Quote (IDUTCIH @ Oct 19 2011 10:02pm)
What do you think of the IIFIYM(If it fits in your macros) style.
Basically Josef Rakich a young 20 year old has a GREAT physique and he follows the IIFIYM. Basically you can eat anything doesn't matter as long as it fits your macros. Do you believe in this or have any reasoning to why you would agree/disagree?
Secondly
Meal frequency and nutrient timing is all irrelevant for improving body composition, just eat whenever you want from the time you wake up to the time you go to sleep make sure you have hit your desired macros and calorie requirements for your desired goals.
IIFYM is quite frankly a load of BS. It's a half-assed approach at nutrition that most hardgainers and mesomorphs look up to as the be-all end-all of diets because of how unbelievably nonrestrictive it is.
However here are the inferant flaws:
1. IIFYM does not consider micronutrients
2. IIFYM does not consider the glycemic index
3. IIFYM does not consider fat ratios (unsaturated/saturated/trans etc)
4. IIFYM does not consider sodium and other minerals
5. IIFYM does not consider strategic meals at strategic times of the day (IE: Protein shake PWO w/ 30-40g sugar, or casein before bed, etc.)
6. IIFYM does not consider fiber or the speed at which certain foods digest
7. IIFYM does not consider food sensitivities or allergies
8. IIFYM does not consider maintaining anabolism through strategic eating times
9. IIFYM does not consider individuals who tend to gain fat rapidly
10. IIFYM does not consider processed foods, additives, artificial sugars/flavors, etc.
IIFYM is a totally flawed approach at bodybuilding nutrition. The problem with it is that most people who see great success with it are natural born mesomorphs or true hardgainers. Both of these people respond very well to copious amounts of calories (even from dirty sources) and tend to gain muscle without fat. They are NOT the majority of the population and should not be regarded as such. Furthermore, people such as Josef Rakich (obviously a hardgainer from birth) who have openly discussed their use of "gear" have absolutely no credibility as to what diet is supreme for the general lifting community.
Example...do you really think that if a male required 200g protein, 400g carbs, and 80g fats that he could simply get the 200g protein in two 100g shakes, then go get the 80g of fat from 4 tbsp of olive oil, and then get the 400g carbs from 80 tablespoons of sugar? Absolutely not right? Well on the IIFYM, that would technically be acceptable.
I hope this helps, and you consider staying on a proper diet to achieve maximum gains.