d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Site Suggestions > Site Suggestions Archive > Diablo 2 Rule Change
Prev1345
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 47,392
Joined: Aug 31 2009
Gold: Locked
Warn: 60%
Jun 23 2011 12:18pm
Quote (DoomOnYou @ Jun 23 2011 11:15am)
it is essentially something where you "buy in" (by buying the anni) and hope you win. It falls under the same category and it is not and will not be allowed.


do you not "buy in" hoping to win when u buy any unid item?
ive asked this question multiple times and there is honostly no difference by deffinition of gambling and buying unid items

This post was edited by jce on Jun 23 2011 12:19pm
Retired Moderator
Posts: 48,115
Joined: Apr 27 2007
Gold: 31,374.06
Trader: Trusted
Jun 23 2011 12:19pm
Quote (zell1luk @ Jun 23 2011 02:16pm)
Well thats specific. Now you are contradicting what the other mod said, so this show there is no logical reasoning behind why this is an illegal trade.
/e You still never answered my question in post #34.


really? He said it's gambling and therefore not allowed. I said it's a gamble and therefore not allowed. How exactly did we contradict each other? Please read more carefully next time.

and to your question - no, obviously. it would still be a gamble and therefore not allowed.

Quote (jce @ Jun 23 2011 02:18pm)
do you not "buy in" hoping to win when u buy any unid item?
ive asked this question multiple times and there is honostly no difference by deffinition of gambling and buying unid items


the difference is that when buying a unid item there is no reward for getting specific stats. Therefore it is not a gamble like what you are doing in your topic where the buyer gets a fg prize for getting certain stats.

This post was edited by DoomOnYou on Jun 23 2011 12:20pm
Member
Posts: 47,392
Joined: Aug 31 2009
Gold: Locked
Warn: 60%
Jun 23 2011 12:20pm
Quote (DoomOnYou @ Jun 23 2011 11:19am)
really? He said it's gambling and therefore not allowed. I said it's a gamble and therefore not allowed. How exactly did we contradict each other? Please read more carefully next time.

and to your question - no, obviously. it would still be a gamble and therefore not allowed.



the difference is that when buying a unid item there is no reward for getting specific stats. Therefore it is not a gamble like what you are doing in your topic where the buyer gets a fg prize for getting certain stats.


no they dont?

This post was edited by jce on Jun 23 2011 12:21pm
Member
Posts: 16,909
Joined: Aug 14 2009
Gold: 0.00
Jun 23 2011 12:22pm
Quote (DoomOnYou @ Jun 23 2011 01:19pm)
really?  He said it's gambling and therefore not allowed.  I said it's a gamble and therefore not allowed.  How exactly did we contradict each other?  Please read more carefully next time.

He said it's gambling due to the price difference, but nowhere does he say that if you only have the 1 option, it would be illegal.
/e And there has still not been a straight forward answer why jsp will not allow this a "trade at your own risk". weather or not jsp supports it, no one honestly cares, we just wanna trade.

This post was edited by zell1luk on Jun 23 2011 12:28pm
Member
Posts: 47,392
Joined: Aug 31 2009
Gold: Locked
Warn: 60%
Jun 23 2011 12:26pm
Quote (zell1luk @ Jun 23 2011 11:22am)
He said it's gambling due to the price difference, but nowhere does he say that if you only have the 1 option, it would be illegal.
/e And there has still not been a straight forward answer why jsp will not allow this a "trade at your own risk", weather or not jsp supports it, no one honestly cares, we just wanna trade.


had 16x clean trades this way this ladder
over 40 last ladder there is no reason this shouldnt be aloud
Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List
Prev1345
Closed New Topic New Poll