What Genre defines the selection?
Example: There are 218+ "Isekai" to select "Top 50", however some of them have a season or more BEFORE 2018.
Hmm, what now... what about Titans? (whatever the title is, but the story is based on people getting eaten by Titans etc)
I like the idea... I would also think a minimum of five(5) different Genre and 50 listed, then you can take those 250 and minimize the selection by how many of them fit two(2)+ different genre out of the 5 selected.
Example:
Action
Magic
Sci Fi
Isekai
... ???