d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Science, Technology & Nature > Kid Is Genius
Prev13456712Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 16,181
Joined: Jun 11 2006
Gold: 24,441.00
Dec 17 2010 10:15pm
Quote (nobrow @ 17 Dec 2010 21:57)
"Organic" fruit and veggies are worse for you than pesticide, they have to use a more poisonous plant so that the insects don't eat it. There is a lecture from a professor at MIT on this if you care to look it up. Also why can you people not realize that GM food is necessary, the fish DNA makes the plants frost resistant.


Maybe u can explain in furthur detail about that? I have never heard someone say that before; but u konw crops have their own defenses already in nature...

GM food is not nessessary. The growing seasons exist for more than one reason. Growing the same thing in the same place all year long can and will deplete the soil; and Also the effects on health are staggering; and should not be ignored in this discussion. Even if GM food could yield enough to rest all of the worlds famine, what is the point if the food is going to kill us as fast as a famine would anyway? Sure starvation would be faster, but the point is, even if we get enough GM food for the entire world to eat and we were able to distribute it to everyone, is it really better for everyone; or just the company who has a patent on the seeds to grow them?

GM foods have not yet come close to solving the world hunger problem, and neither has organic food. The problem is not the amount of food, but rather our ability to distrubute it. GM foods are bad news for everyone; i would hope you have enough respect for yourself to take care of your own body.
Member
Posts: 11,343
Joined: Jan 23 2007
Gold: 752.10
Dec 17 2010 10:19pm
Quote (Toothfariy @ Dec 17 2010 10:15pm)
Maybe u can explain in furthur detail about that? I have never heard someone say that before; but u konw crops have their own defenses already in nature...

GM food is not nessessary. The growing seasons exist for more than one reason. Growing the same thing in the same place all year long can and will deplete the soil; and  Also the effects on health are staggering; and should not be ignored in this discussion. Even if GM food could yield enough to rest all of the worlds famine, what is the point if the food is going to kill us as fast as a famine would anyway? Sure starvation would be faster, but the point is, even if we get enough GM food for the entire world to eat and we were able to distribute it to everyone, is it really better for everyone; or just the company who has a patent on the seeds to grow them?

GM foods have not yet come close to solving the world hunger problem, and neither has organic food. The problem is not the amount of food, but rather our ability to distrubute it. GM foods are bad news for everyone; i would hope you have enough respect for yourself to take care of your own body.


In order to keep insects from eating the crop, a more poisonous one must be used. The professor compared the chemicals, and if you wash your fruit/veggies before eating them there are more negative effects on the organic crops.
Member
Posts: 16,181
Joined: Jun 11 2006
Gold: 24,441.00
Dec 17 2010 10:27pm
Quote (nobrow @ 17 Dec 2010 22:19)
In order to keep insects from eating the crop, a more poisonous one must be used. The professor compared the chemicals, and if you wash your fruit/veggies before eating them there are more negative effects on the organic crops.


I cant find this lecture, can u link me to it?
Member
Posts: 29,427
Joined: Sep 17 2007
Gold: 742.59
Dec 17 2010 10:29pm
I don't understand what all the hub bub is about over genetically modified foods. All of the food you eat today is genetically modified due to a natural process known as natural selection. What is wrong with speeding this up and enhancing good qualities of food while eliminating the bad?
Also, this kid doesn't realize the population of the world is growing at an alarming rate and we can't feed nearly 7 billion people with "organic" and "natural farms". We need to embrace techniques that maximize efficiency in cost, there are already enough starving children, why make more?
Member
Posts: 32,985
Joined: Mar 17 2005
Gold: 6.00
Dec 18 2010 12:18am
Quote (Toothfariy @ Dec 17 2010 10:25pm)
ironic you should say that; im taking into consideration a lot more than 1 source for information. Theres a wonderful book called Seeds of Deception by Jeffery Smith which compiles all the research against GM foods and trust me when i say its a lot of information. It would be a good place for you to learn somthing. Its all very well cited. Some of the sources include Hardvard Research, The Lancet, and even Monstantos own research on the subject, which somehow Monsanto just seems to leave out...

And sure you can call me an idealist, but the difference is there is actually something we can do about this that will solve MANY problems.

Im sry that you believe everything the FDA tells you; there are the same people who told us cigarettes, agent orange, asbestos, and PCB's had no adverse health effects.
Whats even funnier is that the FDA has begun harassing raw dairy farmers; depsite the fact that raw milk from grassfed cows is not only cleaner, but way more nutrient dense than commerical pasturized milk. They believe its not safe to drink milk raw, but indeed the numbers should speak for themselves. The point is, the FDA puts the health of the american people 2nd to the interest of industry. Which is why GM seeds got approved without ANY human safety testing. And i am not kidding, to my knowledge, there have been absolutly no safety testing on humans; ever.

How can they say thats safe without any evidence to back it up? It would be like Ford telling you that you'll get better gas mileage in your car if you added half a pound of mashed potatos to every tank. There is obviously no research to back that up, but hey, Ford said it, it must be true.

Its sad to see people with such strong opinions on subjects of which they know very little. You opinion is based off of very little actual knowledge of what is going on. So i would recommend you read the book i talked about above

and by the way, ive asked a few times already, show me the potentionally good stuff; i want to know what it is since i obviously fail to see any at all.


like i said before of course its clear to see things are bad for us but that doesn't mean there is a real alternative. ill take the comment about the FDA feeding us lies as a conspiracy theorist bullcrap so no more responses for you since you think the government is out to get you and anything they say is a lie. have fun pretending like we have choices about these types of things on the scales we work with today.
Member
Posts: 16,181
Joined: Jun 11 2006
Gold: 24,441.00
Dec 18 2010 12:36am
Quote (Psycho- @ 18 Dec 2010 00:18)
like i said before of course its clear to see things are bad for us but that doesn't mean there is a real alternative. ill take the comment about the FDA feeding us lies as a conspiracy theorist bullcrap so no more responses for you since you think the government is out to get you and anything they say is a lie. have fun pretending like we have choices about these types of things on the scales we work with today.


its not a conspiracy when you have overwhemling research showing the complete opposite. The FDA failed to follow their own approval procedures. Even Monsantos research on safety says they're bad news.
I dont completely mistrust the FDA, but it is been shown to me MANY times that their first interest is industry, and second is actual health. I dont go to the FDA as a first source or final source of information. I think thats extremely irresponsible; it would be like saying the bible is fact because the offical bible writers said it was; even in the face of overwhemling objective observable evidence to show the reverse. A smart person doesnt rely on a single persons opinion or a single source of information; especially when that info has been shown to be false many many times.

And please, dont be so quick to dodge. After actually researching this, you would come to realize as i have that GM foods are bad news and you would probably never eat them either.

Have fun being another mindless ignoramus that are so abundant nowa days; lmk when you actually research this, maybe then you can have an educated opinion
Member
Posts: 20,461
Joined: Jun 16 2008
Gold: 722.53
Warn: 10%
Dec 18 2010 01:19am
I'm going to have to take sides with toothfairy on this one. The FDA is not always right, and it is always good to see two sides of the story.
Member
Posts: 16,181
Joined: Jun 11 2006
Gold: 24,441.00
Dec 18 2010 01:21am
Quote (AEtheric @ 18 Dec 2010 01:19)
I'm going to have to take sides with toothfairy on this one. The FDA is not always right, and it is always good to see two sides of the story.


Thank you :)
First thing we've ever agreed on? lol
Member
Posts: 32,985
Joined: Mar 17 2005
Gold: 6.00
Dec 18 2010 01:31am
Quote (Toothfariy @ Dec 18 2010 01:36am)
its not a conspiracy when you have overwhemling research showing the complete opposite. The FDA failed to follow their own approval procedures. Even Monsantos research on safety says they're bad news.
I dont completely mistrust the FDA, but it is been shown to me MANY times that their first interest is industry, and second is actual health. I dont go to the FDA as a first source or final source of information. I think thats extremely irresponsible; it would be like saying the bible is fact because the offical bible writers said it was; even in the face of overwhemling objective observable evidence to show the reverse. A smart person doesnt rely on a single persons opinion or a single source of information; especially when that info has been shown to be false many many times.

And please, dont be so quick to dodge. After actually researching this, you would come to realize as i have that GM foods are bad news and you would probably never eat them either.

Have fun being another mindless ignoramus that are so abundant nowa days; lmk when you actually research this, maybe then you can have an educated opinion


like i said before of course the way foods are grown has a bad side but that doesn't mean you have another real choice. you can keep ranting about it being bad but there isn't a real alternative to current methods. driving cars is bad cause they have killed millions of people and that is an absolute fact....does that change your mind about driving because its dangerous? hell no it doesn't and you'll continue to drive knowing the risk just because its more convenient. you can keep saying its bad but there isn't a better option out there for now. let me know when your ideals find an answer instead of just being being words.
Member
Posts: 16,181
Joined: Jun 11 2006
Gold: 24,441.00
Dec 18 2010 01:54am
Quote (Psycho- @ 18 Dec 2010 01:31)
like i said before of course the way foods are grown has a bad side but that doesn't mean you have another real choice. you can keep ranting about it being bad but there isn't a real alternative to current methods. driving cars is bad cause they have killed millions of people and that is an absolute fact....does that change your mind about driving because its dangerous? hell no it doesn't and you'll continue to drive knowing the risk just because its more convenient. you can keep saying its bad but there isn't a better option out there for now. let me know when your ideals find an answer instead of just being being words.


LOL do u even know what this argument is about? The alternative is organic farming you dolt; the way we have been farming ever since our species began doing agriculture.

And believe it or not, i dont drive all that much. If i can walk, i usually do it. But that isnt even a good analogy at all. For one, i am the one contraling the car, not Ford. And also driving a car doesnt even touch the detrimental effects from GM foods. A lot of things are risky behavior, even sleeping in your house, it could light on fire and you would be crushed etc. Those things are acute traumas which you dont have very much contral over. GM foods is a choice you make every single time you eat one.

I'm sorry but i cannot accept someone telling me that we should eat things that will destroy our bodies. You have hanging on to the belief that GM foods are the only way to solve world hunger, and they have not even come close to solving it. And if you really want to fix world hunger, lets talk about what starvation actually is. "A state of extreme hunger resulting from lack of essential nutrients over a prolonged period"

These foods have been shown to contain much less vital nutrients. So infact we are only starving everyone instead. And if GM foods take over then thats our prolonged period.
GM foods are completely ridiculous. It is a clear example of how we are not responsible enough to use technology like this.

And im sorry if personal health is unrealistic for you, but the organic movement is taking big wind and fast. Maybe one day people will realize that mother nature isnt stupid

This post was edited by Toothfariy on Dec 18 2010 01:58am
Go Back To Science, Technology & Nature Topic List
Prev13456712Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll