d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Free Will Does Not Exist - Change My Mind
Prev1171819202145Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 54,735
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Jul 11 2025 09:09am
It would be a paradox if he could. Its like the often quoted stone so heavy he cant lift it.


how is it a 'paradox' for God to give humans free will?

the commonly quoted stone so heavy thing isn't a defeater btw. No God cannot create a stone so heavy he cannot lift as this is incoherent
omnipotence is the ability to do anything logically possible

This post was edited by majorblood on Jul 11 2025 09:27am
Member
Posts: 54,735
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Jul 11 2025 09:22am
Dude, you posted a link to a THEORY. A theory isn't hard science. Learn your stuff, educate yourself and then come back.


science relies on induction and therefore cannot prove anything in the way you demand.

science can do nothing but correlate observations, no causal deduction is actually possible with science.


so a scientific theory is the best you will ever get from science.
Member
Posts: 21,546
Joined: May 22 2014
Gold: 0.00
Jul 11 2025 06:33pm
anything not repeatable or capturable by a scientific device is not "scientific" but there are many such things we are sure exist
Member
Posts: 7,251
Joined: Oct 9 2021
Gold: 4,661.71
Jul 14 2025 10:54pm
Science, Language, Art, Numbers etc were all conceived/created out of the human mind/consciousness in an attempt to “measure” the “things” around us in what we call qualitative and quantitative data. You don’t have free will you have the illusion of free will(maybe read these big paragraphs and you may learn something). How ironic that Elite is giving you the science and just like in your thread in Science/Technology and nature you said exactly what you claim you didn’t. Science isn’t proven. You are right there too all theories are exactly that “theories”. Repositories of data from mumbling Neanderthals about concepts they can’t grasp.

Like I said that’s why you sound foolish because you yourself aren’t sharing any “scientific data” to support your claim and you are unwilling to even entertain the idea you are dead wrong or at bare minimum don’t “know” what you are talking about you just “think” you do.

To support the other side in that free will to a certain DEGREE does exist. This is because like I said you cannot discuss one without the other they are mutually dependent on each other and inextricably tied.

“All things vary by degree and not of kind, Oneness is the secret of everything”

Try and stop acting. Try and clear your mind of all thoughts. There in the silence you will be one with whatever “God” means to you. Why? Because your mind itself is an illusion and apparatus of the brain which is where the two hemispheres of your brain create all the fantasy to get you to eat/speak/react to the stimuli around you. When you CHOOSE to not eat, not act, not think you are still making a conscious decision up until the moment you “come back down” and have to play your “role as an ego” in order to fit in with the world. That world is an illusion like I said created by humans for humans.

You cannot sit in Samadhi forever and this actually demonstrates free will quite well. Knowing you and God are one and the same only separated by a single thought you suddenly gain a new “purpose” because you were able to differentiate illusion from reality,

Read into philosophical concepts before asking others to explain it to you in two sentences. The answer you seek is buried in a trillion scrolls of ancient Sanskrit but like I said you are too lazy to want to learn. You’ve allowed your disbelief in God and free will to turn you into a pseudo atheist. Good luck with that.


How can one write so much while not saying a thing? You said absolutely nothing here, buddy. You stated a few obvious things like what men did and what men didnt do and thats it. Theres no wisdom in those lines, its repeated empty phrases about your world view without a shred of evidence to bavk anything up.
Member
Posts: 7,251
Joined: Oct 9 2021
Gold: 4,661.71
Jul 14 2025 10:55pm
god is just a theory no proof.


No its much less than a theory. A theory is a scientific concept.
Member
Posts: 7,251
Joined: Oct 9 2021
Gold: 4,661.71
Jul 14 2025 11:01pm
:rofl: :banana:

Guy said the same thing over in the Science/Tech/Nature sub forum in an atheism thread and then when I explained to him what atheism really is he pretended like he read books upon books on philosophy/religion/culture but I know for a FACT he didn't. How? I read almost every major religious texts and probably a hundred minor philosophies on religions from all regions of the world.

It's honestly pathetic because I was like him once, boastful/ignorant atheist/agnostic attitude and saying things just like he is but eventually I said to myself is what I'm saying actually true through and through or am I just "wishin on a wim". What is atheism? These are questions I asked myself at 19 years old and then I spent the last 16 years studying different religions only to have this dude think his shit don't stink and he knows nothing about the conceptual foundations of atheism.

He keeps telling me I'm typing "paragraphs" that he can't read yet he thinks he has great retention of the core tenets and major philosphers behind atheistic/agnsotic world views. You are right, total clown.

I guess us believers in Jesus Christ go to the root of it all scientifically and spiritually whereas the lazy atheist just laughs on a hill alone speaking in platitudes.

