d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Health & Fitness > Why Do Some Deadlifters Do This
Prev1456
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 344
Joined: Apr 11 2016
Gold: 0.07
Apr 24 2016 07:24am
Quote (cloudkicker @ Apr 24 2016 09:12pm)
I didn't say all powerlifters should lower their bars slowly because they can. It is easier by far to do than the concentric portion of the rep, you see maybe 70 percent of the neural activity during an eccentric movement compared to a concentric movement at the same force, and eccentric movement is more metabolically efficient. Regardless you're still expending energy on the eccentric portion that could be saved for another (less than full) concentric contraction. Obviously if you're competing strictly for number of repetitions as in crossfit you don't want to worry about the eccentric component when you can let gravity do that work for you but you get the most bang for your buck from eccentric contractions in terms of muscle damage and satellite cell recruitment. They're best for muscle development and generate high levels of tension (much more tension than concentric movement). You should definitely incorporate them into training but depending on your type of performance you can pay variable attention to them


Yes agreed eccentric movements are easier than concentric

Yes a slow eccentric movement will cause more muscle damage


Is it beneficial to slowly lower your deadlifts?

No

1) chance of injury significantly increases
2) high chance that the muscles you are damaging is your lower back, giving you a lower back pump, making further deadlifting in that session uncomfortable. Therefore, you would be better off dropping your deadlifts and getting more deadlift volume in rather than 'more bang for your buck' deadlifts

This is assuming you are not deadlifting to 'workout' your back but to get stronger
Member
Posts: 4,628
Joined: Oct 2 2010
Gold: 11.58
Apr 24 2016 07:49am
Quote (RyanDyerProtein @ Apr 24 2016 09:24am)
Yes agreed eccentric movements are easier than concentric

Yes a slow eccentric movement will cause more muscle damage


Is it beneficial to slowly lower your deadlifts?

No

1) chance of injury significantly increases
2) high chance that the muscles you are damaging is your lower back, giving you a lower back pump, making further deadlifting in that session uncomfortable. Therefore, you would be better off dropping your deadlifts and getting more deadlift volume in rather than 'more bang for your buck' deadlifts

This is assuming you are not deadlifting to 'workout' your back but to get stronger


Your injury risk should stay the same assuming your technique is good, as I said muscle is stronger eccentrically so unless you're at failure you should have no problem lowering safely. A muscle "pump" has nothing to do with muscle damage, but everything to do with delivery of oxygen and nutrients as well as clearance of co2. Yes an inflammatory response will develop as a result of your workout but that may take an hour or two to establish itself. Extra blood volume should not make your workout uncomfortable, if your back is sore during your workout I would suggest reevaluating your spinal mechanics.
Member
Posts: 344
Joined: Apr 11 2016
Gold: 0.07
Apr 24 2016 07:59am
Quote (cloudkicker @ Apr 24 2016 09:49pm)
Your injury risk should stay the same assuming your technique is good, as I said muscle is stronger eccentrically so unless you're at failure you should have no problem lowering safely. A muscle "pump" has nothing to do with muscle damage, but everything to do with delivery of oxygen and nutrients as well as clearance of co2. Yes an inflammatory response will develop as a result of your workout but that may take an hour or two to establish itself. Extra blood volume should not make your workout uncomfortable, if your back is sore during your workout I would suggest reevaluating your spinal mechanics.


Lowering the deadlift slowly - say for a full 3 seconds significantly increases the time under tension which will indeed result in muscle pumps and fatique you significantly faster. Which is another reason it increases the chance of injury

Anyway if you fist a virgins ass are they still a virgin?

Does the pope shit in the woods?

It doesnt matter in the end cos we all die
Member
Posts: 35,756
Joined: Aug 23 2009
Gold: 56.00
Apr 24 2016 08:00am
Quote (cloudkicker @ Apr 24 2016 06:49am)
Your injury risk should stay the same assuming your technique is good, as I said muscle is stronger eccentrically so unless you're at failure you should have no problem lowering safely. A muscle "pump" has nothing to do with muscle damage, but everything to do with delivery of oxygen and nutrients as well as clearance of co2. Yes an inflammatory response will develop as a result of your workout but that may take an hour or two to establish itself. Extra blood volume should not make your workout uncomfortable, if your back is sore during your workout I would suggest reevaluating your spinal mechanics.


Layne Norton wrote a HUGE article on why you shouldn't lower your deadlifts at over a certain % if training for strength. The risk for the IIRC L5 spine is greatly increased on the eccentric portion of the movement.
Member
Posts: 4,628
Joined: Oct 2 2010
Gold: 11.58
Apr 24 2016 09:24am
Quote (turtol @ Apr 24 2016 10:00am)
Layne Norton wrote a HUGE article on why you shouldn't lower your deadlifts at over a certain % if training for strength. The risk for the IIRC L5 spine is greatly increased on the eccentric portion of the movement.


Layne Norton also got his phd in nutrition. Honestly I know a lot of phds who research in similar fields within kinesiology but know virtually nothing outside of their direct specific research interests.

Take everything with a grain of salt
Member
Posts: 23,919
Joined: Aug 2 2008
Gold: 165.00
Apr 24 2016 09:27am
Quote (RyanDyerProtein @ 24 Apr 2016 06:59)
Lowering the deadlift slowly - say for a full 3 seconds significantly increases the time under tension which will indeed result in muscle pumps and fatique you significantly faster. Which is another reason it increases the chance of injury

Anyway if you fist a virgins ass are they still a virgin?

Does the pope shit in the woods?

It doesnt matter in the end cos we all die


I was told we're all gonna make it

This post was edited by HyphyIll on Apr 24 2016 09:27am
Member
Posts: 4,628
Joined: Oct 2 2010
Gold: 11.58
Apr 24 2016 10:46am
Quote (RyanDyerProtein @ Apr 24 2016 09:59am)
Lowering the deadlift slowly - say for a full 3 seconds significantly increases the time under tension which will indeed result in muscle pumps and fatique you significantly faster. Which is another reason it increases the chance of injury

Anyway if you fist a virgins ass are they still a virgin?

Does the pope shit in the woods?

It doesnt matter in the end cos we all die


I'm also not saying specifically train eccentric deads. 3 seconds is overkill but to perform an eccentric deadlift vs a concentric deadlift at the same cadence, rom and resistance, it's less costly during lowering than elevating. You're talking about two opposite ends of a spectrum. I'm not saying you should do full 3 to 5 second eccentrics but you're also missing out if you just drop the bar.

This post was edited by cloudkicker on Apr 24 2016 10:47am
Member
Posts: 4,759
Joined: Apr 25 2008
Gold: 108.01
Apr 24 2016 11:20pm
Quote (cloudkicker @ Apr 24 2016 05:12am)
I didn't say all powerlifters should lower their bars slowly because they can. It is easier by far to do than the concentric portion of the rep, you see maybe 70 percent of the neural activity during an eccentric movement compared to a concentric movement at the same force, and eccentric movement is more metabolically efficient. Regardless you're still expending energy on the eccentric portion that could be saved for another (less than full) concentric contraction. Obviously if you're competing strictly for number of repetitions as in crossfit you don't want to worry about the eccentric component when you can let gravity do that work for you but you get the most bang for your buck from eccentric contractions in terms of muscle damage and satellite cell recruitment. They're best for muscle development and generate high levels of tension (much more tension than concentric movement). You should definitely incorporate them into training but depending on your type of performance you can pay variable attention to them


What I'm reading here is my broscience was right? :o Fuck. Yes. /self high five!
Go Back To Health & Fitness Topic List
Prev1456
Add Reply New Topic New Poll