d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Site Suggestions > Site Suggestions Archive >
Poll > Guild Bank! > Managel The Guilds Forum Gold
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 24,758
Joined: May 5 2006
Gold: 1,534.72
Aug 26 2009 03:25pm
The Guild Bank!

Well im sure that its not only our guild that has one in the guild holding some fg for the guild donated by members.

In our guild we spend "the guild fg" on D2 classic rush sorc, new member slots, own ranks, guild tournaments, rewards etc...

But here is the problem and what i suggest can be done to fix this.

There is only one that has access to "the guild fg" so if he/she is not on you cant get access to the guild fg until he/she is back on.

Manageing your own fg+the guilds can be hard for some, if they trade alot them self and lose count on whats the guilds and your own.

The guild owner can, manage who can have access to the guilds fg. as i have made an example of on the picture under.




All can send a donation to the guild bank and see how much fg the guild has in its bank from time to time+check the guild log to see what it has been spent on.





Other things that could be changed/added:


only guild members can see the guilds fg.

The fg spent will be showed on the guild log/so will donations.

Donations from each member will stand next to there name on "Edit Member Ranks"

Maybe a "vote" where it has to be over 51% of the votes (from members that have access to manage guild bank)

meaning. so not one member has "veto" on the fg. must be 2/3 etc to "unlock/spend" the fg.

could be something like the picture under, where members have to get the request accepted by over 50% of the "bankers"

Requestion fg for something as shown on the picture under.




Member
Posts: 57,889
Joined: May 23 2007
Gold: 0.00
Aug 26 2009 03:30pm
Nice idea,
but I forsee problems with an angry guild member (that has access to the guild fg) scamming the fg.
Member
Posts: 24,758
Joined: May 5 2006
Gold: 1,534.72
Aug 26 2009 03:31pm
Quote (Greapper @ Wed, 26 Aug 2009, 22:30)
Nice idea,
but I forsee problems with an angry guild member (that has access to the guild fg) scamming the fg.


he cant do this cuz you need more then one member to accept the use of the guild fg. read the rest :p
Member
Posts: 5,487
Joined: Jan 12 2007
Gold: 3,000.00
Aug 26 2009 03:31pm
Further issues would arise as this could be a way to launder scammed fg...

edit: very nicely laid out presentation though. :D

This post was edited by optipvp on Aug 26 2009 03:32pm
Member
Posts: 8,126
Joined: May 20 2009
Gold: 170.00
Aug 26 2009 03:37pm
[x] yes i like it. maybe a gold password too incase a member gets keylogged. and well yeah problems with angry members and such.. but if it takes approval then it should be fine.

/e add a poll. i've said yes.

This post was edited by archangelxo on Aug 26 2009 03:37pm
Member
Posts: 32,143
Joined: Oct 29 2005
Gold: 100.00
Aug 26 2009 03:43pm
By far the best idea I'v seen in the suggestion forum in a while.

Quote (Greapper @ Wed, Aug 26 2009, 09:30pm)
Nice idea,
but I forsee problems with an angry guild member (that has access to the guild fg) scamming the fg.


you should not give people you dont trust the power to manage the guild. that being said, ofcourse this might cause problems. but about as much problems as angry guildmembers kicking all members. which doesnt happen very often I beleve.

Quote (optipvp @ Wed, Aug 26 2009, 09:31pm)
Further issues would arise as this could be a way to launder scammed fg...

edit: very nicely laid out presentation though. :D


I think this can be prevented. its should be quite easy to freeze such a "bank account"




but ye, security would probably be the biggest issue.

This post was edited by Hellskin on Aug 26 2009 03:44pm
Member
Posts: 24,758
Joined: May 5 2006
Gold: 1,534.72
Aug 26 2009 03:45pm
Quote (archangelxo @ Wed, 26 Aug 2009, 22:37)
[x] yes i like it. maybe a gold password too incase a member gets keylogged. and well yeah problems with angry members and such.. but if it takes approval then it should be fine.

/e add a poll. i've said yes.


pole has been added^^


Quote (Hellskin @ Wed, 26 Aug 2009, 22:43)
By far the best idea I'v seen in the suggestion forum in a while.



you should not give people you dont trust the power to manage the guild. that being said, ofcourse this might cause problems. but about as much problems as angry guildmembers kicking all members. which doesnt happen very often I beleve.



I think this can be prevented. its should be quite easy to freeze such a "bank account"


thx for for the support Dennis. spread the word :P
Member
Posts: 20,726
Joined: Jan 2 2007
Gold: 94,877.84
Aug 26 2009 03:52pm
i just voted yes cause of the presentation
i actually dotn think it would work well lol
i am the guild bank :)
Member
Posts: 62,491
Joined: Dec 28 2006
Gold: 11,225.00
Aug 26 2009 03:56pm
suggested, pending since '07 here :)
Member
Posts: 24,758
Joined: May 5 2006
Gold: 1,534.72
Aug 26 2009 04:01pm
Quote (gwyneed @ Wed, 26 Aug 2009, 22:56)
suggested, pending since '07  here :)


did not know about that, but i have added some stuff etc from what he did suggest if you read it :P
Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll