d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Science, Technology & Nature > General Science Thread
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 32,985
Joined: Mar 17 2005
Gold: 6.00
Oct 11 2013 08:04pm
Quote (Immortal0 @ Oct 11 2013 09:03pm)
It doesn't look like anything. To "look," required light. A black hole is absolved from all light, as it's gravity is stronger than light is fast; thus light cannot escape a black hole.

A black hole; technically doesn't look like anything from any angle. Any visualization given to a blackhole is merely a pure concept designed to give speculative clarity to how it works, rather than what state it exists in.


aka looks like a black hole lol
Member
Posts: 14,000
Joined: Apr 6 2009
Gold: 140.07
Oct 11 2013 08:08pm
I am not trying to belittle anyone or make anyone feel stupid, by the way. I just think that this subforum could use a thread where general science questions can be asked. Eventually, another thread can be created with resources and other sites to get reliable information. Wonder is the seed of knowledge, and anyone can tell you that many of the theories we accept today were considered crazy when they were brought to the scientific community (see what i did there? :P). However, these people who essentially invented new ways of thinking had VAST amounts of knowledge and IMMENSE amounts of understanding of the previous theories and the shortfalls they have.

A theory is called such because it explains experimental data extremely well. For example, Newtons Theory of Gravity was called such because it enabled extremely precise PREDICTIONS about the future of a baseball thrown by a pitcher, or a ball rolling down an incline, but it doesnt explain the elipitcal orbits of planets. Thats where someone like takes previously known theories, such as Newtons ToG and Maxwell's E&M equations, and provides a new insight and way of thinking about the problem. This is then measured, tested, tested, and tested again.
Member
Posts: 14,000
Joined: Apr 6 2009
Gold: 140.07
Oct 11 2013 08:13pm
Quote (Immortal0 @ Oct 11 2013 07:03pm)
It doesn't look like anything. To "look," requires light. A black hole is absolved from all light, as it's gravity is stronger than light is fast; thus light cannot escape a black hole.

A black hole; technically doesn't look like anything from any angle. Any visualization given to a blackhole is merely a pure concept designed to give speculative clarity to how it works, rather than what state it exists in.


/e

With that said, this is what it looks like.
http://anonmgur.com/up/389b3891395083b7e32d9ee2cbaeee7e.gif


Actually... A black hole looks like a hole in the middle of space with galaxies and stars bending around it. Obviously not that, well, obvious, but we can see black holes through the mechanic of gravitational lensing.

Its hard to visualize not only space bending, but time bending as well (by bending, I mean the geodesic is not a straight line). And mathematically, in a black hole, the time and space components are "swapped," where your time component no longer depends on t but rather r, the distance you are from the center of the hole. So once one passes the event horizon, the only way to progress "time" is to move inward towards the center. Unfortunatly, if I remember correctly it would happen pretty fast and tidal forces would tear you apart before anything could be realized.

Keep in mind, when one falls into a black hole, they dont know when they pass the event horizon. Only an observer OUTSIDE the system can see that they have essentially "frozen in time." (There are some Susskind and Hawking debates about what happens to the information when it passes the event horizon, but I have not reserached it.
Member
Posts: 2,737
Joined: Jan 22 2013
Gold: 3,433.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 11 2013 08:19pm
Quote (khemist @ Oct 11 2013 10:13pm)
Actually... A black hole looks like a hole in the middle of space with galaxies and stars bending around it. Obviously not that, well, obvious, but we can see black holes through the mechanic of gravitational lensing.

Its hard to visualize not only space bending, but time bending as well (by bending, I mean the geodesic is not a straight line). And mathematically, in a black hole, the time and space components are "swapped," where your time component no longer depends on t but rather r, the distance you are from the center of the hole. So once one passes the event horizon, the only way to progress "time" is to move inward towards the center. Unfortunatly, if I remember correctly it would happen pretty fast and tidal forces would tear you apart before anything could be realized.

Keep in mind, when one falls into a black hole, they dont know when they pass the event horizon. Only an observer OUTSIDE the system can see that they have essentially "frozen in time." (There are some Susskind and Hawking debates about what happens to the information when it passes the event horizon, but I have not reserached it.


>A black hole looks like a hole in the middle of space...
Stopped reading there.
Member
Posts: 14,000
Joined: Apr 6 2009
Gold: 140.07
Oct 11 2013 08:20pm
Quote (Immortal0 @ Oct 11 2013 07:19pm)
>A black hole looks like a hole in the middle of space...
Stopped reading there.




An example of the lensing. Black hole is sans the star.
Member
Posts: 2,737
Joined: Jan 22 2013
Gold: 3,433.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 11 2013 08:36pm
Quote (khemist @ Oct 11 2013 10:20pm)
http://static.ddmcdn.com/gif/blogs/6a00d8341bf67c53ef01630128de99970d-800wi.jpg

An example of the lensing. Black hole is sans the star.


How does that warped light have any pertinence to what a blackhole looks like?
That's like pixelating a photograph and saying that's what an apple looks like.


/e

Any light that comes in contact with a blackhole is infinitely lost.
If anything, that image is more of a veil as to what a blackhole looks like, rather than a clarification.


This post was edited by Immortal0 on Oct 11 2013 08:37pm
Member
Posts: 14,000
Joined: Apr 6 2009
Gold: 140.07
Oct 11 2013 08:45pm
Quote (Immortal0 @ Oct 11 2013 07:36pm)
How does that warped light have any pertinence to what a blackhole looks like?
That's like pixelating a photograph and saying that's what an apple looks like.


/e

Any light that comes in contact with a blackhole is infinitely lost.
If anything, that image is more of a veil as to what a blackhole looks like, rather than a clarification.


black holes bend the "lines" of space, if you will (technically geodesics), that light travels in. many large bodied objects do, such as our own sun.

gravitational lensing is a way to detect black holes. as well as observing red/blue shifting of light escaping the pull of the gravitational field (say it swings close and slingshots a different direction).

In a sense, you are right. We dont technically "see" a black hole. But there can be observations made that can suggest one is there.

This post was edited by khemist on Oct 11 2013 08:46pm
Member
Posts: 3,290
Joined: Oct 22 2005
Gold: 3,100.00
Oct 12 2013 10:32am
Quote (Immortal0 @ 12 Oct 2013 03:36)

[B]Any light that comes in contact with a blackhole is infinitely lost.
If anything, that image is more of a veil as to what a blackhole looks like, rather than a clarification.


Isn't a block hole increasing in mass? therefore light would turn into matter.
Additionally you should read about hawkings radiation
Member
Posts: 2,737
Joined: Jan 22 2013
Gold: 3,433.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 12 2013 11:46am
Quote (Hell Knight @ Oct 12 2013 12:32pm)
Isn't a block hole increasing in mass? therefore light would turn into matter.
Additionally you should read about hawkings radiation


Light is infinitely condensed far past the point of "cooling," to the state of being called matter.
As far as I can answer your question; when light enters a blackhole, it will go through all stages. This includes plasma-tic; gaseous; liquid; solid; red; green; up; down; blue; tomorrow; PI; okay; apples; no.

A blackhole will condense and breakdown every aspect of every aspect of every aspect that is captured by it.


____________∞
To generalize your question; it would not convert into matter because it would never reach a point of stability in which it could condense. It would do the exact opposite of turning into matter. It would increase. It would become something higher than light. Faster, lighter, just more...

Anti-light if you will. Of course, that is a stable definition and if it was in a blackhole, it would continue to articulate into something even more.
Member
Posts: 46,808
Joined: Oct 24 2009
Gold: 18,285.00
Oct 12 2013 01:24pm
Its funny how ppl start making up stuff about blackholes and try sounding smart in the process...

The most intelligent and informed physicists of our time are still questioned by what will happen to an object when it is completely consumed by a blackhole.

In addition, noone knows whats inside a blackhole for certain so im wondering what makes u ppl think u know the answers...
Go Back To Science, Technology & Nature Topic List
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll