d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Strategy & Guides > Damage Vs Deadly Strike > D2:R
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 3,481
Joined: Nov 12 2021
Gold: 60.00
Oct 1 2024 10:54am
This if for Gm Melee duels, if attack rating and defense is the same for both setups which of these options is better?

Zeal -
6.2k Damage
66 Deadly Strike

Or

Zeal -
9k Damage
35 Deadly Dtrike

Plz any insight is appreciated
Member
Posts: 23,029
Joined: Nov 19 2020
Gold: 61,651.70
Oct 1 2024 11:18am
Its kinda simple math no?
Member
Posts: 3,481
Joined: Nov 12 2021
Gold: 60.00
Oct 1 2024 11:24am
Quote (AndrewTate @ Oct 1 2024 10:18am)
Its kinda simple math no?


Pretend im really dumb and explain plz

This post was edited by Bonerguy on Oct 1 2024 11:24am
Member
Posts: 46,747
Joined: Aug 11 2018
Gold: 59.00
Oct 1 2024 01:27pm
Assuming they are the average damages the 9k 35% ds

they seem crazy high to be average damages though

This post was edited by parker84 on Oct 1 2024 01:32pm
Member
Posts: 3,481
Joined: Nov 12 2021
Gold: 60.00
Oct 1 2024 01:57pm
Quote (parker84 @ Oct 1 2024 12:27pm)
Assuming they are the average damages the 9k 35% ds

they seem crazy high to be average damages though


Its max damage for both ones with edc and the other with botd berserker axes

setups:
botd highlord
3083 - 9125 damage
35ds
20693 ar
30693 defense (b4 proc)

Edc angelics
2185 - 6456 damage
66ds
27047 ar
30589 defense (b4 proc)

Botd gface angelics gores
2782 - 8673
30ds and 60cb
23195 ar
30153 defense (b4 proc)

This post was edited by Bonerguy on Oct 1 2024 02:13pm
Member
Posts: 46,747
Joined: Aug 11 2018
Gold: 59.00
Oct 1 2024 02:02pm
Quote (Bonerguy @ Oct 1 2024 08:57pm)
Its max damage for both ones with edc and the other with botd berserker axes[/QUOTE

well put the average damage for each then i will tell u
Member
Posts: 8,349
Joined: Jul 14 2007
Gold: 29,364.60
Oct 1 2024 10:34pm
Quote (Bonerguy @ 1 Oct 2024 21:57)
Its max damage for both ones with edc and the other with botd berserker axes

setups:
botd highlord
3083 - 9125 damage
35ds
20693 ar
30693 defense (b4 proc)

Edc angelics
2185 - 6456 damage
66ds
27047 ar
30589 defense (b4 proc)

Botd gface angelics gores
2782 - 8673
30ds and 60cb
23195 ar
30153 defense (b4 proc)


Just calculate: (min DMG + max DMG) / 2 * (1 + ds/100)

For EDC that would be: (2185 + 6456) / 2 * (1+ 66/100) = 8641/2 * 1.66 = 7172,03 average damage.

To factor in ar, you need to know/assume def and level of your opponent.
Calculation see:
https://theamazonbasin.com/wiki/index.php/Attack#:~:text=Chance%20to%20hit%20has%20a,Leap
This is all assuming same attack speed etc. for all setups.
Member
Posts: 3,481
Joined: Nov 12 2021
Gold: 60.00
Oct 2 2024 12:42am
Quote (watashi @ Oct 1 2024 09:34pm)
Just calculate: (min DMG + max DMG) / 2 * (1 + ds/100)

For EDC that would be: (2185 + 6456) / 2 * (1+ 66/100) = 8641/2 * 1.66 = 7172,03 average damage.

To factor in ar, you need to know/assume def and level of your opponent.
Calculation see:
https://theamazonbasin.com/wiki/index.php/Attack#:~:text=Chance%20to%20hit%20has%20a,Leap
This is all assuming same attack speed etc. for all setups.


This was helpful ty
Member
Posts: 46,747
Joined: Aug 11 2018
Gold: 59.00
Oct 2 2024 01:33am
I would use edc setup in gm melee out of these options
Member
Posts: 46,747
Joined: Aug 11 2018
Gold: 59.00
Oct 2 2024 01:34am
Quote (parker84 @ Oct 2 2024 08:33am)
I would use edc setup in gm melee out of these options


U should be using gores also so should have 81ds
Go Back To Strategy & Guides Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll