]Guild Orb - I would like this if you could customize it yourself. What if my Guild Leader wants bright purple, but it doesn't match with my current orb, signature, avatar, and board style? That would just annoy me.
So, no as it stands for the orb. Possibly if I could customize it myself, after it's purchased then I would vote yet.
Guild Icon - As long as there was a reasonable size limit, then I would vote yes to this. I would rather have the icon, than the orb, personally.
I think it would look better to just have the small Icon for your guild, rather than colors that may or may not match up.
So, no to the orb, yes to the icon.
Love the guild Orb idea. [x] Yes