Makes me feel old AF. Remember talking about a lot those guys on here when they were just starting out.

Anyways, IMO I think beltre is the only one who gets in on the first time list. possibly first ballot HOFer.

Time flies by man
Baseball forum popped off 2010-2020 or so
Totally dead now :/

I agree with Beltre. He will get in 1st ballot.
A-Rod would have, but the juice…..lmao

Helton and Wagner should make it in this time.

Of the guys below 20%, I think only Pettitte has a chance and that’s going to take forever….unlikely.

Gonzo, Wright, Holliday, Reyes, Bautista, Victor Martinez, Shields, Phillips and Colon will never make it. Chase Utley probably on the same boat, but I give him a slightly better chance. Still don’t see him making it.

Mauer will eventually.

This post was edited by ZxFamily-GuyxZ on Nov 25 2023 10:07pm

Beltre should be a lock.

Helton should already be in. I could see them not ever letting Mauer in just because he had such a short prime due to his position/injuries. Same with Posey when he's eligible.

If Mauer played 1B his whole career I think he could have put up monster numbers. 3k hits could have been a possibility. He was that good.

3x world series champ, 7 time allstar, nl mvp, nl roty, gold glover, 5x silver slugger, nl batting champ..... if u dont think posey is getting in to the hof your high/the hof is fuckin broken