d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Health & Fitness > Question About Whey Protein > Hello
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 20,444
Joined: Jul 8 2008
Gold: 22.00
Mar 19 2017 06:23am
Quote (cloudkicker @ Mar 18 2017 11:07pm)
when was animal based protein linked to cancer? thats quite a claim to make without any evidence


red meat and some processed meat cooked at high temps were found to be mutagenic, take that as you will. never did find a peer-reviewed case study on whether or not it's carcinogenic.

also whey is fine. it's allergenic, that's the only thing i watch out for.
Member
Posts: 50,633
Joined: Jun 18 2007
Gold: 32,090.31
Mar 19 2017 08:41am
Quote (Wretch @ Mar 19 2017 07:23am)
red meat and some processed meat cooked at high temps were found to be mutagenic, take that as you will. never did find a peer-reviewed case study on whether or not it's carcinogenic.

also whey is fine. it's allergenic, that's the only thing i watch out for.


https://examine.com/nutrition/scientists-just-found-that-red-meat-causes-cancer--or-did-they/

Quote (RewtheBrave @ Mar 18 2017 03:33pm)
Animal-based protein has been linked to cancer. The worst offender is reportedly casein. I avoid casein but I still take whey isolates. The thing about cancer: literally everything you ingest outside of vegetables and water (assuming they aren't polluted) causes cancer, either directly (like smoking cigarettes) or indirectly (like simple CHO), although 'indirect' and 'direct' are relative to the number of physiological mechanisms involved. So ... here's the thing. If you want to eat clean and still eat animal based foods:

- don't eat it cooked above 350 F, ideally even above 325
- avoid charring it at all costs
- don't eat the fat
- avoid eating overly processed protein

But before you freak out, at least if you avoid casein, if you lift and generally eat clean and live clean and still take whey isolates, your chances of getting cancer are already reduced compared to that of the average person who isn't taking a protein supplement. (i.e., think of the other crap you could be doing/eating)


Not really related, but your post reminded me of an article I saw that made the bold claim that cancer was completely man made and the proof was because researchers didn't find cancer in ancient Egyptian mummies or something like that.

One of the comments was something along the lines of "Would you rather die from a mosquito bite in your 20's or die from cancer in your 70's"

Humans are living to the point where our bodies our failing. Sure there are some things that you want to avoid that can greatly increase the chances of that happening, but you can't live your life in fear of cancer.
Member
Posts: 20,444
Joined: Jul 8 2008
Gold: 22.00
Mar 19 2017 09:55am
Quote (Braxton11 @ Mar 19 2017 10:41am)


the bit about iron is interesting. never knew that.

really though, things like this have been hard for me to interpret and reach a reasonable conclusion about.

whether tests are done in vitro or not, or animal tested, or human tested, the difficulty in pinpointing probable cause in something like cancer, mutagenic vs. carcinogenic, it's a lot.

either way, the suggestion and a bit of reasonable doubt is enough to make me avoid red meat \o/
Member
Posts: 4,628
Joined: Oct 2 2010
Gold: 11.58
Mar 19 2017 10:07am
Quote (Wretch @ Mar 19 2017 08:23am)
red meat and some processed meat cooked at high temps were found to be mutagenic, take that as you will. never did find a peer-reviewed case study on whether or not it's carcinogenic.

also whey is fine. it's allergenic, that's the only thing i watch out for.


yes, high temperature cooking of heme in meat drives a rxn with carcinogenic byproducts but animal protein itself is not carcinogenic. its the cooking process that produces compounds that cause harm to our cells. this is why rew needs to review his understanding and claims, he hears buzzwords and reads headlines and glosses over the nitty gritty important shit. casein and whey are indeed animal-based proteins but at what point in their production are they exposed to 400F temperatures, in the presence of heme, that might drive carcinogenic potential? i would bet that milk proteins are no more carcinogenic than proteins from plants.

Quote (Wretch @ Mar 19 2017 11:55am)
the bit about iron is interesting. never knew that.

really though, things like this have been hard for me to interpret and reach a reasonable conclusion about.

whether tests are done in vitro or not, or animal tested, or human tested, the difficulty in pinpointing probable cause in something like cancer, mutagenic vs. carcinogenic, it's a lot.

either way, the suggestion and a bit of reasonable doubt is enough to make me avoid red meat \o/


mostly in vitro (not vivo) and epidemiological studies making an association between CR cancer and meat intake.

This post was edited by cloudkicker on Mar 19 2017 10:10am
Member
Posts: 2,837
Joined: Feb 17 2017
Gold: 421.95
Warn: 10%
Mar 19 2017 12:45pm
Quote (RewtheBrave @ Mar 18 2017 12:33pm)
Animal-based protein has been linked to cancer. The worst offender is reportedly casein. I avoid casein but I still take whey isolates. The thing about cancer: literally everything you ingest outside of vegetables and water (assuming they aren't polluted) causes cancer, either directly (like smoking cigarettes) or indirectly (like simple CHO), although 'indirect' and 'direct' are relative to the number of physiological mechanisms involved. So ... here's the thing. If you want to eat clean and still eat animal based foods:

- don't eat it cooked above 350 F, ideally even above 325
- avoid charring it at all costs
- don't eat the fat
- avoid eating overly processed protein

But before you freak out, at least if you avoid casein, if you lift and generally eat clean and live clean and still take whey isolates, your chances of getting cancer are already reduced compared to that of the average person who isn't taking a protein supplement. (i.e., think of the other crap you could be doing/eating)


Carbohydrates do not cause cancer/ and or are linked to cancer in any way.
Member
Posts: 4,628
Joined: Oct 2 2010
Gold: 11.58
Mar 19 2017 07:14pm
Quote (LolV @ Mar 19 2017 02:45pm)
Carbohydrates do not cause cancer/ and or are linked to cancer in any way.


dont worry he believes in alternative medicine so what hes saying makes sense
Member
Posts: 8,960
Joined: May 10 2008
Gold: 785.00
Mar 19 2017 07:48pm
i'll try organic protein see how i like it costs a bit more in canada but if its good why not

so all i take is creatine and this new protein powder i only take teaspoon of creatine with my post workout shake thats it basicly



i dont really eat red meat anymore ever since i started training

i stick to chicken breast and salmon buy a huge pack of both at costco sometimes some ground turkey

Member
Posts: 181,749
Joined: Jan 21 2008
Gold: 434,745.46
Mar 20 2017 11:32am
This is probably a stupid question but if I make my protein shake ahead of time (either w/ water or milk) and put it in the fridge to keep it cold, will it lose any of its features or w/e?
Member
Posts: 2,837
Joined: Feb 17 2017
Gold: 421.95
Warn: 10%
Mar 20 2017 02:02pm
Quote (Prone @ Mar 20 2017 09:32am)
This is probably a stupid question but if I make my protein shake ahead of time (either w/ water or milk) and put it in the fridge to keep it cold, will it lose any of its features or w/e?


No.

As a matter of fact it will preserve the protein longer as heat denatures protein.
Member
Posts: 16,621
Joined: Jan 7 2017
Gold: 90.58
Mar 20 2017 02:40pm
Quote (RewtheBrave @ Mar 18 2017 12:33pm)
Animal-based protein has been linked to cancer.


The Sun has been linked to skin cancer too. Better not go to the beach! Fuck my social life right!

This post was edited by JohnMiller92 on Mar 20 2017 02:40pm
Go Back To Health & Fitness Topic List
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll