Quote (A1R @ Aug 9 2014 12:49am)
Raynor can you explain why hypertrophy is better than strength while on a cut? Thanks.
This has been a topic of contention for many years in the bodybuilding arena.
There are some very different opinions, and some people react differently to different methods.
However, here are some explanations for both:
PURE hypertrophy is not really recommended for cutting. However, high volume, low rest, high tempo, medium weight exercises, conducted at a cardio pace, have been shown to burn MORE calories per minute/hour, and engage more muscles during that time, than traditional strength training. That being said, if the primary goal is to cut body fat, this high volume cutting routine would be superior.
HOWEVER, the other thought process is that during a cut, you will substantially lose strength, and high intensity cardio style weight sessions will only further reduce this strength. This is actually TRUE. However, one of the primary reasons for strength loss is the lack of calories, lack of glycogen, and obvious Catabolism.
If one was to train strength during a cut, one would reduce the amount of calories spent and thus would reduce the amount of strength lost due to slower catabolic processes. However, strength training during a cut also opens the door for greater risk of injury, especially in the 1-5 rep range, now that your body is catabolic and not able to repair itself as well.
These, however, are both traditional cutting diets + routines, not to be confused with KETO, Intermittent Fasting, Zig Zag, etc. These other cutting routines all have different reactions.
I have seen some clients with extremely good results from low rep strength routines during a cut. Others, have had poor results and immediately saw great results when on a high-intensity cutting routine.
That being said, based on the multitude of various people I've trained, as well as the reduced risk of injury, and increased rate of fat loss, I tend to generalize my recommendations towards high-intensity cardio-paced weight routines during cutting to maximize results for a broad spectrum audience.