d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Israel - Gaza Peace Deal
Prev1232425262737Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 5,523
Joined: Feb 10 2006
Gold: 3,315.00
Oct 27 2025 02:18am
No you don't get to just brush over the shootings of children by IDF soldiers like they face some sort of dilemma. There are snipers in IDF that deliberately target children and if you say they don't what threat did a 4 year old girl who got shot in the head pose to an Israeli sniper?


You should in your same paragraph call out all of Hamas wrongdoings towards children too then. Don’t just focus on what pushes your narrative - be honest.
Member
Posts: 5,523
Joined: Feb 10 2006
Gold: 3,315.00
Oct 27 2025 02:20am
If you guys actually care about children, don’t just use them when it’s convenient for your argument - be about it.
Member
Posts: 4,157
Joined: Dec 22 2004
Gold: 1,217.00
Oct 27 2025 02:33am
You should in your same paragraph call out all of Hamas wrongdoings towards children too then. Don’t just focus on what pushes your narrative - be honest.


If you guys actually care about children, don’t just use them when it’s convenient for your argument - be about it.


Your argument makes no sense.
I'm claiming IDF snipers are targeting kids. Hamas has nothing to do with IDF snipers killing defenceless kids.
I have put forward plenty of evidence to support that fact.

You can then make an argument that Hamas (a known terror organization is also harming kids) and i would agree. Does that excuse IDF snipers then for shooting a 4 year old girl in the head?
If you want to have a balanced debate about what group is the worst terrorist organization IDF or Hamas, we can do that debate seperately. I imagine it's quite close.





Member
Posts: 17,973
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Oct 27 2025 03:09am
Your argument makes no sense.
I'm claiming IDF snipers are targeting kids. Hamas has nothing to do with IDF snipers killing defenceless kids.
I have put forward plenty of evidence to support that fact.

You can then make an argument that Hamas (a known terror organization is also harming kids) and i would agree. Does that excuse IDF snipers then for shooting a 4 year old girl in the head?
If you want to have a balanced debate about what group is the worst terrorist organization IDF or Hamas, we can do that debate seperately. I imagine it's quite close.


You’re twisting it. There’s zero credible proof the IDF goes around targeting kids. The IDF has rules of engagement and investigates civilian deaths. Hamas is the one hiding behind kids, firing from schools, hospitals, and houses, and putting civilians in danger on purpose.

When Hamas turns neighborhoods into launch sites, tragic things happen, but that’s on them. There’s a big difference between a combat mistake in a war zone and deliberately using kids as shields or teaching them to die for propaganda.

Trying to say the IDF and Hamas are “equally bad” isn’t balance, it’s simply shows moral confusion.
Member
Posts: 17,973
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Oct 27 2025 03:10am
If you guys actually care about children, don’t just use them when it’s convenient for your argument - be about it.


When Jewish Israeli kids were burning in cars outside of the Nova festival these guy were protesting against Israeli

Sickening
Member
Posts: 4,157
Joined: Dec 22 2004
Gold: 1,217.00
Oct 27 2025 03:33am
You’re twisting it. There’s zero credible proof the IDF goes around targeting kids. The IDF has rules of engagement and investigates civilian deaths. Hamas is the one hiding behind kids, firing from schools, hospitals, and houses, and putting civilians in danger on purpose.

When Hamas turns neighborhoods into launch sites, tragic things happen, but that’s on them. There’s a big difference between a combat mistake in a war zone and deliberately using kids as shields or teaching them to die for propaganda.

Trying to say the IDF and Hamas are “equally bad” isn’t balance, it’s simply shows moral confusion.


Zero credible evidence? Countless doctors, journalists and even IDFs own snipers have testified to targeting civilians .... that's not credible?
How is it a combat mistake to shoot a 4 year old in the head? Was it also a "combat mistake" when israeli soldiers murdered an entire ambulance crew and tried to burry the evidence?

When Israel occupies a territory illegally for +70 years tragic things happen, but that's on them. You see you can twist that argument around and it will make sense, but i try to avoid that because i don't think murdering civilians is ever acceptable despite the horrors israel has and is right now committing.


Quote
Israeli soldiers are using Palestinian civilians as human shields in Gaza to enter and clear tunnels and buildings they suspect may have been booby-trapped, a leading Israeli NGO and newspaper have reported.
The practice was so widespread across different units fighting in Gaza that it could in effect be considered a “protocol”, said Nadav Weiman, the executive director of Breaking the Silence, a group founded by Israeli combat veterans to document military abuses.
The group has collected testimony describing the practice from veterans of the 10-month war in Gaza. The accounts they have heard match those reported in an investigation by the newspaper Haaretz, which claimed that the chief of staff’s office was aware of the practice.
“The senior ranks know about it,” one source said to have taken part in finding civilians to serve as human shields told the paper. “Our lives are more important than their lives,” Haaretz quoted commanders telling their soldiers.



https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/aug/14/israeli-forces-in-gaza-use-civilians-as-human-shields-against-possible-booby-traps
Member
Posts: 5,523
Joined: Feb 10 2006
Gold: 3,315.00
Oct 27 2025 04:08am
Your argument makes no sense.
I'm claiming IDF snipers are targeting kids. Hamas has nothing to do with IDF snipers killing defenceless kids.
I have put forward plenty of evidence to support that fact.

You can then make an argument that Hamas (a known terror organization is also harming kids) and i would agree. Does that excuse IDF snipers then for shooting a 4 year old girl in the head?
If you want to have a balanced debate about what group is the worst terrorist organization IDF or Hamas, we can do that debate seperately. I imagine it's quite close.


It’s not an argument, it’s a fact. Both sides are abusing children, you just choose to call out one side because you’re partisan and have a narrative to push. If you wanna claim you care about kids, then you should point all of it out when it pertains to this war. I didn’t “excuse” any of it for the record. As far as I’m concerned both sides are trash.
Member
Posts: 4,157
Joined: Dec 22 2004
Gold: 1,217.00
Oct 27 2025 04:15am
It’s not an argument, it’s a fact. Both sides are abusing children, you just choose to call out one side because you’re partisan and have a narrative to push. If you wanna claim you care about kids, then you should point all of it out when it pertains to this war. I didn’t “excuse” any of it for the record. As far as I’m concerned both sides are trash.


I disagree.

I'm only a partisan in a sense that i want israel to stop annexation and murdering kids. Would i like everyone to stop murdering kids. Sure ofc that would be great however only one country on earth is currently murdering enough of them to fill football stadiums.

Member
Posts: 17,973
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Oct 27 2025 07:01am
Zero credible evidence? Countless doctors, journalists and even IDFs own snipers have testified to targeting civilians .... that's not credible?
How is it a combat mistake to shoot a 4 year old in the head? Was it also a "combat mistake" when israeli soldiers murdered an entire ambulance crew and tried to burry the evidence?

When Israel occupies a territory illegally for +70 years tragic things happen, but that's on them. You see you can twist that argument around and it will make sense, but i try to avoid that because i don't think murdering civilians is ever acceptable despite the horrors israel has and is right now committing.





https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/aug/14/israeli-forces-in-gaza-use-civilians-as-human-shields-against-possible-booby-traps


Occupied from who?
Member
Posts: 5,523
Joined: Feb 10 2006
Gold: 3,315.00
Oct 27 2025 09:25am
I also hate when people dodge questions. Can anyone answer me this…

Hypothetically

If Israel is attacked and then their attackers go and hide among civilians and children - how are they to respond?
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1232425262737Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll