There's nothing random about free will... which is why it's free will. Nothing random about sending a neural impulse to move your arm, for example.
If you actually understood quantum mechanics, you'd understand that the randomness is on the order of h-bar/2, very small. As the particle number of a system increases, it very quickly approaches classical behaviour. Your theory is to connect this randomness to free will? What mathematical model have you proposed?
i've been pressing him to (using a purely naturalistic worldview since he rejects God) explain how free will can exist
in his worldview fundamentally everything is just physics, quantum mechanics, etc. so everything is ultimately determined or random (at some level in probabilistic quantum mechanics)
if his brain is an outcome of this physics there is no room for free will, an honest naturalist must be deterministic (or we can accept his random or indeterministic worldview that things happen, at least on the quantum mechanic level, due to probabilistic causation -- it still isn't free will).
there is no free will without God
Yup. That was true for a long period of time, still is in some areas and is also true in the bible by the way.
A lot of humans societies however developed and moved on from this because of empathy - which is a feeling that is also originating from the same logic.
slavery was never presented as morally good in the bible, the text is largely descriptive of existing social realities rather than prescriptive commands that say ‘you shall have slaves.’
in fact, people do a lot of bad shit in the bible and it's not prescriptive saying their behavior is good.
This post was edited by majorblood on May 15 2025 12:52pm