We brought up a lot in the various threads that ES has an edge in those super astronomically high HP monsters like heralds/ubers/baal while BB clears other stuff ultra fast, but there's still an honest question about whether ES is even optimal in those cases. Specifically because you have to swap gear or risk dying to baal's chilling armor as an actual threatening spell, ie must wear black oak luna, and the issue where either you must use a bone break and have some significant reducing in EHP or you deal piddly damage to physical immune heralds. Though the fact bone break makes amp/sigil apply 100% of their effect means immunes will be at ~-40% dr and die fast, it is a bit of a drawback for normal pvm. Still not a big deal because of blood oath and consume and the stupid high amounts of EHP a warlock has anyway. I think these are very minor grievances for an ES build, but they are little speed bumps nonetheless
Also the mana issue is another minor gripe, BB uses half the mana per cast and regains twice as much from siphon, its so generous on mana you can get away with no insight and feel mostly fine. ES needs that meditation aura critically, and even with it, if you miss casts in a bad direction like shooting at a wall by mistake you can drain your bulb fast.
Disagree with insight, aside from my first 99 lock (who used insight weapon) - I haven't needed insight on an ES or BB lock on their journeys to 99. Siphon and a little mana leech is all that was needed to keep the blue bulb full. Occasional use of a mana pot if in an area with tons of skeletons like stony tomb or something, but even then, there were usually enough zombies to leech from.
Lumping ubers in with heralds and baal seems disingenuous (unless I'm misunderstanding your point), as ubers aren't part of a regular whole game clear (unless you get amazingly lucky with statues I suppose) - it would be every third game at the absolute luckiest, if you get a key from each boss on each game (unless you get triple key drops 3 times...then I guess you can do it in 1 game).
Furthermore, while ubers with BB is possible, and kind of fun using their summons against them, echoing makes easy work of them very quickly. Uber ancients with BB is brutal...would be faster to grush up a new ES warlock and take them down with the new char once you put on some basic equipment lol. In both cases, BB and ES, nothing more is needed for safety than the usual pre-buff and swap out some mf pieces for res/absorb gear (ie nagel for ravenfrost).
If you factor in all these other expanded content, then echoing is much better and faster, but again, if you're just clearing certain high density, low hp areas, BB has the edge.
But most importantly, at the end of the day, both are good builds! Still might want an echo lock or smiter for ubers/ancients though lol
This post was edited by FoldersUnite on Apr 6 2026 06:08pm