d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Israel - Gaza Peace Deal
Prev1212223242537Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 17,975
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Oct 23 2025 01:09pm
Well, I don’t watch or read Israeli media. Not the formal channels anyway. I find it sh*t. I get info from various telegram channels which don’t involve all those good for nothing commentators.
What does the comment of me not knowing about Israeli media has to do with anything ? You read every newspaper issued in the US ?

About your source -
Maybe I’m missing something but activating Hannibal directive doesn’t mean that people were actually killed because of it ? I went briefly through the article and couldn’t find any evidence. On the contrary the article did say that pilots were afraid hitting hostages even when Hannibal directive was issued. Kinda the opposite from what you claim but I didn’t actually read it all so who knows maybe I missed something.

US and Israel goes long way. It’s concerning that the west falls into radical Islam propaganda. Like anything in life, sometimes you are up.. sometimes down.


If you would actually use the directive October 7ty would have ended in 1 hour

Member
Posts: 56,246
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 584,571.66
Oct 23 2025 02:40pm
If you would actually use the directive October 7ty would have ended in 1 hour


multiple links above were provided. the directive was ordered. are you suggesting that the IDF disobeyed orders?
Member
Posts: 56,246
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 584,571.66
Oct 23 2025 03:20pm
dont answer that. ignore that i asked. moving on.

Ultimately Israel refused to fully investigate everything that happened on Oct 7th and we will probably never know the full details (of the Hannibal directive) on the day.

This post was edited by ferdia on Oct 23 2025 03:28pm
Member
Posts: 29,426
Joined: Mar 24 2011
Gold: 1,040.00
Warn: 40%
Oct 23 2025 03:34pm
multiple links above were provided. the directive was ordered. are you suggesting that the IDF disobeyed orders?


I said that after it happened see posts in the first 100 pages.

If you would actually use the directive October 7ty would have ended in 1 hour


Still pretending the United States doesn't run your country and not the other way around.

Just another one of Uncle Sam's expensive pawns. What does 38 trillion get a Rothschild & Rockefeller crony?

lmk buds
Member
Posts: 17,975
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Oct 24 2025 10:29am
multiple links above were provided. the directive was ordered. are you suggesting that the IDF disobeyed orders?


I serve in the IDF you can show me what ever you like.
The hesitation that day proves that they didnt use Hannibal directive and if they did it was very limited
Member
Posts: 56,246
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 584,571.66
Oct 24 2025 11:10am
I serve in the IDF you can show me what ever you like.
The hesitation that day proves that they didnt use Hannibal directive and if they did it was very limited


That sentence doesn’t make sense because it’s trying to say two different things at once. It says, “They didn’t use it,” and then it says, “but if they did, it was only a little.” That’s like saying, “It didn’t rain today, but if it did, it was just a tiny bit.” You can’t state something didn’t happen and then also say maybe it did — those two ideas don’t fit together. If you really want to be clear, you have to pick one: Either they didn’t use the Hannibal Directive, Or they did, but maybe not fully. You can’t use both in the same sentence as proof of each other. Well, YOU can, and YOU do, but this does not win debates.

understand i am not trying to lecture you, i am trying to get you to debate or get your point across in a coherent fashion.

This post was edited by ferdia on Oct 24 2025 11:12am
Member
Posts: 33,919
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
Oct 24 2025 11:31am
dont answer that. ignore that i asked. moving on.

Ultimately Israel refused to fully investigate everything that happened on Oct 7th and we will probably never know the full details (of the Hannibal directive) on the day.


Yes lets do an investigation into how Israel had a few less casualties because they used common sense in waging war.
Member
Posts: 4,432
Joined: Feb 18 2007
Gold: 0.00
Oct 24 2025 11:59am
That sentence doesn’t make sense because it’s trying to say two different things at once. It says, “They didn’t use it,” and then it says, “but if they did, it was only a little.” That’s like saying, “It didn’t rain today, but if it did, it was just a tiny bit.” You can’t state something didn’t happen and then also say maybe it did — those two ideas don’t fit together. If you really want to be clear, you have to pick one: Either they didn’t use the Hannibal Directive, Or they did, but maybe not fully. You can’t use both in the same sentence as proof of each other. Well, YOU can, and YOU do, but this does not win debates.

understand i am not trying to lecture you, i am trying to get you to debate or get your point across in a coherent fashion.


He certainly can because giving the order and obeying the order is two different things
The situation with the tank is the only incident I’m aware of.. but might be few more.
Regardless, I don’t understand what people are trying to prove about Hannibal directive anyway.

This post was edited by WhiteSouned on Oct 24 2025 11:59am
Member
Posts: 50,686
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,886.00
Oct 24 2025 01:20pm
If the IDF actually believed in the absolutist measures like a hannibal directive, their response to 250 Israelis taken hostage would be to carpet bomb Gaza with incendiaries, killing the 250 hostages and 2 million palestinians and shooting anyone who tried to escape the firestorm. World powers that actually take the barbaric steps to extinguish a threat don't spend 2 years performing roof knocks and warning phone calls to civilians to get them out of the way of a surgical campaign of destruction.
Member
Posts: 1,598
Joined: Jan 9 2009
Gold: 1,024.00
Oct 24 2025 01:45pm
So when is Israel going to prosecute and punish the traitors who helped hamas on october 7th?
Its useally the step you take before starting a war..
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1212223242537Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll