d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Science, Technology & Nature > Just A Thought > ...
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 32,507
Joined: Jan 28 2007
Gold: 44,500.00
Aug 15 2012 09:23am
Theoretically, when you look at yourself in a mirror, you are looking into the past. Fractions of a second, but that is not the point.

Is there any possible way you can increase the distance the light has to travel so when looking into the mirror you can noticably see that your looking into the past?

How is that possible? Light travels over 180,000 miles per second. There is no stretch of land or space that can give us this distance, or even telescopes to reach such distances.

But what if a series of mirrors were setup hundreds of miles away from each othere that reflected an image up to a distance of 90,000 miles, and then returned the image through the mirrors back to your starting location.

If this were theoretically done and set up, would you then be able to see a second into the past?

If so then could this be done on a nanoscale? Taking a large image, scaling it down, then reflecting the images over small distance trillions of times then scaling the image back to normal size which will produce an image that was happened seconds ago?

This is very far fetched but its something I thought when taking Physics in college. Never really looked into it.
Member
Posts: 6,759
Joined: Jul 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
Aug 15 2012 09:46am
why do you need a mirror? if you look at anything, the light it reflects takes a nonzero amount of time to reach your eye
Member
Posts: 2,692
Joined: Jun 9 2007
Gold: 100.00
Aug 15 2012 09:58am
Telescopes cant see 180,000 miles?

I understand the mirror model idea your going for, its a simple concept mirrors and used as an example because theyre easy to relate to and understand but definately not practical for doing anything like this. if your reflecting something back and forth that much your going to get all kinds of limits, the mirror will absorb some light, the air between the mirrors will scatter some ect.. I dont think shrinking an image and changing and bringing it back is going to change the way the speed of light works either.

And this can be done...just get a webcam.
Member
Posts: 15,114
Joined: Nov 18 2005
Gold: 89,176.00
Aug 15 2012 10:05am
Quote (JunkFace @ Aug 15 2012 10:58am)
Telescopes cant see 180,000 miles?

I understand the mirror model idea your going for, its a simple concept mirrors and used as an example because theyre easy to relate to and understand but definately not practical for doing anything like this.  if your reflecting something back and forth that much your going to get all kinds of limits, the mirror will absorb some light, the air between the mirrors will scatter some ect..  I dont think shrinking an image and changing and bringing it back is going to change the way the speed of light works either.

And this can be done...just get a webcam.


lol was going to say
I look quite a ways into the past everytime I watch a movie
Member
Posts: 7,324
Joined: Dec 22 2002
Gold: 1,261.00
Aug 15 2012 02:17pm
Quote (joshd21 @ Aug 15 2012 08:23am)
Theoretically, when you look at yourself in a mirror, you are looking into the past. Fractions of a second, but that is not the point.

Is there any possible way you can increase the distance the light has to travel so when looking into the mirror you can noticably see that your looking into the past?

How is that possible? Light travels over 180,000 miles per second. There is no stretch of land or space that can give us this distance, or even telescopes to reach such distances.

But what if a series of mirrors were setup hundreds of miles away from each othere that reflected an image up to a distance of 90,000 miles, and then returned the image through the mirrors back to your starting location.

If this were theoretically done and set up, would you then be able to see a second into the past?

If so then could this be done on a nanoscale? Taking a large image, scaling it down, then reflecting the images over small distance trillions of times then scaling the image back to normal size which will produce an image that was happened seconds ago?

This is very far fetched but its something I thought when taking Physics in college. Never really looked into it.


Well first of all, I don't understand what the difference would be between seeing the past on a mirror surface and seeing it on a monitor. We can easily record and reproduce images already.
Also, I think it would be much easier to slow light down and have less distance traveled, than create a million mirrors thousands of miles apart. Considering we've already managed to slow light down to 17 m/s, you could see a few seconds into the past with just a single mirror that is only like 20 meters away.

This post was edited by russian on Aug 15 2012 02:18pm
Member
Posts: 10,680
Joined: Oct 26 2011
Gold: 11.01
Aug 15 2012 02:37pm
Quote (Derkaderk @ Aug 15 2012 06:46am)
why do you need a mirror? if you look at anything, the light it reflects takes a nonzero amount of time to reach your eye


This, anything that you see is pretty much the past.

Member
Posts: 13,578
Joined: Jul 27 2010
Gold: 2,285.00
Aug 15 2012 06:06pm
Quote (joshd21 @ Aug 15 2012 11:23am)
Theoretically, when you look at yourself in a mirror, you are looking into the past. Fractions of a second, but that is not the point.

Is there any possible way you can increase the distance the light has to travel so when looking into the mirror you can noticably see that your looking into the past?

How is that possible? Light travels over 180,000 miles per second. There is no stretch of land or space that can give us this distance, or even telescopes to reach such distances.

The moon is about 250,000 miles away. The Sun is 93,000,000 miles away. Andromeda (the nearest galaxy to our Milky way) is 14.6 quintillion miles away.
Member
Posts: 16,431
Joined: Jan 27 2006
Gold: 6.66
Aug 15 2012 07:11pm
Quote (joshd21 @ 15 Aug 2012 11:23)
Theoretically, when you look at yourself in a mirror, you are looking into the past. Fractions of a second, but that is not the point.

Is there any possible way you can increase the distance the light has to travel so when looking into the mirror you can noticably see that your looking into the past?

How is that possible? Light travels over 180,000 miles per second. There is no stretch of land or space that can give us this distance, or even telescopes to reach such distances.

But what if a series of mirrors were setup hundreds of miles away from each othere that reflected an image up to a distance of 90,000 miles, and then returned the image through the mirrors back to your starting location.

If this were theoretically done and set up, would you then be able to see a second into the past?

If so then could this be done on a nanoscale? Taking a large image, scaling it down, then reflecting the images over small distance trillions of times then scaling the image back to normal size which will produce an image that was happened seconds ago?

This is very far fetched but its something I thought when taking Physics in college. Never really looked into it.


seeing in the past is quite easy if you make the technology availible today

the best method though is probably just big brothering the world
Member
Posts: 54,736
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 1,463.83
Aug 15 2012 07:37pm
babby's first thought
Member
Posts: 13,305
Joined: Sep 28 2005
Gold: 4.21
Aug 15 2012 09:28pm
take a picture. boom
Go Back To Science, Technology & Nature Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll