d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Site Suggestions > Site Suggestions Archive >
Poll > Guild Suggestions > 5 In 1
12317Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 71,157
Joined: Aug 14 2006
Gold: 6,440.13
Oct 8 2008 09:23am
Some of the these have been already suggested, others haven't, but it cant hurt to list them all at once. I will keep bumping this topic till I get a response from Paul so go ahead and vote now mad.gif

First I list the ideas, then give a little explanation for all of them:

1. Being able to edit guild members all at once
2. More than 50 ranks
3. To be able to make ranks visible even if there is noone in that group
4. Notification upon new post in the guild notebox
(bold the My guild link forexample, just like its already implemented with topic titles)
5. Youtube link into the guild charter

Explanations:

1. Being able to edit guild members all at once just like we can with the friendlist. When buying a new rank, it is really a pain in the ass to edit everyone. The bigger the guild the more time it consumes and you will get the guild log flooded with separate logs. Insted of these individual events we could have just a single log: "edited member(s): ...." per each "editing session".

2. Pretty much self-explanatory. Eternity is already approaching its limits, why not make it available to buy more ranks? Personally I dont care much about this, since Im currently pretty far away from having 50 ranks in my guild, but still a decent idea imo.

3. At first this can sound a bit strange.



But lets say you have a guild named "Parliament of England" where guild members are required to buy their own ranks. You could then separate them to House of Lords and House of Commons. Those ranks would have noone in them, but it would still appear in the guild list separating the members. You could do this with a "World War II guild" (separating Germany, England, USA, etc...) Busido guild (village people, members of the tea house, fighters, priests, rulers etc) and there are a lot of guild themes that would benefit from such option.
Also if the last person of a rank leaves your guild than it will no longer be visible for others to see, but it the rank in itself still looks cool.

4. Already suggested a lot of times, even by me. It would still be very useful imo, since it makes interaction much much faster. I can forget to check those posts for days till the content of the message "expires".

5. Just like its enabled in the profiles (for fg). I - for example - could use one: japanese drumms music or some documentary about samurais, etc...
Member
Posts: 29,340
Joined: Oct 4 2005
Gold: 4.20
Oct 8 2008 09:43am
all of them heart.gif
Member
Posts: 37,085
Joined: Oct 24 2007
Gold: 1,201.66
Oct 8 2008 11:53am
I've heard a few of them before, but all of them sound great and sensible and I can't see any problem with it wink.gif

Voted for all
Member
Posts: 42,999
Joined: Jul 16 2006
Gold: 1.00
Oct 8 2008 01:49pm
i like this

all of them
Retired Moderator
Posts: 27,588
Joined: Jul 5 2005
Gold: 505.00
Trader: Trusted
Oct 8 2008 01:58pm
1. Being able to edit guild members all at once I like this one
2. More than 50 ranks I'm neutral on this one, but I might use it if it were added
3. To be able to make ranks visible even if there is noone in that group I'm not for this one
4. Notification upon new post in the guild notebox (bold the My guild link forexample, just like its already implemented with topic titles) Not sure this is really needed.
5. Youtube link into the guild charter Not a fan of this one, either. Some people would likely post irrelevant junk.

1. yes 2. neutral 3. no 4. no 5. no
Member
Posts: 17,002
Joined: Apr 10 2007
Gold: 3.66
Oct 8 2008 02:58pm
@ of them
Member
Posts: 71,157
Joined: Aug 14 2006
Gold: 6,440.13
Oct 9 2008 03:40am
Thanks everyone for the votes

Quote (RewtheBrave @ Wed, Oct 8 2008, 08:58pm)
1. Being able to edit guild members all at once I like this one
2. More than 50 ranks I'm neutral on this one, but I might use it if it were added
3. To be able to make ranks visible even if there is noone in that group I'm not for this one
4. Notification upon new post in the guild notebox (bold the My guild link forexample, just like its already implemented with topic titles) Not sure this is really needed.
5. Youtube link into the guild charter Not a fan of this one, either. Some people would likely post irrelevant junk.

1. yes 2. neutral 3. no 4. no 5. no


4. Well I always forget to check it :\ and we dont have a guild forum, pming every member would be waste of time so this is pretty much the best option we have to interact. Sure we could just chat in a guild topic, but what is the point of guild notebox than?

5. Why would guilds pay for an embended youtube slot if they are only going to post irrelevant junk? I mean we have this feature enable in the profiles, why not in the guild charter also?
Member
Posts: 71,157
Joined: Aug 14 2006
Gold: 6,440.13
Oct 11 2008 07:41am
bump
Member
Posts: 71,157
Joined: Aug 14 2006
Gold: 6,440.13
Oct 12 2008 02:49am
bump
Member
Posts: 71,157
Joined: Aug 14 2006
Gold: 6,440.13
Oct 14 2008 04:39am
bump
Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List
12317Next
Closed New Topic New Poll