d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Site Suggestions > Site Suggestions Archive >
Poll > Suggestion Not To Close Discussion Threads?
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 11,220
Joined: Jan 23 2010
Gold: 2,246.76
Jun 27 2010 12:12pm
I do believe it's pretty ridiculous to close a thread in a Site Suggestion subforum that fast.

I seriously wanted to discuss this rush-topic to find a better solution than there is right now. I'm not saying the Event Section has to disappear or anything... I just would like to have a better solution than right now, because many ppl desperately try to find a rush-service and there is no reasonable way to provide good rushers there THE WAY IT IS RIGHT NOW - im not against it! I just wanna find a better solutions for rushers (only).


yeah i know this is gonna be closed soon, i just like the irony of it

This post was edited by theFan on Jun 27 2010 12:13pm
Member
Posts: 23,396
Joined: Aug 8 2006
Gold: 559.34
Jun 27 2010 12:20pm
Quote (theFan @ Jun 27 2010 11:12am)
I do believe it's pretty ridiculous to close a thread in a Site Suggestion subforum that fast.

I seriously wanted to discuss this rush-topic to find a better solution than there is right now. I'm not saying the Event Section has to disappear or anything... I just would like to have a better solution than right now, because many ppl desperately try to find a rush-service and there is no reasonable way to provide good rushers there THE WAY IT IS RIGHT NOW - im not against it! I just wanna find a better solutions for rushers (only).


yeah i know this is gonna be closed soon, i just like the irony of it


yea they do this.. they have closed a few topics ive brought up about the report button. Anything that makes them look bad (wheather they where involved or not) they rush to close it with a half-assed repsone that really doesnt do anything.

The response i got to asking about the report button and using it in your own topics getting your topic closed. (IE- report sum1 so mods close your topic and tell you to repost later).. couldnt quate it so i just copy'd it.

IceburnReport Post Top #6 Jun 27 2010 06:16am
Group: Members++
Posts: 13,490
Joined: Apr 29 2006
Gold: 52,670.70
Trader: Mediator
Guild: Ancients
Warn: 0%

I can assure you all violations are taken care of appropriately.
If you have an issue with why your thread was closed, please pm the appropriate moderator of your section

List of Trade Moderators (For trading grounds)
List of Junior Moderators (For most things non-trading related)

.. sadly no they arnt.. they close the topic and go on.. cant tell me they PM everyone and tell them not to spam every time.. they just dont do it.. (moderators have confirmed their own lazyness to me in private.)



Watch this will be closed shortly. :P


Quote (Komets @ Jun 27 2010 11:20am)
If something isn't going to happen there is no reason to discuss it.

No [x]


this attiude is why nothing gets done.. if everyone just said screw my events and refused to use it.. i bet it would go away :P

This post was edited by Grimdayz on Jun 27 2010 12:22pm
Member
Posts: 1,597
Joined: Mar 25 2010
Gold: 0.01
Jun 27 2010 12:20pm
If something isn't going to happen there is no reason to discuss it.

No [x]
Member
Posts: 11,220
Joined: Jan 23 2010
Gold: 2,246.76
Jun 27 2010 12:33pm
Quote (Komets @ Jun 27 2010 07:20pm)
If something isn't going to happen there is no reason to discuss it.

No [x]


this is ridiculous as well.... this means u doesnt even give it a chance to change


@Grimdayz, someone understands me - thx

the weird thing is, we will never get enough attention to be able to change this fact neither...



so smarter than closing this topic is just to let it die naturally which it will unforunately sooner than later

This post was edited by theFan on Jun 27 2010 12:35pm
Member
Posts: 23,396
Joined: Aug 8 2006
Gold: 559.34
Jun 27 2010 12:38pm
Quote (theFan @ Jun 27 2010 11:33am)
this is ridiculous as well.... this means u doesnt even give it a chance to change


@Grimdayz, someone understands me - thx

the weird thing is, we will never get enough attention to be able to change this fact neither...


you might be suprized. There was good times on jsp.. once there was truly honest hard working mods(there still are some), and i understand diablo has had a decline, thus the diablo based site has declined. But there are die hards still here.

TBH as far as the my events goes, i refuse to use it, 100% refuse, i work around it and get my work done, ive also made a small name for myself as a good rusher so that helps.

Dont give up though, stick by your cause, they do try to update and change things, last time i spoke with paul they had some new things they where going to try (havnt seen or heard of it since) but there is always up to change for the better. We may not always be correct as well and need to listen to both sides of the dissucion.




This post was edited by Grimdayz on Jun 27 2010 12:42pm
Member
Posts: 36,120
Joined: Apr 2 2006
Gold: 208,274.67
Jun 27 2010 12:42pm
The suggestion forum is not the correct place for discussions.

A good suggestion should contain:
-A topic title + a description.
-Clear explanation about the idea.
-Arguments, why the suggestion is useful.
-A poll where members can vote on the suggestion
-Pictures (not possible in all cases of course). It's not a must, although it might help in understanding the suggestion.

Find a feasable and proper solution for the 'problem' and follow the above wordings to post your suggestion.
Member
Posts: 23,396
Joined: Aug 8 2006
Gold: 559.34
Jun 27 2010 12:44pm
Quote (eekzie @ Jun 27 2010 11:42am)
The suggestion forum is not the correct place for discussions.

A good suggestion should contain:
-A topic title + a description.
-Clear explanation about the idea.
-Arguments, why the suggestion is useful.
-A poll where members can vote on the suggestion
-Pictures (not possible in all cases of course). It's not a must, although it might help in understanding the suggestion.

Find a feasable and proper solution for the 'problem' and follow the above wordings to post your suggestion.



http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=45431499&f=258

the first topic he posted.. seems to match this purty well...

the anweser the mod gave was childish IMO.


seems like a pissy mod forced him into make this topic.. witch is a disscusion topic now.

the orginal topic was a clear yes or no question with reasonable explaintion of the situation and a just fix for the problem.

This post was edited by Grimdayz on Jun 27 2010 12:46pm
Member
Posts: 36,120
Joined: Apr 2 2006
Gold: 208,274.67
Jun 27 2010 12:45pm
Quote (Grimdayz @ 27 Jun 2010 20:44)
http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=45431499&f=258

the first topic he posted.. seems to match this purty well...

the anweser the mod gave was childish IMO.


It was pretty clear that the suggestion has been shot down, try something better next time :)
Member
Posts: 23,396
Joined: Aug 8 2006
Gold: 559.34
Jun 27 2010 12:46pm
Quote (eekzie @ Jun 27 2010 11:45am)
It was pretty clear that the suggestion has been shot down, try something better next time :)


seems like another lame excuse.


Not everyone is a puzzle solver.. or a problem fixer.. some people are just good honest people trying to provide services to people and seemingly got screwed over by the implment of the My Events. His question was simple and clear.. now maybe sombody would have come by and seen his post, had a wonderfull inspiration and fixed the whole problem in one post... just never know. Guess now we wont ever know. Unless they see this topic... thats unclear off topic and basicly spam.

This post was edited by Grimdayz on Jun 27 2010 12:49pm
Member
Posts: 11,220
Joined: Jan 23 2010
Gold: 2,246.76
Jun 27 2010 01:00pm
Grimdayz - that maybe sounds gay, but you enlightened my day lol

you really got me!

and yeah i had many guys who vouched for me already and was really surprised - i didnt ask anybody to vouch for me @ anytime but got sometimes 5 vouches from different ppl in one of my grush threads and that is somehow amazing imho

can you pm me more information about the things they were going to try? thx! i will think about creating a better thread (not so soon though) about rushers for this subforum



for this topic: i think closing threads is pretty senseless here, if a thread is crap, he will get faded away automatically soon enough
Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll