d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Science, Technology & Nature >
Poll > The Big Bang Theory
Prev112131415Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 15,375
Joined: Sep 1 2007
Gold: 34,723.00
Jan 10 2009 02:00am
It's not even proven that the universe is expanding. It's found that by red swift with the doppler effect which was everywhere where they looked and concluded that the universe is exponentially expanding. O rly? How do they explain the red shift on the sun then, it's not moving away from us, that's for certain. Hence, doppler effect = unreliable method to meassure if the universe is expanding or not. Strange things are happening in the universe which could produce these red shifts rolleyes.gif

This post was edited by Mark28 on Jan 10 2009 02:01am
Member
Posts: 8,004
Joined: Jul 26 2007
Gold: 6,013.00
Jan 10 2009 02:08am
Quote (ChaosDealer73 @ Wed, Dec 10 2008, 07:23pm)
If I remember correctly, they are attributing both expansion and contraction to black holes and other things of massive gravity that distort space time. Although black holes absorb matter, they do constantly loose some of their density, when there is nothing left to absorb, they only get smaller in size. This plays into the safety of creating black holes on earth, they would be so small they would instantly disappear. There is some other theory out there that says that when then last black hole ceases to exist, so will the universe. If you look at black holes in the common diagrams, they are marked by severe alterations to space time. See image:
http://www.upscale.utoronto.ca/GeneralInterest/Harrison/BlackHoles/transp8.2.gifThat would act as grounding. Think of it as putting a pin through a sheet of paper on a bulletin board, as the pin is slowly removed, the piece of paper loses its connection to the lower piece. When the grounding ceases to exist (as in there are no more black holes) the universe will simply fall apart. I don't know if I buy into that idea, and it was really confusing to read about and I probably rephrased it wrong, but it is an interesting theory.

Another theory is that eventually one black hole will absorb all the information in this universe. All that information will be ejected into a parallel universe or it will recreate the conditions prior to the big bang. When the ultra black hole no longer can support its own massive gravity, it will explode, similar to the big bang.

Edit: Whoops. Didn't see your last post, Paul. Hehe.


meh, the parallel universe theory sounds very rediculous to me. Something alike it may exist, but I highly doubt its the way they explain it. However, sinse a lot of these galaxies rotate around these black holes like we do around our sun, it is very possible that studying them will help us to discover where gravity comes from. ^^

Member
Posts: 20,461
Joined: Jun 16 2008
Gold: 722.53
Warn: 10%
Jan 10 2009 02:19pm
The big bang theory is a big peice of shit that has a billon of patched up holes in it.
Member
Posts: 28,720
Joined: Jun 28 2007
Gold: 20,040.00
Jan 10 2009 02:54pm
why isnt there a ''maybe''
Member
Posts: 894
Joined: Aug 30 2008
Gold: 383.04
Jan 10 2009 04:26pm
in my oppinion most people that say "no" don't know enough about it to even put a quality answer, also, I don't think it would disprove at least Christianity or Judaism (obviously as it makes up the first half of Christianity, for the most part) because the old testament states that "god" created the world in x amount of time (supposively a day wasn't a day back then (lol)), meaning the big bag could have infact happened, and remain inside the boundaries of the old testament.

No I am not a follower of either religion, although I have at least some understanding of both
Member
Posts: 16,429
Joined: Apr 3 2005
Gold: 282.00
Jan 10 2009 05:54pm
Quote (AEtheric @ Sat, Jan 10 2009, 03:19pm)
The big bang theory is a big peice of shit that has a billon of patched up holes in it.


a theory must not be a universal explanation...in fact falsifiability is one of the requirements for a scientific theory(quite contrary to religion/creationism that claim to be true unconditionally)

Quote
Big Bang theory = false.

Many parts of the theory have been proven false already

same here, read above

That's a religious/creationist way of thinking: "Theory xxx does not explain why yyy therefore it is false OMG I'M A GENIOUS".

Quote
It's not even proven that the universe is expanding. It's found that by red swift with the doppler effect which was everywhere where they looked and concluded that the universe is exponentially expanding. O rly? How do they explain the red shift on the sun then, it's not moving away from us, that's for certain. Hence, doppler effect = unreliable method to meassure if the universe is expanding or not. Strange things are happening in the universe which could produce these red shifts


what red shift from the sun?You mean the light scattering in the atmosphere?
Member
Posts: 894
Joined: Aug 30 2008
Gold: 383.04
Jan 10 2009 10:44pm
light has not traveled far enough for us to discover if the universe has stopped expanding, thats how vast the universe is (light will never travel far enough because space is just that, space, empty, open space, what happens when there is nothing? there is space, that answers most statements here. I don't think many people on this website have enough knowledge about the universe, religion (although it should have little to do with this
topic), and i seriously doubt any astronomers or any scientists that would fit under the "space" category have accounts here

This post was edited by layhooo3 on Jan 10 2009 10:51pm
Member
Posts: 6,877
Joined: Jan 26 2008
Gold: 17,869.00
Jan 11 2009 11:47pm
Quote (njaguar @ Wed, Dec 10 2008, 02:23pm)
One thing that always intrigued me was the thought of super black holes. Collapsed stars that become so massive that they become black holes (even light cannot escape their pull of gravity), and eventually these get larger and larger as they suck up more and more matter around them, eventually whole solar systems and galaxies.. Perhaps it is one of these that sparks an explosion that is similar to the "Big Bang", but maybe on an individual scale (unless the black hole becomes large enough to suck in the whole universe, and the point of "explosion" just happens to exactly be the size OF the universe's matter combined...)

ohmy.gif


But Even Super Black Holes "Eject" Hawkin Radiation.....wierd huh?
Member
Posts: 33,701
Joined: Jul 17 2006
Gold: 1,990.00
Jan 11 2009 11:50pm
Quote (Mark28 @ Sat, Jan 10 2009, 12:00am)
It's not even proven that the universe is expanding. It's found that by red swift with the doppler effect which was everywhere where they looked and concluded that the universe is exponentially expanding. O rly? How do they explain the red shift on the sun then, it's not moving away from us, that's for certain. Hence, doppler effect = unreliable method to meassure if the universe is expanding or not. Strange things are happening in the universe which could produce these red shifts  rolleyes.gif


links plz?
Member
Posts: 12,601
Joined: Mar 16 2008
Gold: 4,910.00
Jan 12 2009 12:06am
Quote (Spira @ Wed, Dec 10 2008, 01:29pm)
What do you think is inside of a black hole?

What if it's just a universe transporter, and it's really nothing to be afraid of?
It just sucks in light, and planets and everything and just moves up to a different spot.


Hopefully black holes are friendly, cause I could see something like that happening in the future.
Who cares about the economy if we're gonna get eaten by a super black hole?


I just don't see how an 'explosion' creates matter, or our planets. And then how does life begin? How did we even get that first organism?
It would have had to come from somewhere, maybe it got sucked out of somewhere by a black hole


But then you would have to ask, where did it come from, and where did that come from.
I believe in the big bang theory mainly because it's the most possible thing I've heard :\
Go Back To Science, Technology & Nature Topic List
Prev112131415Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll