Draisaitl>McDavid
8.5M AAV>12.5M AAV (Actually 15M w/ Bonus Structure)
Contract Locked 24-25>Contract Locked 25-26
McDavid averaging 32% more earnings based off 12.5M AAV
McDavid averaging 44% more earnings based off 15M AAV
Draisaitl takes twice as many faceoffs with a better winning percentage, his shooting percentage is almost twice as good as McDavids, he spends more Time On Ice, He has 4 more Game Winning Goals, he has 5 more Powerplay Goals, he spends more time on the ice Short Handed.
By the numbers and what you get.... Draisaitl is the better hockey player and worth more to the team.
Draisaitl is charismatic/funny... McDavid is vanilla vanilla, with more vanilla with awesome highlight reels?
These are just facts.
I'll take Draisaitl for 8.5M