d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo > Diablo 3 > D3 Discussion > Which Offhand Is Better? > Thanks
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 4,095
Joined: Feb 1 2011
Gold: 9,384.01
Warn: 10%
Jan 5 2013 07:26am
planning to buy one

this sword


vs this dagger


which one us better? thanks
Member
Posts: 50,239
Joined: Jun 11 2008
Gold: 2,079.67
Jan 5 2013 07:33am
depend on char, skill setup, other gear, killing area.

Member
Posts: 4,095
Joined: Feb 1 2011
Gold: 9,384.01
Warn: 10%
Jan 5 2013 07:36am
Quote (Tommyvv @ Jan 5 2013 09:33pm)
depend on char, skill setup, other gear, killing area.


sorry, ww/sprint barb and rend for more ls.
Member
Posts: 3,626
Joined: Sep 12 2011
Gold: 679.00
Jan 5 2013 07:51am
u dont want 400dps weapon^^ go with sword
Member
Posts: 4,095
Joined: Feb 1 2011
Gold: 9,384.01
Warn: 10%
Jan 5 2013 08:03am
Quote (Haj @ Jan 5 2013 09:51pm)
u dont want 400dps weapon^^ go with sword


but the dagger has 100% cd vs 65%. plus some str,
better for tornado dmg, right?
Member
Posts: 15,293
Joined: Jul 9 2012
Gold: 3,000.00
Jan 5 2013 08:47am
Quote (Kundrumb @ Jan 5 2013 02:03pm)
but the dagger has 100% cd vs 65%. plus some str,
better for tornado dmg, right?


Raw damage is low as hell, the IAS on the Sword makes up for some of the attack speed.
Member
Posts: 4,095
Joined: Feb 1 2011
Gold: 9,384.01
Warn: 10%
Jan 5 2013 09:22am
Quote (Sefira @ Jan 5 2013 10:47pm)
Raw damage is low as hell, the IAS on the Sword makes up for some of the attack speed.


i imported my char into this calculator http://theasiangamer.com/d3-damage-calculator/

with sword, screen damage is 159684, mainhand dmg 67577
with dagger, screen damage is 148132, mainhand dmg 74624

difference in screen damage is 11552 in favour of sword. 7.8% more damage
difference in mainhand damage (which contributes to tornado damage) is 7047 in favour of dagger. 10.4% more damage.

i hit 26 ticks MH 30 ticks OH tornado breakpoints with either one.

This post was edited by Kundrumb on Jan 5 2013 09:25am
Member
Posts: 3,544
Joined: Jun 9 2012
Gold: 3.50
Warn: 10%
Jan 5 2013 10:36am
Quote (Kundrumb @ Jan 5 2013 03:22pm)
i imported my char into this calculator http://theasiangamer.com/d3-damage-calculator/

with sword, screen damage is 159684, mainhand dmg 67577
with dagger, screen damage is 148132, mainhand dmg 74624

difference in screen damage is 11552 in favour of sword. 7.8% more damage
difference in mainhand damage (which contributes to tornado damage) is 7047 in favour of dagger. 10.4% more damage.

i hit 26 ticks MH 30 ticks OH tornado breakpoints with either one.


Don't listen to retards, dagger will be better actual DPS, but sword will be more sheet dps.
Member
Posts: 50,239
Joined: Jun 11 2008
Gold: 2,079.67
Jan 5 2013 01:58pm
Quote (Kundrumb @ Jan 5 2013 03:22pm)
i imported my char into this calculator http://theasiangamer.com/d3-damage-calculator/

with sword, screen damage is 159684, mainhand dmg 67577
with dagger, screen damage is 148132, mainhand dmg 74624


difference in screen damage is 11552 in favour of sword. 7.8% more damage
difference in mainhand damage (which contributes to tornado damage) is 7047 in favour of dagger. 10.4% more damage.

i hit 26 ticks MH 30 ticks OH tornado breakpoints with either one.


i gess you mean onscrean dps and avarage weapon hit damage?

to know effective damage, you also need to look at the situation you are in
mp0, 1 nado and 1 ww are giving damage, couse monster die in 0.5sec (sword is better)
mp10-boss: 3nado and 1 ww are giving damage (dagger is better) couse monster die in over 3seconds, and monster is so fat it stands in 3 nado
Member
Posts: 4,095
Joined: Feb 1 2011
Gold: 9,384.01
Warn: 10%
Jan 6 2013 12:17am
Quote (thief337 @ Jan 6 2013 12:36am)
Don't listen to retards, dagger will be better actual DPS, but sword will be more sheet dps.


Quote (Tommyvv @ Jan 6 2013 03:58am)
i gess you mean onscrean dps and avarage weapon hit damage?

to know effective damage, you also need to look at the situation you are in
mp0, 1 nado and 1 ww are giving damage, couse monster die in 0.5sec (sword is better)
mp10-boss: 3nado and 1 ww are giving damage (dagger is better) couse monster die in over 3seconds, and monster is so fat it stands in 3 nado


thank you, makes a lot of sense. actually i bought an EF instead, with 0.25 aps, base CD and OS :D
Go Back To D3 Discussion Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll