d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > October Invasion Of Israel
Prev1144714481449145014511643Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 9,109
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Jul 14 2025 05:54am
You’re seriously trying to equate the mass slaughter, rape, and mutilation of over a thousand civilians by a terrorist army on October 7th with a single unverified incident and then tossing in a cheap, homophobic dig as if that somehow strengthens your point? That’s not an argument, it’s deflection. One isolated act, even if true, doesn’t remotely compare to the scale, brutality, and intent of what Hamas unleashed. If that’s your standard of comparison, you’re not after truth you’re just looking to smear.


No, you are doing that per your rehtoric and it's disgusting. Worse, the larger picture this hurts Israel own people. Y'all could end this shit, but better to propagation it. Y'all need to do better by the victims of October 7th. Netenyahu in power is an insult to their memory
Member
Posts: 18,005
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jul 14 2025 06:00am
No, you are doing that per your rehtoric and it's disgusting. Worse, the larger picture this hurts Israel own people. Y'all could end this shit, but better to propagation it. Y'all need to do better by the victims of October 7th. Netenyahu in power is an insult to their memory


You’re deflecting. The original point was about your attempt to equate a single unverified case to a massacre of civilians on an industrial scale. That was systematic, intentional, and proudly documented by the perpetrators themselves. This is not rhetoric, it is reality.

Pointing that out is not spreading anything. It is honoring the victims by refusing to let their suffering be trivialized or twisted for political convenience. If you truly care about them, start by acknowledging what actually happened without making false comparisons or dodging the truth.
Member
Posts: 18,005
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jul 14 2025 06:00am
I was going to respond but its a bit uneven so i am taking a day off.


Have a nice day
Member
Posts: 56,272
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 574,605.03
Jul 14 2025 06:01am
Have a nice day


you too.
Member
Posts: 9,109
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Jul 14 2025 06:02am
You’re deflecting. The original point was about your attempt to equate a single unverified case to a massacre of civilians on an industrial scale. That was systematic, intentional, and proudly documented by the perpetrators themselves. This is not rhetoric, it is reality.

Pointing that out is not spreading anything. It is honoring the victims by refusing to let their suffering be trivialized or twisted for political convenience. If you truly care about them, start by acknowledging what actually happened without making false comparisons or dodging the truth.


No, keep trying to reframe my single sentence into your strawman. Off to work.

This post was edited by RedFromWinter on Jul 14 2025 06:02am
Member
Posts: 39,633
Joined: Nov 16 2005
Gold: 13.37
Jul 14 2025 06:03am
So you’re blaming the victim instead of the rapist how convenient.

That’s a false dichotomy. Even the most advanced militaries can have catastrophic intelligence failures Pearl Harbor, 9/11, the Yom Kippur War. One doesn’t cancel the other. Success in complex, high-level operations doesn’t mean they’re immune to being blindsided, especially by enemies who exploit complacency or exploit political assumptions. Competence isn’t a constant, it fluctuates and October 7 proved that painfully.


Do I really? In this case, the number of victims is definite and known- no need to twist the meaning. If we’re calling this a war, then there are sides to the conflict and war crimes. This is one of them.
Member
Posts: 18,005
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jul 14 2025 06:03am
No, keep trying to reframe my single sentence into your strawman. Off to work.


No need to reframe anything. You compared a massacre to a single incident, got called out, and now you’re dodging. Own your words or rethink them.
Member
Posts: 9,109
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Jul 14 2025 06:06am
No need to reframe anything. You compared a massacre to a single incident, got called out, and now you’re dodging. Own your words or rethink them.



Did I?


I wrote a question and you go mental into strawman fantasy.


Much earlier in the thread, I made a comparison between Israel's genocide to Bosnia and you pull new definitions out of nowhere to put your warm fuzzy hat of denial on.



Imagine if I had wrote more than a single sentence with no context?


Simmer down son
Member
Posts: 18,005
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jul 14 2025 06:07am
Do I really? In this case, the number of victims is definite and known- no need to twist the meaning. If we’re calling this a war, then there are sides to the conflict and war crimes. This is one of them.



Calling this a “war crime” as if it’s just part of a symmetrical conflict ignores reality. October 7 was not a military engagement, it was a deliberate massacre of civilians. Framing it as just another event in a “war” is an attempt to blur the line between terrorism and warfare…. moral relativism.
Member
Posts: 18,005
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jul 14 2025 06:11am
Did I?


I wrote a question and you go mental into strawman fantasy.


Much earlier in the thread, I made a comparison between Israel's genocide to Bosnia and you pull new definitions out of nowhere to put your warm fuzzy hat of denial on.



Imagine if I had wrote more than a single sentence with no context?


Simmer down son


You didn’t ask a neutral question. You implied moral equivalence between an unverified claim and a documented terrorist massacre. That’s not a strawman, that’s exactly what you did. Now you’re trying to hide behind tone and sarcasm instead of defending your point.

If you genuinely think October 7th and Bosnia are comparable, make your case clearly and honestly. Otherwise, stop pretending to be misunderstood when called out on weak analogies and lazy moral relativism.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1144714481449145014511643Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll