d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Strategy & Guides > Math Behind Amp Vs Dr
Prev1232425262760Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 1,555
Joined: Sep 22 2011
Gold: 33.00
Nov 9 2017 04:42pm
all you guys that agree with worrywart need some serious mental counseling

think about what your saying,

if you have no dam reduction, amplify will deal DOUBLE the damage

if you have 50% dam reduction, like a stormshield+dungos, amplify will deal TRIPLE the damage??
........ <_<

did i summarize that about right?? is that what YOU and your buddies are claiming??
Member
Posts: 91,169
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,504.69
Nov 9 2017 04:52pm
Quote (triunes @ Nov 9 2017 04:42pm)
all you guys that agree with worrywart need some serious mental counseling

think about what your saying,

if you have no dam reduction, amplify will deal DOUBLE the damage

if you have 50% dam reduction, like a stormshield+dungos, amplify will deal TRIPLE the damage??
........ <_<

did i summarize that about right?? is that what YOU and your buddies are claiming??


Ready for me to blow your mind? I'll keep the numbers small for you.

10 damage attack:

target has zero DR, not amp'd = 10 dmg taken
target has zero DR, amp'd = 20 dmg taken (amp causes double the dmg)

target has 50 dr, not amp'd = 5 dmg taken
target has 50 dr, amp'd = 15 dmg taken (amp causes triple the dmg) (50% dr still prevents 5 dmg)


isn't math fun kids?
Member
Posts: 1,555
Joined: Sep 22 2011
Gold: 33.00
Nov 9 2017 04:56pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Nov 9 2017 05:52pm)
Ready for me to blow your mind? I'll keep the numbers small for you.

10 damage attack:

target has zero DR, not amp'd = 10 dmg taken
target has zero DR, amp'd = 20 dmg taken (amp causes double the dmg)

target has 50 dr, not amp'd = 5 dmg taken
target has 50 dr, amp'd = 15 dmg taken (amp causes triple the dmg) (50% dr still prevents 5 dmg)


isn't math fun kids?


haha if you want to use words, then you need to find out what words mean


you cant say amp does 'triple' the damage with 50% dr, if you say amp does 'double' the damage with no dr

thats the whole point of damage REDUCTION, it REDUCES the the damage you take, thats the whole point of it


so TRIPLE is MOAR than DOUBLE

go to wendys and buy a double cheeseburger and a triple cheeseburger, and tell me which one has more meat

Member
Posts: 91,169
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,504.69
Nov 9 2017 05:00pm
Quote (triunes @ Nov 9 2017 04:56pm)
haha if you want to use words, then you need to find out what words mean


you cant say amp does 'triple' the damage with 50% dr, if you say amp does 'double' the damage with no dr

thats the whole point of damage REDUCTION, it REDUCES the the damage you take, thats the whole point of it


so TRIPLE is MOAR than DOUBLE

go to wendys and buy a double cheeseburger and a triple cheeseburger, and tell me which one has more meat


triple the same input is more than double the same input. when the inputs are not the same, the multipliers do not necessarily have a linear relationship. such as in this case.

when you have 50 dr, amp causes u to take triple the damage, and here's the REALLY important part, that you would have taken if you weren't amp'd but still had 50 dr.

when you have zero dr, amp causes you to take double the damage, and here's the REALLY important part, that you would have taken if you weren't amp'd but still had zero dr.

you're comparing dmg taken between zero dr and 50 dr, when you should be comparing damage taken when amp'd and not amp'd.

it's a simple mistake, just admit you were wrong. maybe make an "english isnt my first language" excuse.

This post was edited by thesnipa on Nov 9 2017 05:01pm
Member
Posts: 1,555
Joined: Sep 22 2011
Gold: 33.00
Nov 9 2017 05:04pm
you've lost the plot

you cant go around using words like 'double' and 'triple' if your changing the original base damage amount,

in order to use those words then you need to keep the base damage amount the same when referring to it
Member
Posts: 65,913
Joined: Apr 21 2012
Gold: 175.01
Nov 9 2017 05:04pm
triple brain damage confirmed
Member
Posts: 91,169
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,504.69
Nov 9 2017 05:08pm
Quote (triunes @ Nov 9 2017 05:04pm)
you've lost the plot

you cant go around using words like 'double' and 'triple' if your changing the original base damage amount,

in order to use those words then you need to keep the base damage amount the same when referring to it


the base damage amount IS the same, the base DR is not the same. you truly are confused. in all the cases i listed 10 dmg was done to the target.
Member
Posts: 26,530
Joined: Nov 18 2013
Gold: 20,241.01
Nov 9 2017 05:21pm
Quote (triunes @ Nov 9 2017 03:19pm)
no they werent

1.5x does NOT equal 3x


It triples the effective 500 damage you'd take from getting hit with a 1,000 damage attack with 50% DR.
Amp turns it into 1,500. That's effectively 3x damage because you WOULD HAVE ONLY BEEN HIT WITH 500, NOT 1,500.

Quote (triunes @ Nov 9 2017 03:56pm)
haha if you want to use words, then you need to find out what words mean


you cant say amp does 'triple' the damage with 50% dr, if you say amp does 'double' the damage with no dr

thats the whole point of damage REDUCTION, it REDUCES the the damage you take, thats the whole point of it


so TRIPLE is MOAR than DOUBLE

go to wendys and buy a double cheeseburger and a triple cheeseburger, and tell me which one has more meat


SO... Triple of 500 is 1,500 and double of 1,000 is 2,000. Seems like double is bigger than triple if you have 50% DR

This post was edited by Vilify on Nov 9 2017 05:23pm
Member
Posts: 1,555
Joined: Sep 22 2011
Gold: 33.00
Nov 9 2017 05:23pm
i think im dealing with middle school no child left behind math flunkies
Member
Posts: 26,530
Joined: Nov 18 2013
Gold: 20,241.01
Nov 9 2017 05:24pm
Quote (triunes @ Nov 9 2017 04:23pm)
i think im dealing with middle school no child left behind math flunkies


Just because you can't comprehend basic shit doesn't mean the whole world is retarded m8.
Go Back To Strategy & Guides Topic List
Prev1232425262760Next
Closed New Topic New Poll