d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Strategy & Guides > The Ultimate Throw Barb Guide > Chaos, Ubers, Level 99...everything
Prev15678931Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 25,580
Joined: May 20 2006
Gold: 843.00
Sep 8 2008 02:55am
@OP: The guide looks comprehensive. I'll read through it later on, but for now, one important suggestion:

Get rid of the mass colouring (stick to a few colours, if any; it's much easier on the eyes).


@Anca: You are probably not going to win this one. At least be careful with some of your statements. wink.gif

1st
You are ignoring the 33% triggering AD effect from Lacerator which is exactly the reason to use them.
AD removes 100 % physical resist against any non-immune (20 % against phys immune).

Lacerator + Warshrike + HL: 33 % OW, 83-87 % DS (@ clvl 90-99), 33 % CtC slvl 3 AD => win !

2nd
105 fcr telespeed is the same as a sorc. Public knowledge: a sorc can tele just fine with a Spirit shield.
Add to that, a barb has a ton more life.

5th
The +10 vita add from wt is non-boostable life, whereas the straight added life on IK boots is boostable.
I cannot see that you account for this.

Leaving '3rd' and '4th' for you two to discuss.

This post was edited by Faelwen on Sep 8 2008 03:09am
Member
Posts: 8,997
Joined: Mar 30 2008
Gold: 67.22
Sep 8 2008 03:09am
1. I don`t ignore the AD

however since ds is applied to all your physical damage after ayll off wepaon ed is applied, and AD is something totally different

the ds on the warshrike only applies to a hit done with the shrikes and if there is AD on the monster, the more damage, the better
with a helmet like Guillaume`s
he will be at 100% ds with the shrikes and da 50-6x with the lacerators which means more physical damage which then gets increased by the fact that AD is casted

he is probably at what
144% ed from his merc
160ish from double throw
120ish from mastery
75 from str
55ish from dex
--->554% off weapon ed

which means that gulli = ~ 105% additional ed for his shrikes
and ~ 155% additional off weapon ed for the lacerators
+ another 25% from the additional str

2nd
sorc can use the spirit but the barb simply does not have to
with dualhoto he wins a skill, more resis and more fcr (wether that matters, depends on eq)
add to that, that he does not block anymore

okay mea culpa for the vita, forgot the BO completely ^^
so let´s see
wt`s offer 10 str, which equals 40 BO-able life and another 40 non bo-able life
Ik offers 44 hitpoints that can be boosted

which means
4 hp (+BO) from IK versus 40 of wt`s#

so let`s give this barb a lvl 50 BO, which means 182% more life/mana
1,82* 4=7,28

which means 11 hitpoints from the IK boots versus 40 of wt`s
stiull means ~ 2 charms free for the wt`s

This post was edited by Ancalagon on Sep 8 2008 03:12am
Member
Posts: 25,580
Joined: May 20 2006
Gold: 843.00
Sep 8 2008 03:40am
Quote (Ancalagon @ Mon, 8 Sep 2008, 11:09)
1. I don`t ignore the AD

however since ds is applied to all your physical damage after ayll off wepaon ed is applied,  and  AD is something totally different

the ds on the warshrike only applies to a hit done with the shrikes and if there is AD on the monster, the more damage, the better
Strictly speaking, yes, 33-37 % DS from HL on Lacerator hit, and 83-87 % DS from HL + Warshrikes on shrike hit.

with a helmet like Guillaume`s
he will be at 100% ds with the shrikes and da 50-6x with the lacerators which means more physical damage which then gets increased by the fact that AD is casted
nvm, I thought you suggested not using Lacerator at all. But still, he will fare safer with Arreat's (leech, res, dex, and AR).

he is probably at what
144% ed from his merc
160ish from double throw
120ish from mastery
75 from str
55ish from dex
--->554% off weapon ed

which means that gulli = ~ 105% additional ed for his shrikes
and ~ 155% additional off weapon ed for the lacerators
+ another 25% from the additional str
Make that 5 %. Arreat's adds 20 str.

2nd
sorc can use the spirit but the barb simply does not have to
with dualhoto he wins a skill, more resis and more fcr (wether that matters, depends on eq)
add to that, that he does not block anymore
Blocking is not an issue in PvM when teleporting @ 105 fcr (barb/sorc). And the additional 5 fcr is unimportant here. Other than that, I agree.

okay mea culpa for the vita, forgot the BO completely ^^
so let´s see
wt`s offer 10 str, which equals 40 BO-able life and another 40 non bo-able life
Ik offers 44 hitpoints that can be boosted
You have to discard the str ~ vita conversion. The build did not require any hard points in str in the first place.

which means
4 hp (+BO) from IK versus 40 of wt`s#
Because of the above, we are to compare 40 non-boostable life vs. 44 boostable life. IK boots still win (life and AR-wise).

so let`s give this barb a lvl 50 BO, which means 182% more life/mana
1,82* 4=7,28
You mean [4*2.82] = 11.

which means 11 hitpoints from the IK boots versus 40 of wt`s
stiull means ~ 2 charms free for the wt`s
Not anymore.

Edited my replies into your post.

This post was edited by Faelwen on Sep 8 2008 03:56am
Member
Posts: 8,997
Joined: Mar 30 2008
Gold: 67.22
Sep 8 2008 04:01am
totally forgot

more life witgh hoto because it does not need 156 str ^^
or more ar/damage because dex

his build wants to use a 156 str monarch
imho a bit doubteable that het will do without any str at all
assuming charlevel 90
barb starts with 30
eni=67
20 arre
30 from average torch and anni
----->147 str
icon_pointr.gif 9 str need to be put in to reach spirit
only with 1 point less to perfect attributes from either torch or anni, he will be at 0 str with his build

however
30 str anni+torch+30 basestr +67 of eni=127
now add additional 25 of gulli and wt`s to that and you`re at 152 points str, which means 4 points to invest if you want the spirit

to your last answer
Quote

which means 11 hitpoints from the IK boots versus 40 of wt`s
stiull means ~ 2 charms free for the wt`s

that stands rigfht below what you`ve put into that
Member
Posts: 14,856
Joined: Jan 13 2007
Gold: 130.00
Sep 8 2008 04:09am
BLOW YOUR ALL OMG!!
This is one of the best guides i have seen!
Never tryed it out because i havnt seen any guides there was good.. but this! omg! im making it ladder, and i starts right now! LVL 99T/barb here i come!
Ty for best guide @ d2jsp. heart.gif

Member
Posts: 25,580
Joined: May 20 2006
Gold: 843.00
Sep 8 2008 04:29am
Quote (Ancalagon @ Mon, 8 Sep 2008, 12:01)
totally forgot

more life witgh hoto because it does not need 156 str ^^
or more ar/damage because dex
Dex does not matter - he will not block with 2 x Hoto, nor will he be dealing any dmg with the fcr setup.
But as you say, he gets rid of the insane str req of a Monarch. Plus better BO and higher res, both of which are worth considering.


his build wants to use a 156 str monarch
imho a bit doubteable that het will do without any str at all
assuming charlevel 90
barb starts with 30
eni=67
20 arre
30 from average torch and anni
----->147 str
--> 9 str need to be put in to reach spirit
only with 1 point less to perfect attributes from either torch or anni, he will be at 0 str with his build
Yup, he will be needing almost max stats from Anni + Torch to reach 156 str @ clvl 90 without points in str. His choice, obviously.

however
30 str anni+torch+30 basestr +67 of eni=127
now add additional 25 of gulli and wt`s to that and you`re at 152 points str, which means 4 points to invest if you want the spirit
Or replace Spirit by Hoto. I wouldn't like having to worry about stats on Anni + Torch, just to use a Monarch.

to your last answer

Quote

which means 11 hitpoints from the IK boots versus 40 of wt`s
stiull means ~ 2 charms free for the wt`s

that stands rigfht below what you`ve put into that
I was just pointing out the calculation error. I know you said 11 hp after that.

IK boots win in terms of life and AR, if we go by not adding any hard points into str. War Traveler win in terms of dmg and MF.

Edited again.

This post was edited by Faelwen on Sep 8 2008 04:38am
Member
Posts: 8,997
Joined: Mar 30 2008
Gold: 67.22
Sep 8 2008 06:54am
dex does matter in so far as we can go on about point 11 of the guide ar+damage

jupp he will need almost perfect stats from anni and torch to wear the monarch, but otherwise he is far better of using wt`s and gulli because he will kill faster with those, needing less time for the run and thus get more xp from waves

the point AR is really debateable when looking at the fact that one has
basear,raven,dex,mastery,ar bonus of the attack, the fana of the merc,possible enchant and so on and so forth

and wether Ik boots really offer that live ore is doubteable because we can get to that story from a different angle and say....
wt`s offer more damage and if the ik boots wanna do the same damage, you`ll need more maxdam in your inv, meaning less life
Member
Posts: 10,262
Joined: Jul 22 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 30%
Sep 8 2008 06:56am
ill go try
Member
Posts: 2,598
Joined: Aug 18 2008
Gold: 3,115.00
Sep 8 2008 07:15am
Make a video of a chaos run please sad.gif. Get some other program to save the feed or buy a new pc if you have to, I really wanna see this biggrin.gif.
Might try make one myself on euscl biggrin.gif
Member
Posts: 44,628
Joined: Feb 12 2007
Gold: 1,444.13
Sep 8 2008 07:25am
Quote (Ancalagon @ Mon, Sep 8 2008, 08:54am)
dex does matter in so far as we can go on about point 11 of the guide ar+damage

jupp he will need almost perfect stats from anni and torch to wear the monarch, but otherwise he is far better of using wt`s and gulli because he will kill faster with those, needing less time for the run and thus get more xp from waves

the point AR is really debateable when looking at the fact that one has
basear,raven,dex,mastery,ar bonus of the attack, the fana of the merc,possible enchant and so on and so forth

and wether Ik boots really offer that live ore is doubteable because we can get to that story from a different angle and say....
wt`s offer more damage and if the ik boots wanna do the same damage, you`ll need more maxdam in your inv, meaning less life


Are you still rambling on with senseless BS about a build you know nothing about? With your poor excuse for logic. You are not trying to get max block, so get that out of your head, 40% block while teleing is all he needs. This isnt a pvp melee barb using a shield.
All your suggestions have been tried and failed in previous builds of this barb. This is hands down the most successful build option there is. John has spent over 2 seasons worth of time working on this build and has taken it to lvl 98 and lvl 99 100% legit.
Using spirit and hoto he already reaches the fcr bp of 105. So yet again your "logic" is failing you.

Just STFU before you looks as dumb as Ultima1
Go Back To Strategy & Guides Topic List
Prev15678931Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll