d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby > Aaron Rodgers
Prev15678Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 867Replies: 75Track Topic
Member
Posts: 72,078
Joined: May 31 2008
Gold: 3,500.80
#61
Jan 26 2021 01:13pm
Quote (4killer7 @ Jan 26 2021 01:12pm)
Foster never played AGAINST brady, so a handful of people must mean Rodgers is the GOAT.


Rodger's isn't close to brady idk how there is any point arguing this. Mahomes is already about to take his spot over Rodgers as well. Would probably take Peyton and Brees over Rodgers as well. And those are just the QBs I have watched in my lifetime, this doesn't include Montana / Marino / Young


I would take Case Keenum over Kirk's Cousin
Member
Posts: 42,863
Joined: Oct 9 2010
Gold: 10.55
#62
Jan 26 2021 01:28pm
Quote (4killer7 @ Jan 26 2021 11:12am)
Foster never played AGAINST brady, so a handful of people must mean Rodgers is the GOAT.


Rodger's isn't close to brady idk how there is any point arguing this. Mahomes is already about to take his spot over Rodgers as well. Would probably take Peyton and Brees over Rodgers as well. And those are just the QBs I have watched in my lifetime, this doesn't include Montana / Marino / Young


In my opinion, as of right now, i take Brees as my pick for goat (until Mahomes eventually passes them both). When i think of greatness i dont think of championships, but rather talent and position specific accomplishments. Brees tops Brady in yards (+~900), and Completion% (+3.7%). Brady does top Brees is TD's by 10. But i gotta give it to Brees as he did all of this without being part of a dynasty with one of if not the greatest coach of all time. Championships arent won by one player they won by a team, so i personally dont consider bradys rings an end-all-be-all measure of his greatness as a qb.

And certainly rodgers isnt close

This post was edited by VAS3CT0MY on Jan 26 2021 01:30pm
Member
Posts: 72,078
Joined: May 31 2008
Gold: 3,500.80
#63
Jan 26 2021 01:36pm
Quote (VAS3CT0MY @ Jan 26 2021 01:28pm)
In my opinion, as of right now, i take Brees as my pick for goat (until Mahomes eventually passes them both). When i think of greatness i dont think of championships, but rather talent and position specific accomplishments. Brees tops Brady in yards (+~900), and Completion% (+3.7%). Brady does top Brees is TD's by 10. But i gotta give it to Brees as he did all of this without being part of a dynasty with one of if not the greatest coach of all time. Championships arent won by one player they won by a team, so i personally dont consider bradys rings an end-all-be-all measure of his greatness as a qb.

And certainly rodgers isnt close


Bree's played in his little dome for 9+ games every season for the last 14 years. Sorry. I can't crown someone who has a majority of their stats coming from playing in perfect conditions. Hate on Brady if you want, but playing in Foxborough in December and January is a lot more difficult than chilling in a dome. If you're only going to judge based on records and stats, think about the weight of those numbers and how they were accumulated.
Member
Posts: 32,646
Joined: Jun 28 2017
Gold: 3,059.01
Warn: 10%
#64
Jan 26 2021 02:19pm
Quote (VAS3CT0MY @ Jan 26 2021 02:28pm)
In my opinion, as of right now, i take Brees as my pick for goat (until Mahomes eventually passes them both). When i think of greatness i dont think of championships, but rather talent and position specific accomplishments. Brees tops Brady in yards (+~900), and Completion% (+3.7%). Brady does top Brees is TD's by 10. But i gotta give it to Brees as he did all of this without being part of a dynasty with one of if not the greatest coach of all time. Championships arent won by one player they won by a team, so i personally dont consider bradys rings an end-all-be-all measure of his greatness as a qb.

And certainly rodgers isnt close



You gotta be trollin with this one man
Member
Posts: 18,435
Joined: Jun 15 2008
Gold: 28,610.66
#65
Jan 26 2021 02:21pm
Quote (Gilly @ Jan 26 2021 02:13pm)
I would take Case Keenum over Kirk's Cousin


I would too.... I would too.

Jk Keenum sucks Kirk is just ever so slightly above average.

I do miss that prime 2017 defense though


I am forseeing a tale as old as time now where the vikings end up with Rodgers on the tail end of his career much like farve, only to continue the never ending cycle of finding a true franchise QB

This post was edited by 4killer7 on Jan 26 2021 02:23pm
Member
Posts: 32,646
Joined: Jun 28 2017
Gold: 3,059.01
Warn: 10%
#66
Jan 26 2021 02:28pm
Quote (4killer7 @ Jan 26 2021 03:21pm)
I would too.... I would too.

Jk Keenum sucks Kirk is just ever so slightly above average.

I do miss that prime 2017 defense though


I am forseeing a tale as old as time now where the vikings end up with Rodgers on the tail end of his career much like farve, only to continue the never ending cycle of finding a true franchise QB


They won’t get past Staffords bears
Member
Posts: 18,435
Joined: Jun 15 2008
Gold: 28,610.66
#67
Jan 26 2021 02:38pm
Quote (Article @ Jan 26 2021 03:28pm)
They won’t get past Staffords bears


Honestly they won't trade stafford in the division, will most likely be the colts / patriots / 49ers that land staffgod
Member
Posts: 32,646
Joined: Jun 28 2017
Gold: 3,059.01
Warn: 10%
#68
Jan 26 2021 02:59pm
Quote (4killer7 @ Jan 26 2021 03:38pm)
Honestly they won't trade stafford in the division, will most likely be the colts / patriots / 49ers that land staffgod



Washington?
Member
Posts: 18,435
Joined: Jun 15 2008
Gold: 28,610.66
#69
Jan 26 2021 03:10pm
Quote (Article @ Jan 26 2021 03:59pm)
Washington?


good point, washington could be an answer as well, I guess there are quite a few teams that could be in the market. Bears could be in the market but ya I'd have to imagine like the Texans keeping Watson outside of the division the lions would do the same
Member
Posts: 42,863
Joined: Oct 9 2010
Gold: 10.55
#70
Jan 26 2021 03:10pm
Quote (Gilly @ Jan 26 2021 11:36am)
Bree's played in his little dome for 9+ games every season for the last 14 years. Sorry. I can't crown someone who has a majority of their stats coming from playing in perfect conditions. Hate on Brady if you want, but playing in Foxborough in December and January is a lot more difficult than chilling in a dome. If you're only going to judge based on records and stats, think about the weight of those numbers and how they were accumulated.


fair enough, i honestly never even considered weather. Tbh i have no idea why i didnt.
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
Prev15678Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2024 d2jsp  Contact