d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2: Resurrected > D2:R Discussion > Whirlwind Attack Speed? Aoe Or Not?
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 164
Joined: Sep 28 2011
Gold: 277.00
Apr 21 2026 08:11pm
Should it deal aoe damage or continue to hit once at a time?
Member
Posts: 2,367
Joined: Jun 23 2016
Gold: 2,087.00
Apr 21 2026 08:31pm
imo, it should take on cleave's functionality. have two 180 cones with a radius of weapon range. every 4 frames it alternates the cone, hits every monster in that cone. also alternates the weapon, so 2h is just more dmg outright than dual wield. then 2h can be justified to be 5 frames.

This post was edited by Kabryxis on Apr 21 2026 08:32pm
Member
Posts: 1,248
Joined: May 28 2007
Gold: 4,412.60
Apr 21 2026 08:31pm
It is fine as is but it should just be a fixed attack speed. That would open up so many weapon options.
Member
Posts: 831
Joined: Jul 5 2017
Gold: 36,038.00
Apr 21 2026 08:46pm
I think it having a chance to hit (based on ar per monster) as an aoe is the way to go, anything in the weapons defined range. It would make the skill actually function the way youd think it should. the whole reason ww currently feels bad is because it can only hit 1 monster at any given time. so when you whirl through a large pack all that damage is getting split all over the place, which makes short range weapons king because it helps reduce the amount of monsters in range to divide that dmg up. this makes large range 2 handers feel absolutely terrible. in no universe should it feel bad having an eth 2 handed botd trying to ww even with hitting max ias fpa.

This post was edited by rPhase on Apr 21 2026 08:47pm
Member
Posts: 164
Joined: Sep 28 2011
Gold: 277.00
Apr 21 2026 08:51pm
imo, it should take on cleave's functionality. have two 180 cones with a radius of weapon range. every 4 frames it alternates the cone, hits every monster in that cone. also alternates the weapon, so 2h is just more dmg outright than dual wield. then 2h can be justified to be 5 frames.


TBH, I think this games running on the same engine it did 20 years ago. Cleave is a pretty easy thing to simulate by throwing out small aoe in a 5-15 degree radius. THE FACT WW still just deals damage in sequence makes me think they didn't know how to fix it. If they had do add splash damage to each hit. I think it'd work in the engine.

Member
Posts: 7,895
Joined: Jun 15 2017
Gold: 104.67
Apr 21 2026 08:53pm
BuT bArB CAn HoRk p1 TrAv they really good 🤡 :bonk:

This post was edited by BdizzleD2 on Apr 21 2026 08:55pm
Member
Posts: 29,516
Joined: May 26 2014
Gold: 420.69
Warn: 20%
Apr 21 2026 09:45pm
Make it like classic WW

Member
Posts: 2,795
Joined: Jul 19 2016
Gold: 151,390.00
Apr 21 2026 10:11pm
Make it like classic WW


yes please, would open up all sorts of options which is cool!
Member
Posts: 29,516
Joined: May 26 2014
Gold: 420.69
Warn: 20%
Apr 21 2026 10:15pm
yes please, would open up all sorts of options which is cool!



Yup max dmg 2h go brrrrrr

Member
Posts: 3,639
Joined: Aug 18 2021
Gold: 32,990.00
Apr 21 2026 10:43pm
Fixed frames like classic + trigger on hit effects.
Go Back To D2:R Discussion Topic List
Add Reply New Topic New Poll