Don't be a lazy atheist ^Saurod I've heard "real atheist" who make concise well construed arguments in lecture halls. You've never been a philosophical lecture hall in your life and it shows.


You love to throw around phrases like ignorant in my direction without EVER discussing the actual topic. You are pretty awesome for reading everything on the topic, but I wanna how a masterful human, so full of knowledge, isnt able to discuss the topic.

You are a true quack, a guy without the ability to ever deliver a foundation to even discuss on. All you guys say is: Seek wisdom, find god, science is this and that, read books, look into philosophy, we read more than you, we know stuff and you dont...and so on. Its an endless flow of empty phrases.
Member
Posts: 7,251
Joined: Oct 9 2021
Gold: 4,661.71
Jul 14 2025 11:02pm
i cant help but think its a bot? how some of the arguments are structured and that it cant view vids.


Maybe I am? You'll never know.
Member
Posts: 7,251
Joined: Oct 9 2021
Gold: 4,661.71
Jul 14 2025 11:14pm
meh, bullchit
just twice? all the other times 'atheist claim to have read the bible they say 3 times cover to cover. its always been 3 times till now. every time i have tested that claim the 'atheist have failed. not failed 80% or 90% or even 98% but 100% of the time. a astonishing 100% of the time. so i dont believe you. maybe you did some kind of speed readding gimmick on it but i wont even believe that.

then you cant give examples of NO free will just because you think its NO free will.................

science has progressed to a point that it has proven a creator. even the 'atheists have had to make this concession. science has been extraordinarily cruel to the 'atheist

just because God know what your going to do doesnt mean you didnt have a choice.

if you were serious about this claim "...can never trust human senses and perceptions..." you would know not to make final conclusions, its simple reasoning. stuff like this is what gets me thinking your a bot. the whole paragraph is bot gibberish. little wonder people who are having conversations with bots are going coocoo.

you chose not to believe. as already been demonstrated with the "alleged" 'atheist conversation. an excuse can always be found. curious, scripture talks of a "leap of faith" ?

your pride makes you protect what you believe. the fundamental difference between a 'atheist is a 'atheist will say "nothing greater than i" while a creationist will say "there is something greater than i" the difference between the two is light years apart. the 'atheist has the highest level of astonishing arrogance. while the creationist stands in humility.
have you ever been wrong about anything? what was it?

"Instinctual Knowledge " your pride is still making you argue this point. i will say it again. your argument isnt with me it with the scientific papers that use the term.

you wont watch videos either because you cant (bot) or your just not serious about collecting information either way it makes you false.............. irreverent babble


I dont care if you believe I read the bible or not.

I never said I can give you an example of no free will, you completely missed the point. I never said I can proof that free will doesnt exist, but you said its obvious that free will exists. Thats why I asked you to prove it if its so obvious or at least oppose my arguments in a serious way.


"just because God know what your going to do doesnt mean you didnt have a choice."

Okay, why does he know it then? Who told him? No one, right?
So if he just knows it, he made it happen. Thats exactly my point. If he didnt aquire the knowledge about what I am going to do he has to be the source. He didnt get the information, he is the original source of the information. Which means he created the thought/action.

I dont know where you get that "Nothing is greater than I" bullahit from when its believers that think humans are the special ones :rofl:

Nope sorry, still not a scientific term. Not every term is scientific.

This post was edited by Saurod on Jul 14 2025 11:15pm
Member
Posts: 7,251
Joined: Oct 9 2021
Gold: 4,661.71
Jul 15 2025 02:59am
how is it a 'paradox' for God to give humans free will?

the commonly quoted stone so heavy thing isn't a defeater btw. No God cannot create a stone so heavy he cannot lift as this is incoherent
omnipotence is the ability to do anything logically possible


I absolutely agree with you. The thing is tho: Being omnipitent, which includes to be all-knowing, and also giving us humans free will is not logically possible.

Since god is the original source of his knowledge (which means he didnt aquire it from another source), he HAS to be the initiator of every thought and every action. Because that is logically the only way to know something first hand.

This post was edited by Saurod on Jul 15 2025 03:06am
Member
Posts: 7,251
Joined: Oct 9 2021
Gold: 4,661.71
Jul 15 2025 03:03am
science relies on induction and therefore cannot prove anything in the way you demand.

science can do nothing but correlate observations, no causal deduction is actually possible with science.


so a scientific theory is the best you will ever get from science.


That is absolutely not true. Where did you get that from?

Theres plenty of scientific facts that are well beyond the theoretical state.

For example water consists of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom, the Earth orbits the sun, light has a finite speed (about 299,792,458 m/s in a vacuum), DNA contains genetic information and so on. Thats not theoretical, thats factual.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1171819202145Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll