d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Site Suggestions > Site Suggestions Archive >
Poll > Harsher Actions Against Signature Rippers
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 32,538
Joined: Dec 6 2007
Gold: 1,945.00
Jan 5 2010 06:07pm
Theres currently no one in place in the graphics forum with the time to take care of people that rip (steal) artwork.

It gets taken care of if the user is stealing something from someone within d2jsp, but there arent any rules about stealing from other sites.

But in my opinion, if someone on here is charging fg for a signature that was made for someone on another site, doesnt that qualify as scamming as well? Youre paying for a service that wasnt done by that person.

Here is another users take on it, after much discussion about a ripper on this site that had literally over 60 signatures for sale that he had stolen from various sites:

Quote from user:

http://forums.d2jsp.org/user.php?i=327291


"Originally this came up because I noticed how active Motheroftwo is in the photography section - involved, and part of the community. I am part of the Graphic Design section, and I think it would be really nice to have an active mediator there as well. I haven't seen anyone with a TT or Mod posting there since Mork back in 07 (sorry if I got the date wrong, this is what I remember)
The reason that I think having someone who is active around is important is because we run into a lot of ripping/art theft/copyright issues there in Graphic Design, and they generally go unnoticed unless someone who's been around there for awhile happens to notice it. But then, when these things are reported, it's difficult for those in charge to find the evidence against that person accused of art theft without having been around in graphic design forums here at JSP and elsewhere to notice where the object was stolen from."

I feel if you can provide plenty of proof that the person stole the artwork from somewhere, that there should be the same consequences that would happen if they had stolen from within this site (i.e. locked, warned etc).

This goes for people that make changes to artwork, like taking watermarks off of things for people, or changing the name on a signature that they dont have rights to.
Member
Posts: 7,635
Joined: Mar 14 2004
Gold: 215.00
Jan 5 2010 06:13pm
I agree with you. I feel this is just as bad as scamming someone on d2. I check the graphic section daily and know what you mean.

(Did triss give you permission to post that?) lol

Member
Posts: 32,538
Joined: Dec 6 2007
Gold: 1,945.00
Jan 5 2010 06:16pm
Quote (hollenhoe @ Jan 5 2010 07:13pm)
I agree with you. I feel this is just as bad as scamming someone on d2. I check the graphic section daily and know what you mean.

(Did triss give you permission to post that?) lol


Yes, we exchanged a lot of pms regarding the matter.



Thanks for the votes everyone ^^
Member
Posts: 13,788
Joined: Jun 14 2006
Gold: 11.00
Jan 5 2010 06:53pm
+ Most of us get like 250+ Fg's each signature.. That's way more than the average scam :/ ...

So ripping is just as bad as scamming if not worse...
Member
Posts: 32,538
Joined: Dec 6 2007
Gold: 1,945.00
Jan 5 2010 11:08pm
Quote (Mag1z @ Jan 5 2010 07:53pm)
+ Most of us get like 250+ Fg's each signature.. That's way more than the average scam :/ ...

So ripping is just as bad as scamming if not worse...


Nice way of looking at it, I know theres been times where Ive gotten 400-500, and all the services like Soufortes make 400 per every time.

Ive seen people locked because of scamming a few runes worth like 10 xD

Thanks ^^

E: Prime example of a ripper that Ive been trying to get locked since October:


http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=38658306&f=111&o=0

This post was edited by Xandriia on Jan 5 2010 11:15pm
Member
Posts: 6,702
Joined: Sep 23 2007
Gold: 32,469.95
Jan 5 2010 11:16pm
yeaaaaaa
Member
Posts: 4,482
Joined: Apr 10 2007
Gold: 1,389.00
Jan 5 2010 11:27pm
Yeah, definitely. I have talked with some people about how it is around here regarding stolen artwork, and basically it comes down to: If it's not used on the site/made on the site, nothing can be done about it. But, people in the graphic section generally can't stand art theft and a lot of us are able to identify stolen stuff because we have seen it from other sites/tutorials etc. So we know a rip when we see it and can definitely provide the proof needed to mods to show that.
But, we get a lot of people posting stolen work from places like Deviantart, or other forum signature graphic related sites. It's really a bummer that nothing is done about it :\
Member
Posts: 57,889
Joined: May 23 2007
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2010 11:38pm
Quote (Xandriia @ 6 Jan 2010 14:08)
E: Prime example of a ripper that Ive been trying to get locked since October:

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=38658306&f=111&o=0


lol wtf?
he's selling mass amounts of stolen artwork?
Member
Posts: 32,538
Joined: Dec 6 2007
Gold: 1,945.00
Jan 5 2010 11:39pm
Quote (Trisstrae @ Jan 6 2010 12:27am)
Yeah, definitely. I have talked with some people about how it is around here regarding stolen artwork, and basically it comes down to: If it's not used on the site/made on the site, nothing can be done about it. But, people in the graphic section generally can't stand art theft and a lot of us are able to identify stolen stuff because we have seen it from other sites/tutorials etc. So we know a rip when we see it and can definitely provide the proof needed to mods to show that.
But, we get a lot of people posting stolen work from places like Deviantart, or other forum signature graphic related sites. It's really a bummer that nothing is done about it :\


Thanks for clarifying Trisstrae, that might help the people that arent really involved with the graphics forum understand ^_^

Quote (Greapper @ Jan 6 2010 12:38am)
lol wtf?
he's selling mass amounts of  stolen artwork?


Yep.

I made a ripper accusation a long time ago, and he ended up removing the pictures, but he still posts them in threads.


This post was edited by Xandriia on Jan 5 2010 11:39pm
Member
Posts: 36,137
Joined: Jun 17 2007
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2010 11:45pm
Quote (Xandriia @ Jan 5 2010 09:39pm)
Thanks for clarifying Trisstrae, that might help the people that arent really involved with the graphics forum understand ^_^



Yep.

I made a ripper accusation a long time ago, and he ended up removing the pictures, but he still posts them in threads.


Gather up the threads, send them to an available Junior Mods.?
http://forums.d2jsp.org/staff.php?g=20
Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll