d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Science, Technology & Nature > Asteroid 2012 Da14 Won't Kill Us (yet), > But Ought To Scare Us Into Action
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 2,864
Joined: Aug 24 2011
Gold: 0.00
Mar 14 2012 10:23am
I think you would be a good science fiction writer.
Member
Posts: 20,755
Joined: Jun 21 2005
Gold: 1,891.73
Mar 14 2012 10:31am
Quote (undertow85 @ Mar 13 2012 09:25am)
The near earth asteroid 2012 DA14 discovered last year is not going to hit Earth next year, scientists say. Phew. And yet, it will still be coming in way too close for comfort (17,000 miles away--closer than many orbiting satellites), and may hit us the next time around, in 2020, or on another orbit in the more distant future.

This threat, which would have the impact of a thermonuclear bomb, ought to sufficiently scare us into contemplating several courses of action:

1. Watch the skies

Imagine if 2012 DA14 had been on course to hit us. We would have been caught with our pants down. There was insufficient time to build a spaceship capable of colliding with the asteroid to destroy it or bump it off course, a project that experts say would have taken two years. We need a better early warning system to detect the next gloomy discovery and give ourselves a fighting chance. Right now, when we detect an asteroid with a telescope we learn its position, but it is harder, and takes longer, to nail down its orbit. That is still the case with 2012 DA14, which astronomers are keeping a close eye on.

2. Invest in technology to stop an asteroid

There are many different ideas about how to stop an asteroid, which range from destroying it (with a nuclear device, for instance) to changing its course. The latter action would require hitting it with a kinetic interceptor or using a bit of "solar powered orbital mechanics" that involves painting (yes, painting) the asteroid white to change the ratio between reflected and absorbed radiation. We could also strap a rocket to the space rock to steer it away from us or "tow" it away with a "gravitational tractor." Others have suggested solar sails, "giant mirrors that fly through space via the force of sunlight reflecting off them."

While some of these ideas may seem far-fetched, at the very least we ought to give the best ideas their day in court right now, as we will only get to do this experiment once.

In the worst-case scenario, we would need to be prepared for the event of an asteroid making impact, in which case we would need to figure out ways to move large populations and possibly develop a fair lottery system for what would be much coveted space in the bunker. Some people, of course, may choose to accept our fate, if not embrace it, when the doomsday event draws near. On the other hand, experts such as Stephen Hawking have suggested that we need to be prepared to abandon Earth altogether, which would require the construction of a space colony.


1.) Think about how much space there is to cover, and how many spots we would have to be looking in. We would almost literally have to look at every single space rock, calculate how large it is, its speed it's trajectory; figure out if it is coming close, and figure out how long it would take for a rock to strike. And even then who knows, it may collide with another piece of space debris and change everything.

2.) Engineering is all about trial and error. Safety standards are developed from the failured attempts of the past. This would be new ground for us, being that it would be something we have never done before. There could be countless over-looked factors when attempting to knock something off-course.

Most importantly of all, do we have all of the money to support all of this? I don't think technology has reached the stage yet where we can do all of these things economically.

I do agree that we need to try and protect ourselves but I don't know that we can right now.

This post was edited by penguinhero on Mar 14 2012 10:32am
Member
Posts: 9,692
Joined: Apr 10 2006
Gold: 19,597.59
Apr 20 2012 10:22pm
imo we dont have the technology to deflext an asteroid, though we are close. i also think there is no point in going out of our way to research this. we will have the technology someday, the odds of being hit with an extinction level meteor is extremely miniscule. not to mention we track these objects and know where a majority are within reason.

dont get me wrong there is always a chance and we could be demolished tomorrow. but there are definitely more pressing matters. like 2012 or whatever.
Go Back To Science, Technology & Nature Topic List
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll