d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Science, Technology & Nature > Why Does A Flat Universe Imply That It's Infinite?
Prev1345
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 10,680
Joined: Oct 26 2011
Gold: 11.01
Feb 4 2012 01:56pm
Quote (Derkaderk @ Feb 4 2012 09:09am)
Point them out

You expect us to show you evidence for everything, and then you never show anyone evidence for anything.

Why do any of us humor you any more. This has to be a big practical joke, right?


I'm sorry I didn't understand, point what out? The bold part?
The bold part is just what he/you said..
Or so you say stuff but you don't believe it yourself??

If you want me to reply correctly to you, you need to be honest on your posts, and argue with what you really believe yourself.
Unless it becomes a big bag of peanuts ^^

Or what are you talking about, to point out?


Edit: I was just questioning how does it make sense for someone to question that maybe the universe is finite but at the same time is expanding?

I mean the whole concept of expansion already defines it being finite, just increasing that limit. So this shouldn't even need to be queationed since its basic.
Now assuming that the universe is finite (as in can't be bigger than a certain size) and at the same time believe it is expanding, it just ultra non sensical.

This post was edited by omghacks2 on Feb 4 2012 02:06pm
Member
Posts: 6,759
Joined: Jul 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
Feb 4 2012 02:20pm
Quote (omghacks2 @ Feb 4 2012 01:56pm)
I'm sorry I didn't understand, point what out? The bold part?
The bold part is just what he/you said..
Or so you say stuff but you don't believe it yourself??

If you want me to reply correctly to you, you need to be honest on your posts, and argue with what you really believe yourself.
Unless it becomes a big bag of peanuts ^^

Or what are you talking about, to point out?


Edit: I was just questioning how does it make sense for someone to question that maybe the universe is finite but at the same time is expanding?

I mean the whole concept of expansion already defines it being finite, just increasing that limit. So this shouldn't even need to be queationed since its basic.
Now assuming that the universe is finite (as in can't be bigger than a certain size) and at the same time believe it is expanding, it just ultra non sensical.


No I'm asking you to point out what I asked you to point out last time: the inconsistencies. The parts of physics that contradict one another
Member
Posts: 10,680
Joined: Oct 26 2011
Gold: 11.01
Feb 4 2012 03:51pm
Quote (Derkaderk @ Feb 4 2012 10:20am)
No I'm asking you to point out what I asked you to point out last time: the inconsistencies. The parts of physics that contradict one another


Almost every theory in physics makes sense alone, when you think of it as a separate question.
But when you try to relate 2 of those theories you find that they cant co-exist.
One nulls the other, one is contradictory to the other denying its truth.

However people often tend to just "memorize" theories even if they can't rationalize them to the point where it actually makes sense to them.
And so they fall into a paradigm, and their questions will and be created assuming the truth of all the theories they accepted as being correct.
Which many times turns into a question impossible to answer correctly. So it's created a vicious circle.

By easily denying one of those theories as being correct, sometimes the answer shows up.
So you should always make sure that you got your mind right, solid and have no doubts on your beliefs.

My point is, dont just accept anything as truth, because someone said it or it was in a book, or even worse because it's a law of physics..
What is a law of physics and what makes it a law? What do you actually know of this universe, and life and yourself to stamp a theory as law of physics? Absolutely nothing.
What we see could even be a huge room, and we are actually just atoms in a world of gods.

So your imagination and creativity is the limit, as long as you can reason it, no one is more correct than you because he's a physicist, a magician or a preach.

PS: I will show you what I mean in a couple hours when I get back to my computer.

And to everyone, nothing that I say is to be taken as an offense whatsoever btw, I love to get unreasoned and chalanged, all comments are comments as long as you advance and evolve along the conversation using new comments or different ideas.

This post was edited by omghacks2 on Feb 4 2012 03:57pm
Member
Posts: 6,759
Joined: Jul 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
Feb 4 2012 03:53pm
Quote (omghacks2 @ Feb 4 2012 03:51pm)
Almost every theory in physics makes sense alone, when you think of it as a separate question.
But when you try to relate 2 of those theories you find that they cant co-exist.
One nulls the other, one is contradictory to the other denying its truth.

However people often tend to just "memorize" theories even if they can't rationalize them to the point where it actually makes sense to them.
And so they fall into a paradigm, and their questions will and be created assuming the truth of all the theories they accepted as being correct.

My point is, dont just accept anything as truth, because someone said it or it was in a book, or even worse because it's a law of physics..
What is a law of physics and what makes it a law? What do you actually know of this universe, and life and yourself to stamp a theory as law of physics? Absolutely nothing.
What we see could even be a huge room, and we are actually just atoms in a world of gods.

So your imagination and creativity is the limit, as long as you can reason it, no one is more correct than you because he's a physicist, a magician or a preach.

PS: I will show you what I mean in a couple hours when I get back to my computer.

And to everyone, nothing that I say is to be taken as an offense whatsoever btw, I love to get unreasoned and chalanged, all comments are comments as long as you advance and evolve along the conversation using new comments or different ideas.


okay point em out later when you're back at your computer
Go Back To Science, Technology & Nature Topic List
Prev1345
Add Reply New Topic New Poll