d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Health & Fitness > Trap Bar Deadlift Vs Barbell Deadlift
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 43,754
Joined: Mar 2 2013
Gold: 77.43
Nov 6 2017 10:58pm
Trap bar just feels way more natural and comfortable to me, are there disadvantages to using the trap bar for deadlifting?
Member
Posts: 4,498
Joined: Dec 30 2015
Gold: 88.50
Nov 6 2017 11:12pm
Trap bar likely feels better for a few reasons

You are directly over the weight, rather than having the weight in front of you with a barbell

There are handles on a trap bar, if you're using the handles then you are picking the bar up from a higher point than with a barbell. Higher starting point = better leverages = can lift more weight. Flip the trap bar upside down if you want to make it more challenging

Neutral grip, doesnt cause any rotating or twisting of the bar and therefore your spine (mixed grip can cause this)


Generally, people are stronger with trap bar than with a barbell ^ for those reasons

No disadvantages whatsoever using a trap bar. For 95% of applications it is superior to a barbell deadlift, especially for sports athletes. The only time id recommend you barbell deadlift is if youre training for a powerlifting competition

Although dont forget, trap bar is for pussies and barbell is for men



tl;dr - Trap bar > barbell



Member
Posts: 43,754
Joined: Mar 2 2013
Gold: 77.43
Nov 6 2017 11:13pm
Quote (Excusemem8 @ Nov 7 2017 12:12am)
Trap bar likely feels better for a few reasons

You are directly over the weight, rather than having the weight in front of you with a barbell

There are handles on a trap bar, if you're using the handles then you are picking the bar up from a higher point than with a barbell. Higher starting point = better leverages = can lift more weight. Flip the trap bar upside down if you want to make it more challenging

Neutral grip, doesnt cause any rotating or twisting of the bar and therefore your spine (mixed grip can cause this)


Generally, people are stronger with trap bar than with a barbell ^ for those reasons

No disadvantages whatsoever using a trap bar. For 95% of applications it is superior to a barbell deadlift, especially for sports athletes. The only time id recommend you barbell deadlift is if youre training for a powerlifting competition

Although dont forget, trap bar is for pussies and barbell is for men



tl;dr - Trap bar > barbell



Your last two statements totally contradict each other 😂😂

But thanks, I think I’ll stick to trap bar for a while.
Member
Posts: 4,498
Joined: Dec 30 2015
Gold: 88.50
Nov 6 2017 11:14pm
Quote (Kiss @ Nov 6 2017 09:13pm)
Your last two statements totally contradict each other 😂😂

But thanks, I think I’ll stick to trap bar for a while.


No they dont. Im just letting ya know whats up

Trap bar is safer, easier, more sports orientated

Barbell is harder, and thus more badass for internet points

This post was edited by Excusemem8 on Nov 6 2017 11:16pm
Member
Posts: 43,754
Joined: Mar 2 2013
Gold: 77.43
Nov 6 2017 11:16pm
Quote (Excusemem8 @ Nov 7 2017 12:14am)
No they dont. Im just letting ya know whats up



Yeah I feel ya. I don’t deadlift much so I feel like using the trap bar and just getting used to the lift will help me out. I don’t want to jump straight into bar bell, I definitely feel the extra stress in my lower back.
Member
Posts: 4,498
Joined: Dec 30 2015
Gold: 88.50
Nov 6 2017 11:23pm
Quote (Kiss @ Nov 6 2017 09:16pm)
Yeah I feel ya. I don’t deadlift much so I feel like using the trap bar and just getting used to the lift will help me out. I don’t want to jump straight into bar bell, I definitely feel the extra stress in my lower back.


The ting goes pap pap pap skrrrrrrr brap brap brap skkkkrrrrrrr du du du bap bap boom
Member
Posts: 15,649
Joined: Oct 15 2008
Gold: 50.10
Nov 6 2017 11:28pm
Quote (Excusemem8 @ Nov 7 2017 05:23am)
The ting goes pap pap pap skrrrrrrr brap brap brap skkkkrrrrrrr du du du bap bap boom


2+2 is 4 minus 1 thats 3


quik maffs
Member
Posts: 18,699
Joined: Apr 24 2007
Gold: 0.00
Nov 7 2017 05:43am
Quote (Excusemem8 @ Nov 7 2017 05:14am)
No they dont. Im just letting ya know whats up

Trap bar is safer, easier, more sports orientated

Barbell is harder, and thus more badass for internet points


Trap bar is for bitches and IG models
Barbell are for men
Member
Posts: 5,645
Joined: Jan 15 2014
Gold: 570.00
Nov 7 2017 09:57pm
i love trap bar

don't listen to excusemem8 he's just a fat powerlifter, not that strong too

if u wanna get into the shredded club u gotta use the trap bar
Member
Posts: 23,919
Joined: Aug 2 2008
Gold: 165.00
Nov 8 2017 11:26am
Quote (Excusemem8 @ 6 Nov 2017 22:23)
The ting goes pap pap pap skrrrrrrr brap brap brap skkkkrrrrrrr du du du bap bap boom


What about my evo?
Go Back To Health & Fitness Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll