d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Health & Fitness > How Come These Strongman Guys > Don't Play Sports?
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 95
Joined: Nov 3 2015
Gold: 0.00
Jan 26 2016 12:59pm
Quote (CMBurns @ Jan 26 2016 01:46pm)
When you train for a sport as intense as strongman, it's not easy to transfer to another sport and still remain competitive. Obviously you're an athlete with a winner mentality and extreme dedication, so whatever the fuck you decide to do that kind of fits your strength and body shape, you'll be much better than the average joe instantly. But that doesn't mean you'd be able to compete with the very best.

Strongman is its own thing. It's a different world. People need to give up on that stereotype that they're all big idiots who just lift heavy things. If you actually bothered listening to some of them talk, you'd realize you're way off. It's a very extreme sport where you push yourself way past your limits every day. Those guys are incredibly impressive. It's too bad it doesn't pay more because the appeal of "making it" is very low unlike football.

Very well put. To clear up what I said before I don't want it to seem like all strongmen are not athletic, some of them probably are and could play in the NFL, for example, but for the most part their athleticism is specific to weight lifting/power-lifting. Just like a NFL player being good at running routes, catching the ball at the highest point or understanding who to block and do it well - strongmen focus on different things that separate themselves in the industry.

My point was centered around ALL strongmen being able to play in the NFL because that is NOT the case. Some could, most couldn't.
Member
Posts: 34,398
Joined: Dec 27 2010
Gold: 13,590.01
Jan 26 2016 02:12pm
Quote (CMBurns @ Jan 26 2016 01:46pm)
When you train for a sport as intense as strongman, it's not easy to transfer to another sport and still remain competitive. Obviously you're an athlete with a winner mentality and extreme dedication, so whatever the fuck you decide to do that kind of fits your strength and body shape, you'll be much better than the average joe instantly. But that doesn't mean you'd be able to compete with the very best.

Strongman is its own thing. It's a different world. People need to give up on that stereotype that they're all big idiots who just lift heavy things. If you actually bothered listening to some of them talk, you'd realize you're way off. It's a very extreme sport where you push yourself way past your limits every day. Those guys are incredibly impressive. It's too bad it doesn't pay more because the appeal of "making it" is very low unlike football.


I think the only people who think strong men are dumb are people who haven't ever picked up a weight in their life.

A lot of strong men have a greater knowledge of the human body and nutrition than most of the general population.
Member
Posts: 15,942
Joined: Aug 11 2007
Gold: 8,221.76
Jan 26 2016 02:37pm
Quote (xrmd @ Jan 26 2016 04:12pm)
I think the only people who think strong men are dumb are people who haven't ever picked up a weight in their life.

A lot of strong men have a greater knowledge of the human body and nutrition than most of the general population.


looks can be deceiving

come a long way since back in the day lol



Member
Posts: 34,398
Joined: Dec 27 2010
Gold: 13,590.01
Jan 26 2016 02:51pm
Quote (noob_whacker @ Jan 26 2016 03:37pm)


What does this have to do with my post lol
Member
Posts: 15,942
Joined: Aug 11 2007
Gold: 8,221.76
Jan 26 2016 03:15pm
Quote (xrmd @ Jan 26 2016 04:51pm)
What does this have to do with my post lol


mostly this
"looks can be deceiving"

cuz u say "A lot of strong men have a greater knowledge of the human body and nutrition than most of the general population. "

but looking at alot of strongmen , cuz overweight, pudgy looking, or just meathead look, people may think they r troglodytes and not smart

then again im sure some are not smart, some are
Member
Posts: 35,236
Joined: Sep 4 2007
Gold: 80.00
Jan 26 2016 09:31pm
Quote (noob_whacker @ 26 Jan 2016 17:15)
mostly this
"looks can be deceiving"

cuz u say "A lot of strong men have a greater knowledge of the human body and nutrition than most of the general population. "

but looking at alot of strongmen , cuz overweight, pudgy looking, or just meathead look, people may think they r troglodytes and not smart

then again im sure some are not smart, some are


Except they're not overweight.
Member
Posts: 15,942
Joined: Aug 11 2007
Gold: 8,221.76
Jan 26 2016 11:21pm
Quote (CMBurns @ Jan 26 2016 11:31pm)
Except they're not overweight.


alot of them are overweight, how are they not? because their weight distribution helps them lift heavier weights? still overweight for healthy standards
Member
Posts: 35,236
Joined: Sep 4 2007
Gold: 80.00
Jan 27 2016 05:54am
Quote (noob_whacker @ 27 Jan 2016 01:21)
alot of them are overweight, how are they not? because their weight distribution helps them lift heavier weights? still overweight for healthy standards


I thought you meant fat when you said overweight. Clearly they're not small dudes, but its muscle.
Member
Posts: 15,649
Joined: Oct 15 2008
Gold: 50.10
Jan 27 2016 11:44am
This entire thread could have been stopped with just the phrase specificity of training.
Member
Posts: 35,229
Joined: Jul 11 2006
Gold: 15,501.00
Feb 1 2016 11:48pm
Quote (ArtofApocalypse @ Jan 25 2016 03:27pm)
So some points I'd like to chime in without any evidence to back up my words:

Steroids:
Pretty sure professional players still take / have taken steroids.

Coordination:
Take the pool of Strongman's, surely some of them are in fact 'coordinated' they just do not know it due to their devotion at a young age lifting weights.
I would say coordination is probably the only thing that practice can't really make perfect, but I don't expect Strongman's to become wide receivers or play baseball.

Intelligence:
I'd bet professional power lifters are on the same level as professional athletes, have you ever listened to a professional athlete speak?

Cardio:
There are professional NFL players that are constantly on the 'line' of not being in shape enough and get tired after running the field. The magical thing about cardio is that you can condition your heart, if you want to.
Surely professional strongman's are great at sticking to diets and lifting plans, so this isn't a genetic block.

Strength:
I will assume here that they have enough strength to sacrifice a bit while they cut / condition themselves and still be bigger than the competition.

Skillset:
Perhaps I define skillset differently, but a Strong Man's skillset is in fact accomplishing great feats by dedication of a certain health style, this SKILLSET would allow them to transfer over to a different environment that requires them to be in a different shape due to the change of environment.

I'm not saying they are going to overnight be professional athletes, but surely it's a career choice worth looking at?


I've been around a good amount of top tier all star nfl and nba athletes... I can hang decently well with some nfl guys and beat a lot of nba guys in the weight room... But then once you step into the actual sports world it's really just an absolutely mind blowing experience.

You simply cannot fathom how truly athletic these guys are until you see them in person.

I remember one time playing pick up basketball with 2 fairly high level nfl linemen... Oh lawd oh lawd. If you saw how they move you would understand why strong men will never ever be able to make the leap.

Hell, brock lesnar couldn't even make the leap into the nfl and he's a mega freak.

It simply comes down to natural selection, these human beings can do things that you me and strong men will never be able to no matter how hard we work, how hard we train, how bad we want it...

To get to professional sports you have to be the 1% of the 1% of the 1%...... There's roughly 1600 "jobs" or athletes in the nfl... Maybe 10% of those spots are open every year.. That's 160.. Maybe 20-30 of those 160 will be able to sustain a 5+ year career....

My numbers might be off, but you get the idea. Just because you're big and strong and are good at picking heavy things up doesn't mean you're going to be able to beat someone that's devoted their life to a sport.

This post was edited by MVPx on Feb 1 2016 11:53pm
Go Back To Health & Fitness Topic List
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll