d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Site Suggestions > Site Suggestions Archive > Much Like eebay > This Has Probably Been Brought Up
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 10,390
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 55.00
Apr 16 2009 01:47pm
Why not have a trader % rate...

Like 1 vote +
1 vote -

So you can see how these people trade before s/a gets filled up :/
Member
Posts: 35,221
Joined: Dec 25 2007
Gold: 0.00
Apr 16 2009 01:48pm
No
Will be abused a crap load.
Member
Posts: 37,085
Joined: Oct 24 2007
Gold: 1,201.66
Apr 16 2009 01:48pm
The potential for abuse is way too high. This will never happen :( sorry.
Member
Posts: 10,390
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 55.00
Apr 16 2009 01:50pm
Yea i thought of that, mabey if the person had to approve your comment before hand... oh well,

at least it wasnt a random suggestion :(
Member
Posts: 16,828
Joined: Dec 28 2005
Gold: 4.20
Apr 16 2009 01:52pm
Quote (xVanished @ Thu, Apr 16 2009, 08:48pm)
No
Will be abused a crap load.


Like in eebay or alegro...
Member
Posts: 10,390
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 55.00
Apr 16 2009 01:54pm
A button is added from person A. to click accepting the bin.

Then and only then will person B. allowed to be able to leave a comment.
Member
Posts: 23,616
Joined: Jan 30 2006
Gold: 7,405.52
Apr 16 2009 02:56pm
I would vote no,

Not needed and would be abused.

There are ways to tell if someone has generally good intentions or not, this rating would be more inacurate then the current ways of finding out if someone is good or not.
Member
Posts: 37,126
Joined: Nov 6 2006
Gold: 9,221.15
Apr 16 2009 03:02pm
Quote (wassabi-69 @ Thu, 16 Apr 2009, 22:56)
I would vote no,

Not needed and would be abused.

There are ways to tell if someone has generally good intentions or not, this rating would be more inacurate then the current ways of finding out if someone is good or not.


And what would those be?

Posts mean nothing, joindate means nothing, FG means nothing. ( If they use Paypal reversal they are spending FG that shouldn't be there)
Only 'the tag' matters, but that tag is very rare.


Anyhow, I also don't think a 'Trusted Trader Rating' should be implemented. (Abuse, multi's, friends etc.)

This post was edited by uNoTopia on Apr 16 2009 03:12pm
Member
Posts: 23,616
Joined: Jan 30 2006
Gold: 7,405.52
Apr 16 2009 03:07pm
Quote (uNoTopia @ Thu, Apr 16 2009, 03:02pm)
And that would those be?

Posts mean nothing, joindate means nothing, FG means nothing. ( If they use Paypal reversal they are spending FG that shouldn't be there)
Only 'the tag' matters, but that tag is very rare.


Anyhow, I also don't think a 'Trusted Trader Rating' should be implemented. (Abuse, multi's, friends etc.)


What I do is save the user under my favorites.

- View there last posts
- Search posts
- Conversation
- Perhaps their profile also gives you clues towards their integrity and personality.

There is no 100% sure way to know but there are clues.

edit : The ways above I listed are much more acurate than simply looking at ( ex.14892 thumbs up 243 thumbs down )

This post was edited by wassabi-69 on Apr 16 2009 03:09pm
Member
Posts: 25,374
Joined: Feb 22 2007
Gold: 266.00
Apr 16 2009 03:23pm
Quote (Hydr8 @ Thu, Apr 16 2009, 02:47pm)
Why not have a trader % rate...

Like 1 vote +
1 vote -

So you can see how these people trade before s/a gets filled up :/


Ive suggested this before, on the Karma lvl.
You can rate Karma +1, Karma -1, each user is aloud 1 vote per person.
Reason it was rejected, was that ppl can make multis to ruin someones rep.
Meh.
My responce to that, was to have the user able to make his karma viewable or not.
Say I have good karma, then I would make it viewable, so ppl know ppl like me, and if my karma got raped by some random, I would just make it un-viewable.
Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll