Which would you guys recommend for a welling Mage?

Earth XIV
Level Req: 55
Spell Damage: 258 to 453

+115% Enhanced Effect
+18 Dexterity
+2% Mind Numb
+10% Glancing Blow

OR

Ice XIV
Level Req: 55
Spell Damage: 475 to 570

+127% Enhanced Effect
+80 Max Life
+2 Magic Luck
+1% Damage Return
+3% Mana Syphon


Not sure if the Dmg on the Earth is accurate, this is just listed from someone else, so it should be higher with my character because of my high intel gear. Anyways, your help is appreciated.

Ice

Ice ofc, not only better ee but mods such as ML and MS

the ice is more consistent and has more ee

==> more damage

==> better

This post was edited by Cloudfire on Oct 9 2009 02:27pm

id pick ice from these two charms

ice, cuz it helps you know when to continue welling or when to give up

Ice XIV
Level Req: 55
Spell Damage: 475 to 570

+127% Enhanced Effect
+80 Max Life
+2 Magic Luck
+1% Damage Return
+3% Mana Syphon

This has higher EE so its better, but try to make sure you use the same charms up your climb to gain more Profs to make your future climbs go more smoothly

I would definately use the ice charm.