d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Science, Technology & Nature > Thoughts On Ritalin/adderall?
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 12,397
Joined: Feb 11 2007
Gold: 270.56
Oct 21 2010 04:36pm
Quote (Aisu_aS @ Oct 21 2010 02:25pm)
Sort of like cancer! i guess that is made up too.

/e wouldnt want a warn for personal attack.
Quote (Toothfariy @ Oct 21 2010 02:18pm)
Don't even try to assert a personal claim like that. There are so many factors that are contributing to that you simply cannot attribute it to a singlar thing. Also even if it is helping her, its still not treating the problem.




No its not, but it is one that is not only overly diagnosed, but also treated completely the wrong way. You would be shocked how much your diet can effect your brain function. I dont think i can advocate enough how much a strong diet and the right foods can effect a person.

Adderal may temporarly help and cover up some of the symptoms, but it in no way comes close to addressing the underlying cause of the problem in the first place, which is the goal of most people to resolve. This is a classic example of how the conventional medical community has a simple dogmatic approach to a complex problem.

And I also have a big problem with pathologizing psychological issues. This very easy leads to a self fullfilling prophecy and thus reaffirms the pathology.


vouch.

This post was edited by VereorNusquam on Oct 21 2010 04:37pm
Member
Posts: 16,181
Joined: Jun 11 2006
Gold: 24,441.00
Oct 21 2010 04:40pm
Quote (Phisherman @ 21 Oct 2010 16:23)
Oh ok, so everyone who has ADD is really just addicted to junk food. Thanks for the info, Dr. Dumbass.


Wow... go back to your bridge and read a fuckin book, you might learn somthing

Quote (Aisu_aS @ 21 Oct 2010 16:25)
Sort of like cancer! i guess that is made up too.


It actually wasnt until sometime in the 1800's that cancer first appeared in medcial records. The spike in cancer rates goes hand in hand with the industrial revolution. It is realtively a new disease.

This post was edited by Toothfariy on Oct 21 2010 04:41pm
Member
Posts: 15,197
Joined: Mar 12 2008
Gold: 51.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 21 2010 04:46pm
Quote (Toothfariy @ Oct 21 2010 05:40pm)
Wow... go back to your bridge and read a fuckin book, you might learn somthing



It actually wasnt until sometime in the 1800's that cancer first appeared in medcial records. The spike in cancer rates goes hand in hand with the industrial revolution. It is realtively a new disease.


Please tell me which book you have read that says ADD is 100% curable by eating certain foods.
Member
Posts: 12,397
Joined: Feb 11 2007
Gold: 270.56
Oct 21 2010 04:47pm
Quote (Phisherman @ Oct 21 2010 02:46pm)
Please tell me which book you have read that says ADD is 100% curable by eating certain foods.


you arent even understandin his argument, are you?
Member
Posts: 16,181
Joined: Jun 11 2006
Gold: 24,441.00
Oct 21 2010 05:03pm
Quote (VereorNusquam @ 21 Oct 2010 16:47)
you arent even understandin his argument, are you?


Obviously not

Quote (Phisherman @ 21 Oct 2010 16:46)
Please tell me which book you have read that says ADD is 100% curable by eating certain foods.


I do not the exactly physiological contruct of ADD. However, what i do know is that one of our main neurotransmitters called norepinephrine, cannot be made without the right building blocks. DHEA and other trace amino acid constituants are needed to properly make norepinephrine. DHEA is also esstential in making the sex hormones testosterone, estrogen, and pregnenolone. Where do you find DHEA? Not in any prescription medication; especially not adderall, otherwise it would be listed as a nutritional supplement. We find it in the food we eat, along with our basic amino acids. It is like this with MANY other things not just ADD.

The standard westernized diet consists of very poor quality, very refined and nutrient barren foods, which has extremely low amounts of these building blocks. Hippocrates "the father of modern medecine" was always an advocate of food before medecine. We can fix so many chronic problems simply by adjusting our diet.

But thats beside the point, wtf do you think Adderal actually does? It effects brain chemistry just like food does, only it is isolating a singular thing and not addressing the whole problem.

So please, come back to me when you've read a book on neurophysiology and understand what is acutally happening

This post was edited by Toothfariy on Oct 21 2010 05:09pm
Member
Posts: 15,197
Joined: Mar 12 2008
Gold: 51.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 21 2010 06:23pm
Quote (Toothfariy @ Oct 21 2010 06:03pm)
Obviously not



I do not the exactly physiological contruct of ADD. However, what i do know is that one of our main neurotransmitters called norepinephrine, cannot be made without the right building blocks. DHEA and other trace amino acid constituants are needed to properly make norepinephrine. DHEA is also esstential in making the sex hormones testosterone, estrogen, and pregnenolone. Where do you find DHEA? Not in any prescription medication; especially not adderall, otherwise it would be listed as a nutritional supplement. We find it in the food we eat, along with our basic amino acids. It is like this with MANY other things not just ADD.

The standard westernized diet consists of very poor quality, very refined and nutrient barren foods, which has extremely low amounts of these building blocks. Hippocrates "the father of modern medecine" was always an advocate of food before medecine. We can fix so many chronic problems simply by adjusting our diet.

But thats beside the point, wtf do you think Adderal actually does? It effects brain chemistry just like food does, only it is isolating a singular thing and not addressing the whole problem.

So please, come back to me when you've read a book on neurophysiology and understand what is acutally happening


@ bolded - They didn't have medicine like we do now in days of Hippocrates, so no big surprise there.

What's your point? Eating the right foods might help in some cases with mild ADD but for somebody with serious ADD problems, Adderall can work wonders. Is it prescribed to way too many people? Probably, but that's beside the point.

If you knew somebody who actually needs Adderall to function normally you might understand that eating more broccoli isn't going to fix shit.

This post was edited by Phisherman on Oct 21 2010 06:24pm
Member
Posts: 16,181
Joined: Jun 11 2006
Gold: 24,441.00
Oct 21 2010 07:03pm
Quote (Phisherman @ 21 Oct 2010 18:23)
@ bolded - They didn't have medicine like we do now in days of Hippocrates, so no big surprise there.

What's your point? Eating the right foods might help in some cases with mild ADD but for somebody with serious ADD problems, Adderall can work wonders. Is it prescribed to way too many people? Probably, but that's beside the point.

If you knew somebody who actually needs Adderall to function normally you might understand that eating more broccoli isn't going to fix shit.


You are seriously one of the most ignorant people i've ever met

A while back, i had a severe duodenal ulcer. Now i dont know how many people have experienced this, but it is nearly impossible to function. It is like a machine is running around constantly stabbing your stomach. The only thing you can focus on is ending the pain, and believe me when i say its painful, and it stays all day all night. I had that for 8 months until it started to get better.

I went to my doctor 6 times to try to get help. All he knew how to do was to put me on some other kind of medecine. Prilotec OTC, Antacids, etc. None of them offered a long term result. Most of the time, i had relief for about a day or two, then it would come back even worse than before. The problem was not my lack of those medecines, but it was the food i was eatting that was perpetuating this problem. This is how i got into the nutrition field. I changed my diet, and within a month, i was able to turn this around.

All of the research and books ive read have shown that there is a spike in ADD that goes along with the advent of HFCS, artificial ingredients, etc etc etc. This is somthing that can and should be addressed nutritionally, and it can and has been done.

It may not be the end all final solution for all, but in mostly all cases changing to a better diet will help a lot.

and i will emphasize one point i made eariler, Adderall offers temporary support, but in no way addresses the underlying issue. The issue is not a lack of adderall in the body.

If you still dont understand this, then go read a book call: Nutrition and Physical Degeneration by Weston A. Price, and learn somthing.
Member
Posts: 3,526
Joined: Aug 7 2009
Gold: 115.20
Oct 21 2010 08:17pm
Why are there so many overdiagnoses of ADHD/ADD? The answer is potentially a simple one, it may be to some that the pharmaceutical industry wants your money to buy their drugs, or, that doctors/parents/teachers/etc simply do not know the boundaries of "normal" hyperactivity, and hyperactivity that is potentially problematic.

Why has the disorder only recently been diagnosed, and so often at that? Because nowadays, many kids have crap diets, because they are given what they WANT to eat, and more in quantity overall, by doting parents, and most foods marketed for children are full of sugar/fat/additives etc. All that energy needs to be expelled somehow, resulting in a hyperactivity, that surrounding adults may pick up on as ADHD. Furthermore, elements of psychology have been brought forth by the popular media, who go completely over-the-top in their pseudo-scientific articles, fake cover stories, and scare-mongering, like "Bad Kids Need Drugs to Make Them Normal" with a picture of a stereotypically anti-social youth on the front...you know what I mean.

If doctors received more training in how to diagnose, and parents were less quick to themselves diagnose a disorder like ADHD because they read it in a copy of The Daily Express or something, then drugs such as Ritalin/Adderall would not be so widely produced.


Member
Posts: 16,181
Joined: Jun 11 2006
Gold: 24,441.00
Oct 21 2010 08:20pm
Quote (T1mmy_83 @ 21 Oct 2010 20:17)
Why are there so many overdiagnoses of ADHD/ADD? The answer is potentially a simple one, it may be to some that the pharmaceutical industry wants your money to buy their drugs, or, that doctors/parents/teachers/etc simply do not know the boundaries of "normal" hyperactivity, and hyperactivity that is potentially problematic.

Why has the disorder only recently been diagnosed, and so often at that? Because nowadays, many kids have crap diets, because they are given what they WANT to eat, and more in quantity overall, by doting parents, and most foods marketed for children are full of sugar/fat/additives etc. All that energy needs to be expelled somehow, resulting in a hyperactivity, that surrounding adults may pick up on as ADHD. Furthermore, elements of psychology have been brought forth by the popular media, who go completely over-the-top in their pseudo-scientific articles, fake cover stories, and scare-mongering, like "Bad Kids Need Drugs to Make Them Normal" with a picture of a stereotypically anti-social youth on the front...you know what I mean.

If doctors received more training in how to diagnose, and parents were less quick to themselves diagnose a disorder like ADHD because they read it in a copy of The Daily Express or something, then drugs such as Ritalin/Adderall would not be so widely produced.


Couldnt agree more :)
Member
Posts: 35,291
Joined: Aug 17 2004
Gold: 12,730.67
Oct 21 2010 10:00pm
I think ADD and ADHD are over-diagnosed. Yes, there are some children who need it, but most of the time they don't. I think it's disgusting that medication is pushed so much in America. Most of the time, the kid isn't getting enough attention at home and/or is immature.
Go Back To Science, Technology & Nature Topic List
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll