d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Health & Fitness > Power Clean
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 24,054
Joined: Mar 28 2010
Gold: 24.99
Feb 2 2015 10:27pm
Quote (Lancet_Jade @ Feb 3 2015 12:11am)
Powerlifters don't focus on flexibility or speed? wot

I used to do them back in my football days, I'd like to start doing them again as I think they are a really fun lift.


go ahead then

Member
Posts: 32,685
Joined: Feb 11 2009
Gold: 603.00
Feb 3 2015 12:20am
Quote (Qwaze @ Feb 2 2015 09:27pm)
go ahead then


Planning on it, was just curious as to why they aren't in any programs.
Member
Posts: 2,653
Joined: Jun 26 2013
Gold: 1.05
Feb 3 2015 12:26am
Quote (Lancet_Jade @ Feb 3 2015 03:20pm)
Planning on it, was just curious as to why they aren't in any programs.


They are in starting strength

They are also in the Texas method

The 2 most well known programs ever, ever.

Did u even look, do u even scout? Do u even lift?
Member
Posts: 32,685
Joined: Feb 11 2009
Gold: 603.00
Feb 3 2015 04:23am
Quote (HotHamAndCarl @ Feb 2 2015 11:26pm)
They are in starting strength

They are also in the Texas method

The 2 most well known programs ever, ever.

Did u even look, do u even scout? Do u even lift?


Never really looked into Texas method and I forgot that SS had them in the program.

touche
Member
Posts: 50,633
Joined: Jun 18 2007
Gold: 32,090.31
Feb 3 2015 06:14am
Quote (BoneYard @ Feb 2 2015 06:41pm)
No. Cleans require a lot of coordination, accuracy, flexability, speed and balance which no one who trains hypertrophy or powerlifting bother to train.


Lolcrossfit.
Quote (HotHamAndCarl @ Feb 3 2015 02:26am)
They are in starting strength

They are also in the Texas method

The 2 most well known programs ever, ever.

Did u even look, do u even scout? Do u even lift?


Tell that to your m8 who said people who train strength and hypertrophy can't do them.
Member
Posts: 29,687
Joined: Mar 3 2008
Gold: 0.00
Feb 3 2015 07:01am
Too momentum based for my liking.
Member
Posts: 2,653
Joined: Jun 26 2013
Gold: 1.05
Feb 3 2015 07:02am
Quote (Braxton11 @ Feb 3 2015 09:14pm)
Lolcrossfit.

Tell that to your m8 who said people who train strength and hypertrophy can't do them.


BoneYards mind has been clouded by crossfit don't listen to him
Member
Posts: 10,489
Joined: Jul 2 2009
Gold: 0.01
Warn: 10%
Feb 3 2015 10:25am
Quote (Fooba @ Feb 3 2015 06:01am)
Too momentum based for my liking.


dumbest thing I've ever read smh
Member
Posts: 8,815
Joined: Dec 26 2006
Gold: 172.00
Feb 3 2015 11:38pm
so much facepalm for one thread...

but, my belief as to why they aren't in a lot of programs:
- too technical for most lifters (takes a good amount of work to completely them correctly)
- doesn't highly benefit whatever goal is being pursued
- doesn't fit smoothly into hypertrophy routines*
- doesn't fit smoothly into strength routines (specifically powerlifting)**

wall of text for a bit of my thoughts on training:


*olympic lifts were originally intended to be done in sets of lower reps, they are explosive and technical movements...with higher reps, you lose explosiveness with fatigue..with fatigue, technique begins to break down rapidly...so, getting into higher reps with any sort of load completely defeats the purpose as you can no longer completely the movement safely and also lose the explosive element (if you have to hitch the bar bar on to you stomach and flop around a bit to get it to the rack postion, your are doing it wrong - see a number of crossfit fail videos)..now, since it is done properly in lower rep sets, it isn't as much as a hypertrophy exercise as compared to something else that involves greater TUT..lastly, it works so many different muscle groups, it does not fit cleanly in to any specific day in a hypertrophy routine

**when training for powerlifting, the olympic lifts don't fit in to routines because they don't necessarily correlate directly to higher lifts in the big three..the explosiveness is always beneficial in my opinion, but the olympic lifts are very taxing if done with a high load..so, if you incorporate these in to a powerlifting routine, the energy spent on the olympic lifts would be taken from time that could have been spent better on directly improving the big 3..for example, instead of a clean for explosiveness off of the floor, work with speed deadlifts instead - the load can be higher, it is less technical, and it should translate better directly to the lift you are trying to improve..as with any type of training with a specific goal in mind, specificity of training needs to be taken into account first and foremost (with this example, would you tell an olympic lifter to run half-marathons to lift better? why or why not? would you tell a powerlifter to olympic lift to optimally increase the big 3 numbers? why or why not?)



now, if you are training for something specific and see a reason why a certain lift will benefit that training, then you should probably be doing it..for example, if you are training for most sports, olympic lifts are useful as they teach the body to generate force quickly through triple extension, which in turn also means the body is moving in a synchronized manner (which is also important for sports)


this goes down to any exercise, or anything for that matter..if you don't have a reason to be doing something, then why are you doing it? does it relate to what you are trying to accomplish? and if something seems like it would work for what you are trying to accomplish and you aren't doing it, why don't you start?
Member
Posts: 32,685
Joined: Feb 11 2009
Gold: 603.00
Feb 4 2015 12:09am
Quote (bnrhodes2 @ Feb 3 2015 10:38pm)
so much facepalm for one thread...

but, my belief as to why they aren't in a lot of programs:
- too technical for most lifters (takes a good amount of work to completely them correctly)
- doesn't highly benefit whatever goal is being pursued
- doesn't fit smoothly into hypertrophy routines*
- doesn't fit smoothly into strength routines (specifically powerlifting)**

wall of text for a bit of my thoughts on training:


*olympic lifts were originally intended to be done in sets of lower reps, they are explosive and technical movements...with higher reps, you lose explosiveness with fatigue..with fatigue, technique begins to break down rapidly...so, getting into higher reps with any sort of load completely defeats the purpose as you can no longer completely the movement safely and also lose the explosive element (if you have to hitch the bar bar on to you stomach and flop around a bit to get it to the rack postion, your are doing it wrong - see a number of crossfit fail videos)..now, since it is done properly in lower rep sets, it isn't as much as a hypertrophy exercise as compared to something else that involves greater TUT..lastly, it works so many different muscle groups, it does not fit cleanly in to any specific day in a hypertrophy routine

**when training for powerlifting, the olympic lifts don't fit in to routines because they don't necessarily correlate directly to higher lifts in the big three..the explosiveness is always beneficial in my opinion, but the olympic lifts are very taxing if done with a high load..so, if you incorporate these in to a powerlifting routine, the energy spent on the olympic lifts would be taken from time that could have been spent better on directly improving the big 3..for example, instead of a clean for explosiveness off of the floor, work with speed deadlifts instead - the load can be higher, it is less technical, and it should translate better directly to the lift you are trying to improve..as with any type of training with a specific goal in mind, specificity of training needs to be taken into account first and foremost (with this example, would you tell an olympic lifter to run half-marathons to lift better? why or why not? would you tell a powerlifter to olympic lift to optimally increase the big 3 numbers? why or why not?)



now, if you are training for something specific and see a reason why a certain lift will benefit that training, then you should probably be doing it..for example, if you are training for most sports, olympic lifts are useful as they teach the body to generate force quickly through triple extension, which in turn also means the body is moving in a synchronized manner (which is also important for sports)


this goes down to any exercise, or anything for that matter..if you don't have a reason to be doing something, then why are you doing it? does it relate to what you are trying to accomplish? and if something seems like it would work for what you are trying to accomplish and you aren't doing it, why don't you start?


well put

tyman
Go Back To Health & Fitness Topic List
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll