d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Health & Fitness > How Good Is Canned Tuna For You?
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 15,649
Joined: Oct 15 2008
Gold: 50.10
Apr 2 2015 02:57pm
solid white albacore crew checking in
Member
Posts: 50,002
Joined: Apr 22 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Apr 2 2015 03:09pm
Quote (Wretch @ Apr 2 2015 10:02pm)
might want to re-check your little factoid there!


Might wanna learn a thing or two.
Member
Posts: 35,236
Joined: Sep 4 2007
Gold: 80.00
Apr 2 2015 04:32pm
Quote (Wretch @ 2 Apr 2015 16:02)
might want to re-check your little factoid there!


Man it's like selenium has to be brought up every single year so that people like you stop propagating unfounded bullshit.


Just so we're clear. The most recent study on selenium vs mercury still says that selenium reduces the risks of mercury poisoning significantly, but not COMPLETELY or as much as we thought it did a few years ago.

However, it also states that mercury poisoning from fish has been overexaggerated and that the benefits far outweight the cons. You can shovel down tuna all you like.

This post was edited by CMBurns on Apr 2 2015 04:42pm
Member
Posts: 16,576
Joined: Mar 8 2008
Gold: 150.00
Apr 2 2015 05:38pm
tunas fine its the mayonnaise u gotta watch out for
Member
Posts: 35,756
Joined: Aug 23 2009
Gold: 56.00
Apr 2 2015 05:54pm
When all the hype came out about mercury poisoning in tuna I ate 6 cans a day trying to get superpowers, nothing happened, you'll be fine.
Member
Posts: 15,649
Joined: Oct 15 2008
Gold: 50.10
Apr 2 2015 06:02pm
Quote (MutatedBeaveR @ Apr 2 2015 11:38pm)
tunas fine its the mayonnaise u gotta watch out for


Nothing wrong with mayo.
Member
Posts: 1,716
Joined: Mar 6 2013
Gold: 1.00
Apr 2 2015 06:14pm
Quote (flussp @ Apr 2 2015 02:41pm)
I've heard controversial opinions on this.

What do you guys think?


I think it is fine in moderation.
I agree with most here that it is unlikely to impossible that you will develop mercury poisoning - that doesn't mean you should eat 6 cans a day lol.
If anything, you will simply be depriving yourself of the nutrients found in other tasty meats and your taste for canned fish will probably flame out. :P

I would like to add that most mercury is poorly absorbed from the GI and you should look to where the fish is farmed/taken from. A big source of mercury is industry.
It ends up as air pollution and then enters the water supply where the fish are taken from. Certain brands may be better than others.

Also, the skinny of it is that methyl-mercury is formed in water environments where certain anaerobes are present. It works its way up through them in the food chain eventually ending up in fish after bioamplification.
It is much better absorbed regular elemental mercury and can pass the blood brain barrier better (and also the placenta which is why pregnant women are especially at risk of over-consumption). This is how it causes CNS effects.


TL;DR - you don't have much to worry about, but eating anything in excess (clear excess being multiple servings per day at the expense of other nutritious food) isn't the best option anyway. ;)
Member
Posts: 16,576
Joined: Mar 8 2008
Gold: 150.00
Apr 2 2015 07:25pm
Quote (kragujevac @ Apr 2 2015 07:02pm)
Nothing wrong with mayo.


mayos* mybad
Member
Posts: 423
Joined: Mar 13 2015
Gold: 0.00
Apr 2 2015 07:35pm
Canned tuna is great for you.
Member
Posts: 20,444
Joined: Jul 8 2008
Gold: 22.00
Apr 2 2015 09:40pm
Quote (CMBurns @ Apr 2 2015 05:32pm)
Man it's like selenium has to be brought up every single year so that people like you stop propagating unfounded bullshit.


Just so we're clear. The most recent study on selenium vs mercury still says that selenium reduces the risks of mercury poisoning significantly, but not COMPLETELY or as much as we thought it did a few years ago.

However, it also states that mercury poisoning from fish has been overexaggerated and that the benefits far outweight the cons. You can shovel down tuna all you like.


yeah yeah we've all read the bb article here. i'm gonna trust the doctor more than the internet rando on this one, sorry bud.

seems you think i'm saying anyone who eats tuna is going to get mercury poisoning. hell no eat canned tuna all the time, on toast with some old bay it's delicious

or maybe you're under the impression that i meant anyone who eats a can of tuna will die and that's why you're being so pompous. if so, sorry bout the misunderstanding, what i really mean is "methylmercury toxicity". all clear?

This post was edited by Wretch on Apr 2 2015 09:50pm
Go Back To Health & Fitness Topic List
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll