus causing less quality control of each individual user and on a larger site basis. I think it takes away from people having an opportunity to engage themselves in their trades. Rinse and repeat. It could get boring.

Voted no.


Its called Suggestion

would like at least read more opinions

I know u voted no you said 2 times

This post was edited by Negan on Apr 7 2021 09:35am
Member
Posts: 16,604
Joined: Jul 29 2010
Gold: 10,687.34
Warn: 90%
Apr 7 2021 09:40am
Quote (Negan @ 7 Apr 2021 08:35)
Its called Suggestion

would like at least read more opinions

I know u voted no you said 2 times


I understand. The suggestion would have an impact on nearly every single user on the site. I am trying to think about the cause and effect of what your suggestion would to do the site both on an individual user and as the site in whole, both for the present and the future.



This post was edited by Sempervirens on Apr 7 2021 09:40am
Member
Posts: 44,182
Joined: Feb 12 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Apr 7 2021 09:42am
Quote (Sempervirens @ 7 Apr 2021 17:40)
I understand. The suggestion would have an impact on nearly every single user on the site. I am trying to think about the cause and effect of what your suggestion would to do the site both on an individual user and as the site in whole, both for the present and the future.


I pmed about 30 users this week for items already sold

I think is enough at least try suggestion :)

This post was edited by Negan on Apr 7 2021 09:42am
Trade Moderator
Posts: 20,713
Joined: Sep 9 2012
Gold: 191,473.00
Trader: Trusted
Apr 7 2021 09:43am
Could you elaborate a little more on this please? Would the thread show up in the search feature after its been marked as done or would it have a special flag showing done?
Member
Posts: 16,604
Joined: Jul 29 2010
Gold: 10,687.34
Warn: 90%
Apr 7 2021 09:44am
Quote (Negan @ 7 Apr 2021 08:42)
I pmed about 30 users this week for items already sold

I think is enough at least try suggestion :)


If you are PM trading, which is not how we are supposed to do things, then I don't see the need for you to announce to the public you made your trade. Let the topic die or edit it. You are already taking extra time trading VIA PM.

This post was edited by Sempervirens on Apr 7 2021 09:44am
Member
Posts: 44,182
Joined: Feb 12 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Apr 7 2021 09:46am
Quote (Greenbay_Fan @ 7 Apr 2021 17:43)
Could you elaborate a little more on this please? Would the thread show up in the search feature after its been marked as done or would it have a special flag showing done?


Will try make pic how to do it

But idea will be Click sold and autoedit your First text on thread

so u dont get +1 extra post

Quote (Sempervirens @ 7 Apr 2021 17:44)
If you are PM trading, which is not how we are supposed to do things, then I don't see the need for you to announce to the public you made your trade. Let the topic die or edit it. You are already taking extra time trading VIA PM.


On pd2 99,9% ppl trade via pm to avoid ban on game

This post was edited by Negan on Apr 7 2021 09:46am
Member
Posts: 17,384
Joined: Mar 14 2007
Gold: 31,132.00
Apr 7 2021 09:48am
100% yes.

Especially for not very common Items/rune words, when I don’t put T4t or so, people still pm me, when they do search... would be much easier for both sellers and buyers (searchers)
Member
Posts: 16,604
Joined: Jul 29 2010
Gold: 10,687.34
Warn: 90%
Apr 7 2021 09:50am
Quote (Negan @ 7 Apr 2021 08:46)
Will try make pic how to do it

But idea will be Click sold and autoedit your First text on thread



On p2d 99,9% ppl trade via pm to avoid ban on game



Auto Edit First Text on thread is getting interesting. This would allow for not only "done" but other buttons.

The site does not just support p2d. I understand their are some white lines when it comes to trading safety with some games here but in the end rules are rules. Since this would happen site wide I can't ignore the rest of the site because of p2d. Maybe if this suggestion was to get implemented it could be implemented for certain parts of the forums, much like how requesting a trade meditator works.
Member
Posts: 44,182
Joined: Feb 12 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Apr 7 2021 09:53am
Quote (Sempervirens @ 7 Apr 2021 17:50)
Auto Edit First Text on thread is getting interesting. This would allow for not only "done" but other buttons.

The site does not just support p2d. I understand their are some white lines when it comes to trading safety with some games here but in the end rules are rules. Since this would happen site wide I can't ignore the rest of the site because of p2d. Maybe if this suggestion was to get implemented it could be implemented for certain parts of the forums, much like how requesting a trade meditator works.


Glad at least now sound ok for you :)

Now have to work on idea with pics :love:
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
Prev123410Next
Closed New Topic New Poll