d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Baseball > Philadelphia Phillies Team Thread
Prev1158159160161162169Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 44,599
Joined: Feb 28 2008
Gold: 218.00
Apr 22 2026 08:09pm
I disagree with that. Crawford looks very good and is a future anchor in center. Overpaying for a mediocre at best player like Bader wasn't necessary just to block Crawford from getting his chance.

Bader had a nice run in a contract year but that's far from his normal. Look what he's doing now in SF....notta


Aren't there two other positions in the outfield?

Can't really compare him to what he's doing in SF. He just fit here. Sometimes you just need guys that fit.

Did you forget he hit 258 with the twins before the trade during that same contract year lol

This post was edited by Fgs on Apr 22 2026 08:10pm
Member
Posts: 149,933
Joined: Apr 19 2005
Gold: 0.11
Apr 22 2026 08:48pm
Aren't there two other positions in the outfield?

Can't really compare him to what he's doing in SF. He just fit here. Sometimes you just need guys that fit.

Did you forget he hit 258 with the twins before the trade during that same contract year lol


2025 was an outlier for Bader. He is not that good of a player, and will never be that good of a player. Loved his personality and all, but he wouldn't be doing shit either.

Marsh is better (and younger/cheaper), and Garcia while not doing great this season has had highs in his career that are elite not to mention he's only a 1 year deal while Bader was 2 years guaranteed. Not sure there's really much to miss with Bader, he's not moving the needle and committing to him for $10+M a year for multiple years would just set the team back even more.

This post was edited by Sixers on Apr 22 2026 08:51pm
Member
Posts: 44,599
Joined: Feb 28 2008
Gold: 218.00
Apr 22 2026 10:03pm
2025 was an outlier for Bader. He is not that good of a player, and will never be that good of a player. Loved his personality and all, but he wouldn't be doing shit either.

Marsh is better (and younger/cheaper), and Garcia while not doing great this season has had highs in his career that are elite not to mention he's only a 1 year deal while Bader was 2 years guaranteed. Not sure there's really much to miss with Bader, he's not moving the needle and committing to him for $10+M a year for multiple years would just set the team back even more.


Pedro Feliz wasn't either. Yet he just fit perfectly with that WS team.

You don't need to be a world beater. Some players just galvanized the fan base and other team members. They don't have to hit .300 to be worth the money. Bader brought life to this team, which is currently lifeless
Member
Posts: 149,933
Joined: Apr 19 2005
Gold: 0.11
Apr 22 2026 10:39pm
Pedro Feliz wasn't either. Yet he just fit perfectly with that WS team.

You don't need to be a world beater. Some players just galvanized the fan base and other team members. They don't have to hit .300 to be worth the money. Bader brought life to this team, which is currently lifeless


Batting average is kinda irrelevant these days though. Well, not irrelevant but far down the list of ways to tell how well a good is producing offensively. Schwarber hit .240 last season and was one of the absolute elite hitters in all of MLB (hence the 2nd place MVP finish as a DH). There's a lot more that goes into it and nothing about Bader's career, at 31 years old, stands out as a guy that is moving the needle or producing at a high level. Last season only 7 guys hit .300 in all of MLB, which was the fewest ever tied with 2024 lol.

Great vibes guy, sure. But they aren't missing anything. Him and Casty both suck for their new teams.

This post was edited by Sixers on Apr 22 2026 10:40pm
Member
Posts: 149,933
Joined: Apr 19 2005
Gold: 0.11
Apr 22 2026 11:10pm
Phillies now own the longest losing streak in the league at 8 games.

Worst run differential in baseball as well.

Good thing the 76ers and Flyers are having some success. This is UGLY 🫠
Member
Posts: 149,933
Joined: Apr 19 2005
Gold: 0.11
Apr 23 2026 12:45pm
Walker released :rolleyes:
Member
Posts: 44,599
Joined: Feb 28 2008
Gold: 218.00
Apr 23 2026 07:52pm
Batting average is kinda irrelevant these days though. Well, not irrelevant but far down the list of ways to tell how well a good is producing offensively. Schwarber hit .240 last season and was one of the absolute elite hitters in all of MLB (hence the 2nd place MVP finish as a DH). There's a lot more that goes into it and nothing about Bader's career, at 31 years old, stands out as a guy that is moving the needle or producing at a high level. Last season only 7 guys hit .300 in all of MLB, which was the fewest ever tied with 2024 lol.

Great vibes guy, sure. But they aren't missing anything. Him and Casty both suck for their new teams.


Good thing that's a regular season reward. Over 162 games, I'll take a bopper like shwarber all day. But in limited games against significantly better pitching on the playoffs, I want guys who can sting together hits.

Hrs are much harder to come by in the postseason.

How well did shwarbers regular season success translate to postseason success last year or the year before?

Member
Posts: 46,224
Joined: May 8 2017
Gold: 610.01
Warn: 40%
Apr 24 2026 08:13pm
10
In
A
Row

:rofl:
Member
Posts: 149,933
Joined: Apr 19 2005
Gold: 0.11
Apr 25 2026 08:10am
LOL

Can't do anything but laugh at this point.

Member
Posts: 33,964
Joined: Dec 26 2008
Gold: 6,200.00
Apr 25 2026 10:18am
LOL

Can't do anything but laugh at this point.

https://i.imgur.com/JXWXRYx.jpeg


When you hit rock bottom, the only way is up
Go Back To Baseball Topic List
Prev1158159160161162169Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll