Quote (Kimtown @ Oct 17 2017 03:36am)
What? I'm not gonna bother reading all that but it seems it's arguing against hot/cold.
You've obviously never played basketball or shot one before. Getting into a perfect routine rhythm where you are constantly shooting consistently well is considered 'hot', and well the opposite is 'cold'
It's definitely a thing.
I was cold as fuck in my game last night. Nothing was falling, shooting form was WAY off. A few months ago I was like 7/8 from 3 and almost perfect from the field. I would consider that hot.
Quote (LeDaddy @ Oct 17 2017 03:43am)
How can you be "hot" if you're less likely to make your next shot after every one you make?
@the ad hominem attack, it truly is sad that I trust empirical studies done by others to form opinions rather than doing all empirical studies myself and only formulating opinions on the basis on studies I myself have done or things I have directly experienced :(
You might both be right, you just operate with different definitions of "hot hand" (and some confirmation bias). The feeling is definitely there, yet it doesn't show up statistically. Why?
The following studys might give us some ideas:
1: You're more likely to miss your next shot because the defence adapts, giving you more attention (Raab, Markus; Gula, Bartosz; Gigerenzer, Gerd (2012). "Raab, M., Gula, B., & Gigerenzer, G. (2011)". Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied). The same article confirms that the hot hand exists in Volleyball (where defences cannot shift their attention towards an individual to the same degree).
2: You're attempting shots with a higher difficulty when you're hot (LeDaddys own linked-to deadspin article).
So you'll make shots you otherwise wouldn't hit because you're hot, but you offset that "hotness" due to shot selection. If the defence doesn't honor you, and you keep your shot selection, you should in theory be able to ride the hot hand.
Likewise when you're cold: Players tend to cheat in defence, overhelping, opening up higher quality shots when you're cold. Thus you have a higher probability to make the shot.
You do feel hot when you make that contested step-back 3. On the other hand you do feel cold when you miss wide open Js.
For free throws the hot hand, statistically, seems to exist (Yaari, G.; Eisenmann, S. (2011). "The Hot (Invisible?) Hand: Can Time Sequence Patterns of Success/Failure in Sports Be Modeled as Repeated Random Independent Trials?")
Maybe we could all be friends now? No? Was afraid so