Yep if you are doing an NMFG ladder set, and your only resistances are torch and anni then you're going to be under max. And a lot of melee folks don't waste the extra fg on res on their torch and anni.
So if you're using like a rare pelt, shaftstop, jmod setup, and your charms are only 10 each, then you only have 50%.
So cyclone helps.
And as stated before, torch deaths. So many duels are won at 1 HP that torch makes a huge impact on melee. Worth the points into cyclone. 1 point into cyclone will often be broken by Torch during a duel, also.
That guy was just mad at me for other reasons, he wasn't actually iso an answer to his question/inquiry, but thanks for explaining this anyway Ink haha