Averaging 8.5 based on other comments, I consider that a trophy. A crappy trophy is still a trophy. And he didn't use a gift..

8/10

looks like he used a gift to me

that's definitely gifted, furnace can only roll 4 main properties, 5 with gift, that one has 5. str, vit, % damage , flat damage, socket.

5/10 seen 46xx damage ones.