d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Site Suggestions > Site Suggestions Archive >
Poll > Better Trade Security!
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 10,252
Joined: Nov 25 2009
Gold: 578.20
Dec 25 2009 04:26pm
Okay, alot of people still get scammed, and it must be a huge job for the meds and all the other people takeing care of that matters.
So in this thread: http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=38324851&f=258
But as people say, it might be alittle complicated system, and might be abused.

Then I tought of a system, they use on another site, called xboxlife.dk
And it's pretty simple, and I think it might work well.
There is something called ''Handelskarakterer'' looks like this: Handelskarakterer: 1 total, 1 good, 0 bad
Since I only traded with someone else 1 time before I only got 1. But the guy I was buying something from, looks like this: Handelskarakterer: 500 i alt, 500 good, 0 bad
And this guy is obviously pretty trusted.
So if we could have the same system, people who did something bad, scammed or what ever, would have +1 bad, and the guy who gave him that could leave a comment what he did.

It's all up to you guys, but it works like a charm on that site, and I'm sure it will on this aswell, and make the job alot more easy for meds and other people :).

Member
Posts: 18,156
Joined: Jan 26 2006
Gold: 4,079.61
Trader: Trusted
Dec 25 2009 04:28pm
Again what is going to prevent multi accounters from abusing this or people from doing fake/bribes to get "ratings/points/trust"

Member
Posts: 16,959
Joined: Feb 25 2006
Gold: 1,250.00
Dec 25 2009 04:29pm
Quote (BkK @ 25 Dec 2009 17:28)
Again what is going to prevent multi accounters from abusing this or people from doing fake/bribes to get "ratings/points/trust"


agreeded.
Member
Posts: 4,625
Joined: Jul 14 2006
Gold: 4,799.00
Dec 25 2009 04:29pm
voted no this can be abused also with multi acc's ect
Member
Posts: 70,577
Joined: Dec 17 2005
Gold: 9,004.00
Dec 25 2009 04:30pm
I doubt that site revolves around some forumgold currency.

Voting no and already posted the reason in that other thread.
Member
Posts: 10,252
Joined: Nov 25 2009
Gold: 578.20
Dec 25 2009 04:34pm
How can this be abbused?
I forgot to say, on the site, you have to give a reason why the guy should have +1 good or +1 bad, so people can't just give him a +1 bad, but they must give a reason why? If the guy who got +1 bad, dosen't think he deserved it, he could like the warn, requets it to be removed or what ever.

edit: This would also show if the person you trade with, got any experience in tradeing before, so his not just a random guy, it shows how many +good trades he had

and to give a +good or +bad you would have to leave a message why you did so, this would prevent abbuseing I think.

This post was edited by mmn91 on Dec 25 2009 04:39pm
Member
Posts: 18,156
Joined: Jan 26 2006
Gold: 4,079.61
Trader: Trusted
Dec 25 2009 04:38pm
Fake trades.

I pay you 10fg to +1 me

Thread: shako for 10fg you buy it, i get +1 increase and you get the 10fg that was intended to get me my +1 rank

Multi's: Obvious reasons? They get 10 accounts, use a main one, make a thread with a "Ft list" such as 9x rals ft, the other 9 multis bin the rals the main one gets +9 to rank

Member
Posts: 22,605
Joined: Sep 23 2007
Gold: 1.01
Warn: 40%
Dec 25 2009 04:38pm
Quote (mmn91 @ 25 Dec 2009 23:34)
How can this be abbused?
I forgot to say, on the site, you have to give a reason why the guy should have +1 good or +1 bad, so people can't just give him a +1 bad, but they must give a reason why? If the guy who got +1 bad, dosen't think he deserved it, he could like the warn, requets it to be removed or what ever.


all the requests for removals of bad ratings would require the work of the entire mod team...
this would not work.

use a mediator for your trades.
a secure trade should be worth some minutes.
Member
Posts: 10,252
Joined: Nov 25 2009
Gold: 578.20
Dec 25 2009 04:40pm
Quote (BkK @ Dec 25 2009 11:38pm)
Fake trades.

I pay you 10fg to +1 me

Thread: shako for 10fg you buy it, i get +1 increase and you get the 10fg that was intended to get me my +1 rank

Multi's: Obvious reasons? They get 10 accounts, use a main one, make a thread with a "Ft list" such as 9x rals ft, the other 9 multis bin the rals the main one gets +9 to rank


yeah well, i'm sure we could work something out, I mean...
Member
Posts: 10,252
Joined: Nov 25 2009
Gold: 578.20
Dec 25 2009 05:13pm
Quote (tcl @ Dec 25 2009 11:38pm)
all the requests for removals of bad ratings would require the work of the entire mod team...
this would not work.

use a mediator for your trades.
a secure trade should be worth some minutes.


Yeah but you can't use a med for every small trade, that would requite too much work for you guys.

But I just dont see how this can be abused, you have the leave a comment, so if someone abuse the system, by giveing someone bad ratings, you know who did it.
Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll