Quote (AEtheric @ Nov 13 2010 09:18pm)
Well they're not explicit atheists because they do not outright deny the existence of god, and they're not implicit atheists because knowledge of what a god is is necessary for one to have the stance of agnosticism. They rather would claim that it is not possible to know if there is a god or not, thereby not denying or affirming the existence of a god.
Most atheists are agnostic atheists, myself included. I see no need to go by that title though. Atheist suits me just fine. I'm not an intellectual coward like theists and agnostics are. There is absolutely not one speck of proof for the existence of a deity or any indication there ever was a deity. Agnostics and theists in general tend to vilify atheists because it is the only logical position to take and can't be proven wrong. Atheists can prove both agnostics and theists are wrong and using flawed logic. This is the enlightenment. People need to start becoming enlightened already.
As for how agnostics and theists love to do a play on words such as saying atheists deny the existence of god, which is completely bullshit, here is the definition of deny in the context as it would pertain to this conversion from dictionary.com:
de·ny/diˈnī/Verb
1. Refuse to admit the truth or existence of (something).
How the fuck can I deny the existence of something that has never been proven to exist? I don't deny the existence of deity. I call bullshit on everyone else that claims there is a deity with no proof. Provide physical evidence with logical conclusions to said evidence and I'll accept such a deity exists, not until.
Quote (AEtheric @ Nov 13 2010 09:18pm)
They rather would claim that it is not possible to know if there is a god or not, thereby not denying or affirming the existence of a god.
It's quite easy to substitute god with unicorns or the Flying Spaghetti Monster, but I assure you they don't claim the same strength of agnosticism with unicorns as they do with a god. They are guilty of the 'special pleading' logical fallacy and that example will easily enough prove it. By being fence sitting chickenshits, they are intellectual cowards. They know a deity isn't found anywhere in reality but don't have the courage to admit it to themselves or others.
Whether agnostics are not explicit or implicit atheists doesn't mean they are still not atheists by default. Let's say I was gay. I'm not but let's just say I was. Would saying I was heterosexual stop me from desiring men? No it wouldn't. Just because I don't say I'm gay doesn't stop me from being gay.
This post was edited by urkal on Nov 13 2010 09:48pm