Quote (jlazy @ Oct 13 2011 05:06pm)
Not sure if this question has been brought up
I took a nutrition course last semester
My professor who has also worked as a part-time Nutritionist for the past 25 years said
whey protein powder / protein drinks ie muscle milk is not good for you since it could potentially lead to kidney failure
He continued on telling the class we'd end up in a nursery home stuck in bed and having someone wipe our asses
Says we get enough protein from our diet aprox 4-6 oz of meat will do
I'm curious to know your opinion on whey protein / protein drinks
LMAO!
I'm sorry I have to laugh when I hear nutritionists say things like that.
Throughout med school and even pre-med undergrad I had to deal with a lot of professors who believe in this total BS garbage that you only need about 60g of protein per day.
Take a look at these people and tell me, do you want to look like them?
Also how many bodybuilders have you heard ending up in nursing homes? Not many. How many normal every day people who probably eat only about 60g of protein end up in nursing homes? Almost all of them.
The key is GOOD health through a combination of things - 1. adequate and proper nutrition 2. proper exercise 3. good mindset with low stress 4. meaning and purpose in life
For a human being, you require approximately 1g of protein per pound of LEAN body weight for simple maintenance (as in to avoid muscle atrophy)
That means a person at 200 lbs and 20% body fat would need 200 - 20% (40 lbs) = 160g protein per day MINIMUM to sustain muscle levels.
To build muscle you require around 1.5g of protein per pound of lean bodyweight.
Do not worry about "kidney problems" from protein intake. It's absolutely absurd to believe that a reasonable amount of protein could cause any health problems. Quite the contrary, it will actually help you maintain a lower bf%, higher muscle mass, increased metabolism, increased immune system, increased recovery time, and better overall quality of life. Protein is absolutely essential...without it, you become sick and eventually will die.
Kidney problems from excessive protein only occur in two primary cases - 1. People with existing kidney problems taking in excessive protein (2+ grams of protein per pound of bodyweight or more) and 2. healthy people taking in absolutely obscene amounts of protein (500g + per day)
Don't listen to that psychobabble that these so-called "professionals" try to educate people on. They don't understand anything about nutrition, physical fitness, or basic biology. If we listened to them, our diets would be 60g protein, 300g carbs, and 60g fat. Obvious idiots are obvious.\
Hope this helps!