d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Site Suggestions > Site Suggestions Archive >
Poll > A Way To See Reputation/transactions > Rep System
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 16,589
Joined: Jul 15 2006
Gold: Locked
Jul 27 2012 06:59am
right now we have no idea besides post count / fg / join date how trustworthy a non rated trader is

everytime gold is send out / received feedback can be given/received for each transaction

Im sure something like this has been suggested and rejected but i thought id post it anyways

It's just a pain sometimes when 2009-2012 are cautious to trade with a user like myself whos been around for years and has many many transactions and gold in/out

just a thought to make trading safer

can have a minimum transaction for rep to be left/etc and one feedback/rep per user per transaction with a limit on how much feedback can be left by one user regardless of transaction
so meds will only deal with the gigantic trades.

This post was edited by Chrism2 on Jul 27 2012 07:27am
Member
Posts: 6,813
Joined: Jul 21 2008
Gold: 4.01
Jul 27 2012 07:01am
well people can just use this to "farm" rep, so its pretty unsafe IMO
Member
Posts: 16,589
Joined: Jul 15 2006
Gold: Locked
Jul 27 2012 07:02am
Quote (Rimi @ Jul 27 2012 01:01pm)
well people can just use this to "farm" rep, so its pretty unsafe IMO


people cant if they put restrictions in place
join date/number of reps given.. im gonna repost this as a poll

and by repost i mean attach

edit: and you could only leave rep on transactions over a certain size

This post was edited by Chrism2 on Jul 27 2012 07:05am
Member
Posts: 72,807
Joined: Apr 11 2007
Gold: 0.00
Trader: Trusted
Jul 27 2012 07:36am
http://forums.d2jsp.org/info.php?p=11

Wait and be safe.

I have turned away trades because someone wants to go first and not wait for a med.

Nothing to be ashamed of.
Member
Posts: 16,589
Joined: Jul 15 2006
Gold: Locked
Jul 27 2012 07:45am
Quote (Djsem @ Jul 27 2012 01:36pm)
http://forums.d2jsp.org/info.php?p=11

Wait and be safe.

I have turned away trades because someone wants to go first and not wait for a med.

Nothing to be ashamed of.


if it didnt take 30mins + i would not everyone has time to sit around and wait

another system to vet players is useful especially when there's so few mediators and trusteds
Member
Posts: 13,356
Joined: Jul 9 2011
Gold: 1,700.43
Jul 27 2012 07:55am
Quote (Chrism2 @ Jul 27 2012 09:02am)
people cant if they put restrictions in place
join date/number of reps given.. im gonna repost this as a poll

and by repost i mean attach

edit: and you could only leave rep on transactions over a certain size


The problem with this is basically the same as here: http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=63985597&f=258&p=427283344
- People would 'spoof' transactions by sending large amounts of fg around in a circle to their friends, and in between, then +rep'ing each other. There isn't time for each user's gold logs to be monitored.
Member
Posts: 6,813
Joined: Jul 21 2008
Gold: 4.01
Jul 27 2012 07:58am
Quote (RaveTheGo @ 27 Jul 2012 14:55)
The problem with this is basically the same as here: http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=63985597&f=258&p=427283344
- People would 'spoof' transactions by sending large amounts of fg around in a circle to their friends, and in between, then +rep'ing each other.  There isn't time for each user's gold logs to be monitored.


i meant this by farming rep :o
Member
Posts: 43,883
Joined: Nov 24 2005
Gold: 8,270.00
Jul 27 2012 07:58am
No, and here's why.

1 - Trolls will go around down-rating people and ruining reputation
2 - This will spoil the corrupt and illogical way that people get promoted on D2JSP
Member
Posts: 16,589
Joined: Jul 15 2006
Gold: Locked
Jul 30 2012 07:13am
Quote (bob(Cs2) @ Jul 27 2012 01:58pm)
No, and here's why.

1 - Trolls will go around down-rating people and ruining reputation
2 - This will spoil the corrupt and illogical way that people get promoted on D2JSP


it would have to be after a transaction so you couldnt go around giving a bad rating on a whim
Member
Posts: 96,846
Joined: May 1 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jul 30 2012 02:59pm
No, just use a mediator if you feel uncomfortable trading with someone

Trust is earned through the person, regardless of their tag (or rep in your case)
Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List
Closed New Topic New Poll