Nukes only deter state actors with a clear leadership structure residing in a clearly defined location (say the Mullahs in Teheran). So yes, if Iranian forces or the Syrian army etc. attacked Israel and were on the verge of winning, Israel could threaten to go nuclear to make them stop. But that's a fringe scenario. The only practical way in which the nukes help Israel is deterring hostile neighbors from using WMDs against them.

Where nukes don't really help, however, is a scenario in which the country is attacked by a large, loosely-organized militia full of radicalized fighters who are ready to become martyrs.
Additionally, due to geographic proximity, Israel can't really use nukes in Damascus, Beirut or Gaza because they are to tiny and so stripped for land that they can't risk irradiating any of their own territory.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Oct 9 2025 10:41pm

I mean no large loosely-organized militia of the tens/hundreds of thousands of fighters that it would take to besiege Israel could really exist without being easy targets for nukes. They'd have to already be on top of Israeli forces and overrunning the country before they are targets, not being in pitched battles or any other kind of assembly. If its smaller infiltrations they get picked off, if there are swarms of suicidal arabs trying to march in the millions then they're just a bunch of burnt toast. I mean, its also a bit of a plot hole in the game of thrones backstory, GRRM never really had an explanation for why the anti-targ armies never realized they could just try to penetrate and overrun the opposing armies so dragons would not be able to inflict one-sided losses. But nukes can take out armies before they cross a border.

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DPjzaOPErbY/?igsh=MXN6YWxwYWR1bXpiOQ==

Peace in the middle east

You do not know the history therefore ignorant.
Gazans sings Khaybar which means they want to Genocide us - also I never said murder them all

You actually need to prove there is one, I dont need to prove my innocence this is not how it works

This post was edited by Many_Names on Oct 9 2025 11:05pm

You need air superiority for that, and they simply dont and wont have it.
And we will just kill them all from the skies

But i do know the history and it's not very pretty.

You never said murder them all - your politicians do, i think that makes it worse, because they are actually people of power.

It's been proven there is one. Just because you say there isn't one doesn't make it so.

It wasn’t proven anywhere and saying stuff is different than doing.
Specially by couple of far right morons in the israeli government that cant affect anything
No one starved even ferida fan admit that unless he still waits for the starvation to set in

This is what they sing actually

It has indeed been proven and been declared by several independent researches, scholars and international committees. That you are blind to israels evils doesn't change anything.
These far right morons as you claim them to be are part of the government that enacts and enables these horrors so they can indeed do something, and they are.

No starvation huh.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/oct/08/almost-55000-children-in-gaza-acutely-malnourished-lancet-study-estimates

There is no evidence to support you can change his mind. i am going to take a different approach:

Israel has made a number of notable global contributions across humanitarian, technological, environmental, and diplomatic fields. Its emergency teams, such as IsraAID and the IDF’s Home Front Command, have provided rapid disaster relief in countries including Turkey, Nepal, Haiti, and Japan. Israel’s leadership in water innovation—through desalination, drip irrigation, and recycling technologies pioneered by companies like Netafim—has helped nations such as India, Kenya, and Jordan manage water scarcity. The Jewish National Fund and related organizations have planted over 240 million trees since the early 20th century, making Israel one of the few countries with a net forest gain in recent decades. On the diplomatic front, Israel has pursued peace and normalization through treaties with Egypt and Jordan, as well as the Abraham Accords with the UAE, Bahrain, Morocco, and Sudan. Its technological ingenuity has yielded globally beneficial inventions like the USB flash drive, the Waze navigation app, and the PillCam for internal diagnostics. Continuing this spirit of innovation, Israel has joined international climate initiatives, promoting solar energy, water conservation, and a commitment to achieving net-zero emissions by 2050.